CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Argyll and Bute Council
Standards Committee, Monday 25 August 2003 at 11.30am

DETERMINATION OF QUASI JUDICIAL MATTERS - PROPOSED GUIDANCE

Approved Committee 1 paper

Standards Committee approved this item on Monday 25 August 2003. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item2

Resolved

Decision 1. The Committee adopted the detail contained in the Appendix to the report by the Director of Corporate Services and recommended the terms of the Appendix as the Standards Committee’s guidance to Members of Argyll & Bute Council to supplement the guidance contained in the National Councillors’ Code. 2. To request that information on the terms of the guidance are issued to the press and in due course to Community Councils as part of the review of the scheme. (Ref: Report by Director of Corporate Services dated 11 August 2003, submitted)
Word for word from the decision Argyll and Bute published for this meeting. Source: www.argyll-bute.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Argyll and Bute's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Standards Committee

Summary

1.1Members will all be familiar with the position that in dealing with the determination of planning/licensing applications, Civic Government Hearings and Traffic Orders they are acting in a quasi judicial manner which requires them to demonstrate they are acting impartially without bias. In practice this has a number of implications for Councillors the principal of these is the need to adhere to the rules of natural justice.

Recommendation

2.1The Committee may care to adopt the detail contained in the appendix to this report and offer that as the Standards Committee’s guidance to Members of Argyll & Bute Council to supplement the guidance contained in the national Councillors’ Code.

3. CONTEXT

3.1It is appreciated that it is a very difficult matter for Members in a political context to refuse to comment on their views on a particular application to the public who have elected them. The reality, however, is that any such comments expressing an opinion will more than likely exclude the Member from the decision making process.

3.2It is a matter for all Councillors and Officials together to continue to explain to the public the need to maintain the probity of this process.

3.3It is clear from the Councillor’s Code of Conduct, more so now than ever, that the planning process, in particular, is under great public scrutiny and care must be taken to avoid a breach of the code given the sanctions available now to the Commission.

4. IMPLICATIONS

Policy None Financial None Personnel None Equal Opportunities None Legal None

NIGEL STEWART Director of Corporate & Legal Services

11 August 2003

standards comm. 25 august Appendix

1 The principles of natural justice, as evident from decisions of the court, are that the local authority must reach its decision fairly, without bias and in good faith and must give a reasonable opportunity to the parties concerned to put their case (though not necessarily in person or by representative) and may not act as a judge in its own cause.

2 If the statute under which the Authority is purporting to act lays down a procedure then that procedure must be followed but otherwise, it is not necessary for the procedure of a court of law to be followed. Any procedure which does not offend the principles of natural justice may be employed.

3 The duty on Members is that they must fairly consider the application and exercise their discretion on it fairly and not take into account any reason for their discretion which is not a legal one. If people who have to exercise a public duty by exercising their discretion take into account matters which the court consider not to be proper for the guidance of their discretion then in the eyes of the law they have not exercised their discretion

4 In general there are a number of elements to the approach which should be adopted by Councillors serving in a quasi judicial capacity. These are as follows:-

1. You should not as a general rule express a view either for or against a particular proposal which is to come before you for determination. In the event that you do so you risk the possibility that you may be regarded as acting as a judge in your own cause (auctor in rem suam). Were you to participate in the determination of such a matter on which you had given earlier opinion, this would constitute a breach of the rules of natural justice.

2. In the same way it may give the appearance of bias if you were to attend a meeting called by supporters/objectors of a planning application and express an opinion to them. In fact in many cases it would be difficult to attend a meeting at all without giving the possible appearance of bias which could be subject to challenge. This follows the principle of Audi Alterem Partem i.e hear both sides of the case.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
DETERMINATION OF QUASI JUDICIAL MATTERS: PROPOSED GUIDANCEReport 73 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting
1MINUTESOn the agenda
2DETERMINATION OF QUASI JUDICIAL MATTERS - PROPOSED GUIDANCEThis decision
3INTERM GUIDANCE ISSUED BY STANDARDS COMMISSION FOR SCOTLAND - DRAFT RESPONSEApproved

Who was there

0 of 12 attended
BC
Councillor Brian ChennellVice-Chair, expected
MS
Councillor Moyra StewartMember, expected
JB
Jillian BrownOfficer, expected
GD
Dr Gordon DoughtyChair, expected
DK
Councillor Donald KellyMember, expected
SM
Stuart MacDonaldMember, expected
DM
Councillor Donald MacMillan BEMMember, expected
JM
James McLellanOfficer, expected
CR
Charles ReppkeOfficer, expected
ER
Councillor Elaine RobertsonMember, expected
NS
Nigel StewartOfficer, expected
LS
Lynda SyedOfficer, expected

More from Argyll and Bute Standards Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
31 Jan 2007 Consultative draft guidance and dispensations note issued by the standards commission scotlandDecision 1. To note the terms of the report; 2. Agreed to forward the following comments to the Standards Commission ... Noted Open
31 Jan 2007 November 2006 reportsDecision To note the contents of the report. (Reference: Ombudsman’s Commentary dated 28 November 2006, submitted) Noted Open
31 Jan 2007 December 2006 reportsDecision To note the contents of the report. (Reference: Ombudsman’s Commentary dated 19 December 2006, submitted) Noted Open
31 Jan 2007 January reports 2007Decision To note the contents of the report. (Reference: Ombudsman’s Commentary dated 28 November 2006, tabled) Noted Open
16 Nov 2006 Scottish public services ombudsmanDecision To note the contents of the report. (Reference: Report by Director of Corporate Services dated October 2006,... Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies