CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Argyll and Bute Council
Policy Development Group, Monday 16 January 2006 at 2.00pm

REVIEW OF COMMUNITY COUNCILS IN SCOTLAND

Agreed Committee 2 papers

Policy Development Group agreed this item on Monday 16 January 2006. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item3

Resolved

Members agreed: (a) that since all Community Councils have been invited to submit responses direct to the Scottish Executive, there is no requirement at this time to invite a representative from the Argyll and Bute Association of Community Councils to sit on this Policy Development Group; (b) to endorse the comments set out in the report, subject to the following amendments: Q1.1 – Clarification is required in terms of the role and responsibilities of community councils. They have to recognise and take cognisance of the community planning agenda; Q1.5 – Add a comment to reflect that the changes in 2007 will provide an opportunity to review community council boundaries. Furthermore working practices should be reviewed to take account of multi-member wards; Q3.1 – In the main by way of regular public meetings and, in some cases, newsletters, although the attendance at meetings varies widely across the local authority area. There is a need to review how Community Councils in remote rural areas achieve widespread publicity of issues and effective consultation; Q4.1 – Add a comment to reflect that the Argyll and Bute Association of Community Councils was involved in the last review of the Scheme, which included the issue of funding; Q4.4 – Community Councils can apply to Trust Funds, Challenge Funds, Common Good Fund, the Council’s grant schemes, etc., for assistance towards specific projects; Q4.8 – Add a comment to reflect that community councillors should be able to demonstrate a sound grasp of the issues affecting the area to ensure they are reflecting accurately the views of the community; Q4.10 – Add a comment to reflect that few community councils in Argyll and Bute are affiliated to the Scottish Association as it is felt to be too remote and its views too central belt orientated; Q5.1 – Add a comment to reflect that there is no administrative sanction if they fail to do so, other than the civil law; Q6.1 – Change the comment to reflect that this is a matter for individual communities to respond to; Q6.3 – To respond to consultations and debates in regard to national issues which affect community councils, having ascertained the views of their members. There are concerns, however, that such a body, which is primarily urban based, may not reflect the views of rural areas. (c) that a further meeting of the Policy Development Group be held on 1 st February 2006 to consider its recommendations to the Strategic Policy Committee.
Word for word from the decision Argyll and Bute published for this meeting. Source: www.argyll-bute.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Argyll and Bute's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Policy Development Group

Summary

1.1The attached discussion paper was circulated to Elected Members, Directors and Heads of Service. It forms part of a review, by the Scottish Executive, of Community Councils and the Association of Scottish Community Councils (ASCC).

The Council has been asked to submit its views to the Scottish Executive by 28th February 2006.

Recommendation

2.1To recommend to the Strategic Policy Committee that the comments printed in italics in Section 3 form the basis of the Council’s response to the discussion paper.

3. DETAIL

3.1The discussion paper is divided into 6 main sections, each addressing a particular issue relating to the operation of community councils. Appended is a summary of the questions raised in the paper, together with a draft response to each question. These draft responses have been prepared following consultation with colleagues and taking into account responses already received from elected Members.

Q1.1 Is the current definition of the purpose of community councils appropriate? If not, how should it be changed and why?

Clarification is required in terms of the role and responsibilities of community councils. They are not intended to be a further tier of local government but that is how many community councils would appear to perceive themselves.

Q1.2 Is there a need to amend the legislative provisions relating to the adoption and amendment of community council schemes?

In cases where relatively minor changes to the Scheme are required, for example to reflect minor boundary changes, appropriate flexibility should be built into the legislative provisions to allow this without the need for the time and expense involved in a formal review.

1 Q1.3 Is there a need to ensure greater consistency between local authorities’ community council schemes. If so, why and what elements do you think should be common to all community council schemes?

Guidance on best practice is always welcome, but each local authority must retain the flexibility to vary this in response to local circumstances.

Q1.4 If you have answered ‘yes’ to the above question, could this be achieved by issuing guidance or drawing up a ‘model community council scheme’ or, would this best be dealt with by amending the legislation?

As stated above, guidance is always welcome and to this end a ‘model community council scheme’ might be helpful. Each local authority, however, must retain the flexibility to vary this in response to local circumstances.

Q1.5 Do you foresee the introduction of multi-member wards for local government in 2007 having an impact on the working relationship between community councils and local authority councillors? If so, what measures might be appropriate to ensure a constructive and effective relationship in the new multi-member wards?

The geography of Argyll and Bute is such that the introduction of multi- member wards for local government in 2007 will have an impact on the working relationship between community councils and local authority councillors. Although there are a number of community councils whose boundaries already span two or more local authority wards the situation post 2007 will be radically different due to the large number of inhabited islands to be served by local authority councillors who, in theory, may be resident on the mainland. Use of video conferencing may mitigate the position to some extent, but appropriate facilities are not available in all cases, and are not suited to meetings open to the public.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
REVIEW OF COMMUNITY COUNCILS IN SCOTLANDReport 124 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
Scott Exec CC Review Discussion PaperReport 269 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting
3REVIEW OF COMMUNITY COUNCILS IN SCOTLANDThis decision

Who was there

7 of 15 attended
BB
Brian BarkerOfficer, absent
GF
Councillor George FreemanChair, present
JG
Jane GilliesSecretary, present
AH
Councillor Alison HayMember, present
KM
Kenneth MacdonaldOfficer, present
SM
Susan MairOfficer, absent
JM
Councillor John McAlpineMember, present
JM
James McLellanOfficer, absent
CR
Charles ReppkeOfficer, present
ER
Councillor Elaine RobertsonMember, present
MS
Melissa StewartSecretary, absent
NS
Nigel StewartOfficer, absent

All 15 on the meeting page

On this subject at Argyll and Bute

Search all
  1. REVIEW OF COMMUNITY COUNCILS IN SCOTLANDThis decision
  2. Proposal to review the scheme for the establishment of community councils in argyll and bute phase two feedbackNoted
  3. Consider notice of review request: land south of kilfinan community forest caravan and west of hafton house, tighnabruaich (ref: 20/01429/pp)Agreed
  4. Proposal to review the scheme for the establishment of community councils in argyll and bute: phase one feedbackNoted
  5. Proposal to review the scheme for the establishment of community councils in argyll and buteAgreed
  6. Community Asset Transfer Scrutiny ReviewAgreed

More from Argyll and Bute Policy Development Group

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
20 Feb 2007 Political management arrangementsDecision That the Director of Corporate Services finalise the draft report to reflect the discussion at the meeting a... Decided Open
9 Feb 2007 Consider information required to undertake remitDecision That the Policy Development Group recommend to the Strategic Policy Committee that they note: 1. the positiv... Decided Open
31 Jan 2007 Councillor remunerationDecision The Group noted the contents of the report and the representations made on behalf of the Council. (Ref: Repo... Noted Open
31 Jan 2007 Councillors' allowances and expenses regulations 2007Decision 1. The Group noted the report and the representations that had been made on behalf of the Council, including... Noted Open
31 Jan 2007 The scottish parliament: an awareness seminar for new councillorsDecision Agreed that the Director of Corporate Services accept the offer from The Scottish Parliament and that this b... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies