CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Argyll and Bute Council
Policy Development Group, Friday 16 April 2004 at 10.30am

CONSIDER RESPONSES TO INITIAL CONSULTATION

Agreed Committee 6 papers

Policy Development Group agreed this item on Friday 16 April 2004. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item2

Resolved

Decision 1. Agreed that Douglas Trigg would be appointed to the PDG as a representative from the Association of Community Councils. 2. Agreed that the level of administrative grant, having not changed since 1996, was inadequate, but that the existing level of administrative grant remain for the purpose of the consultation and that these grant levels be reviewed by this Group at a later date. 3. Agreed to increase the number of Members to 6 where the electorate was up to 500 and to 8 where the electorate was between 501 and 2000 and to support the proposals contained within the report relating to additional Members. 4. Agreed that the normal period of life of Community Councils would be four years, and that initial elections under the new Scheme would be conducted by Argyll & Bute Council. Subsequent elections would be the responsibility of Community Councils. 5. Agreed that the consultation document be amended so that rather than automatically ‘appointing’ a candidate from another sub-area, a further by-election could be run for the sub-area, but opened up to allow those candidates who had failed to be elected in another sub-area to stand, although not otherwise qualified to do so. 6. Noted that the request for a Community Council for Easdale had been withdrawn. 7. Agreed that although sympathetic to the request that Kerrera and Hunters Quay Community Councils be retained, to continue with the consultation on the basis that these Community Council would merge with Oban Community Council and Dunoon Community Council respectively. 8. Agreed the suggestion that Benmore and Kilmun be amalgamated with Ardentinny. 9. Agreed that a section of the residents in the South Knapdale Community Council area be ‘transferred’ to the Tarbert & Skipness Community Council area. 10. Agreed that the timescale for the 2 nd Consultation Period be mid May to 16 July 2004, that proposed amendments to the draft scheme be submitted to the Strategic Policy Committee for approval on 9 September 2004 and to Council on 15 September 2004 for final approval. 11. Agreed to make the following changes to the Draft Model Constitution:- (a) Para 4.8 – Delete “Council for the” which is repeated. (b) Para 5.6, 3 rd line should read – “any such vacancy/vacancies as soon as is agreed and is practicable to the Community Council”. (c) Para 5.6 – Six months to be amended to “one year” (d) Para 6.1 – Community Councils should meet on a minimum of 4 occasions, including the AGM, each year. (e) Para 6.2 – Amend to the AGM will be held by 30 June each year. (f) Para 8.4 – Delete Paragraph (g) Para 9.2 – The bank account must be in the name of the Community Council. (h) Para 9.3 – Delete the word “other”. (i) Para 11.1 – Delete “on the grounds of expense or otherwise”. (j) Para 11.3 – Delete existing paragraph and insert “If resolution to dissolve is carried by a majority those present and voting, that will become the final decision of the Community Council”. 11. Agreed to amend the Code of Practice as follows:- (a) Para 3.4 – Should stipulate that the Community Council must provide both a copy of the minutes and agenda of each meeting. (b) Para 5 – Community Councillors should follow the Councillors’ Code of Conduct issued by the Standards Commission for Scotland and any subsequent amendments or revisions to this code. 12. Agreed to issue the Model Standing Orders as part of the 2 nd phase of the consultation process and that the Code of Practice should not form part of this process. 13. Agreed that the Helensburgh Council Wards contained within the report should be amended as they were incorrect. 14. Agreed that this meeting now adjourn until 10am on Wednesday 28 April 2004 to allow the Area Corporate Services Manager time to make the necessary adjustments to the documentation in order that these could be signed off prior to the next phase of the consultation. (Reference: Report by Area Corporate Services Manager dated 24 March 2004, submitted) The meeting re-convened on 28 April 2004 Present: Councillor Dick Walsh (Chair) Councillor Alison Hay Douglas Trigg Councillor Donald MacMillan Attending: Ken Macdonald, Area Corporate Services Manager Apologies: Councillor George Freeman Councillor Isobel Strong
Word for word from the decision Argyll and Bute published for this meeting. Source: www.argyll-bute.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Argyll and Bute's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Policy Development Group

Summary

1.1The initial public consultation period for the Draft Revised Scheme of Community Councils in Argyll and Bute has now closed.

1.2The responses now require to be considered by Members in order that the Draft Scheme can be amended, if required, and circulated for a second consultation period.

Recommendation

2.1That Members consider the responses to the initial consultation, and determine if / how the Draft Scheme should be amended prior to a second public consultation being undertaken.

2.2That Members note the revised timetable for implementation of the Scheme as set out in para 3.7.

3. DETAIL

3.1The initial public consultation period for the Draft Revised Scheme of Community Councils in Argyll and Bute has now closed, and copies of the responses, together with a summary thereof, are annexed to this report.

3.239 responses were received from individuals, Community Councils and voluntary groups. The main issues raised can be summarised as follows (the figures in brackets represent the number of representations received in respect of the particular issue) and can be read in detail if required in the attached annex:

(a) The current and proposed levels of administrative grant are inadequate (11);

(b) Opposition to the proposed reduction in membership (10);

(c) The proposed additional grant for running elections is inadequate (10);

(d) Opposition to the filling of sub-area vacancies by a candidate from another sub-area (7);

1 (e) The Local Authority should be responsible for the running of elections (5);

(f) The proposed four year term is too long (5); and

(g) The proposed four year term is sensible (5)

3.3Taking the main issues in the order set out in 3.2 above:

Issue: The current and proposed levels of administrative grant are inadequate

Comment: The proposals set out in the Draft Scheme are based, and can be met, within existing budget estimates. Any increase in level of grant would require an increase in the budget estimate.

Issue: Opposition to the proposed reduction in membership.

Comment: This may be addressed to a great extent by building into the Scheme a flexibility to allow Community Councils a discretion to increase their membership on the basis of electorate, i.e. a fixed ‘core’ membership plus a discretion to increase this by one per thousand, or part thereof, of electorate..

Issue: The proposed additional grant for running elections is inadequate

Comment: The issues thrown up by Community Council elections are set out in para 3.4 of the consultation document. In terms of the existing Scheme Community Councils are required to meet the costs of running their own elections. The proposal in the Draft Scheme would improve on that position, subject to the budget being made available..

Issue: Opposition to the filling of sub-area vacancies by a candidate from another sub-area.

Comment: Rather than automatically ‘appointing’ a candidate from another sub-area, a further by-election could be run for the sub-area, but opened up to allow those candidates who had failed to be elected in another sub-area to stand, although not otherwise qualified to do so.

Issue: The Local Authority should be responsible for the running of Elections.

Comment: The Local Authority does not have the physical resources to meet such an obligation.

Issue: The proposed four year term is too long / sensible.

Comment: The reasoning for this, which, in any event, has already been determined and implemented is set out in para 3.1 of the

2 first Consultation Document..

3.4Other issues were raised by individual respondents as follows:-

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
CONSIDER RESPONSES TO INITIAL CONSULTATIONReport 117 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
ListofResponsesReport 51 KB Download
PDF
Model ConstitutionReport 91 KB Download
PDF
Polling DistrictsReport 104 KB Download
PDF
Response SummaryReport 53 KB Download
PDF
Scheme for the establishment of Com CouncilsReport 98 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting
2CONSIDER RESPONSES TO INITIAL CONSULTATIONThis decision

Who was there

0 of 13 attended
GF
Councillor George FreemanMember, expected
AH
Councillor Alison HayMember, expected
KM
Kenneth MacdonaldOfficer, expected
DM
Councillor Donald MacMillan BEMMember, expected
SM
Susan MairOfficer, expected
JM
James McLellanOfficer, expected
CR
Charles ReppkeOfficer, expected
MS
Melissa StewartSecretary, expected
NS
Nigel StewartOfficer, expected
IS
Councillor Isobel StrongMember, expected
LS
Lynda SyedOfficer, expected
DW
Councillor Dick WalshMember, expected

All 13 on the meeting page

On this subject at Argyll and Bute

Search all
  1. CONSIDER RESPONSES TO INITIAL CONSULTATIONThis decision
  2. Consider responses to the second consultationNoted

More from Argyll and Bute Policy Development Group

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
20 Feb 2007 Political management arrangementsDecision That the Director of Corporate Services finalise the draft report to reflect the discussion at the meeting a... Decided Open
9 Feb 2007 Consider information required to undertake remitDecision That the Policy Development Group recommend to the Strategic Policy Committee that they note: 1. the positiv... Decided Open
31 Jan 2007 Councillor remunerationDecision The Group noted the contents of the report and the representations made on behalf of the Council. (Ref: Repo... Noted Open
31 Jan 2007 Councillors' allowances and expenses regulations 2007Decision 1. The Group noted the report and the representations that had been made on behalf of the Council, including... Noted Open
31 Jan 2007 The scottish parliament: an awareness seminar for new councillorsDecision Agreed that the Director of Corporate Services accept the offer from The Scottish Parliament and that this b... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies