Decision 1. To note the content of the report by the STV Working Group. 2. To request that the Director of Corporate Services draft a programme of work for the Policy Development Group for consideration at a future meeting. (Ref: Report by STV Working Group Secretariat dated September 2004, submitted).
Word for word from the decision Argyll and Bute published for this meeting.Source: www.argyll-bute.gov.uk
1. Significant consideration has been given to the most appropriate voting system for elections to local government in recent years. In June 1999, the McIntosh Commission recommended that ‘Proportional Representation should be introduced for local government elections. A review should be set up immediately, to identify the most appropriate voting system for Scottish local government.’ The Commission also recommended that ‘The criteria to be used in determining the system or systems of PR to be adopted for Scottish local government should be:
Proportionality;
The councillor-ward link;
Fair provision for independents;
Allowance for geographical diversity; and
A close fit between council wards and natural communities.’
2. The Commission also recommended that 3 systems of PR – Additional Member System (AMS), Single Transferable Vote (STV) and Alternative Vote (AV) top-up – be given particular consideration.
3. The Kerley Group was subsequently set up to advise on the most appropriate system of election, taking account of the criteria identified by McIntosh. The Group examined a number of electoral systems against these criteria, although they attached greatest importance to the first two. The Group rejected the Alternative Vote system (AV) because they believed it to be a majoritarian system and not a proportional system. The majority of the Group concluded that STV best met the requirements of their remit, but a minority disagreed, and had their views recorded separately in the Group’s report which was published in June 2000.
4. The White Paper Renewing Local Democracy – The Next Steps published in March 2002 by the Scottish Executive addressed the recommendations of the Kerley Group and attracted responses from members of the public, councils, community councils and other interested bodies. The outcome of that consultation led to the publication of the draft Local Governance (Scotland) Bill in February 2003. This draft Bill was taken forward by the new Executive following the elections in May 2003 and a revised draft was issued for further consultation in July that year with the final draft Bill being introduced to the Scottish Parliament on 21 November 2003. The Bill completed its Parliamentary passage on 23 June 2004 and received Royal Assent on 29 July.
Remit of the Group
5. The Single Transferable Vote Working Group was one of three Working Groups set up by the Scottish Executive in September 2003 to look at the practical issues raised by the
3 Bill. Details of the remits of the other two Groups - the Councillors’ Remuneration Progress Group and the Widening Access Progress Group – can be found at
The decision to introduce STV had already been taken. The remit of the Group was therefore to examine the procedures necessary to facilitate council elections being held using the Single Transferable Vote and how multi-member wards might operate in practice. In particular, the Group was to consider the practical implications of the introduction of STV across Scotland taking into account the geography of rural and urban areas and the need to retain the councillor-ward link.
Membership
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Political management arrangementsDecision That the Director of Corporate Services finalise the draft report to reflect the discussion at the meeting a...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.