CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Argyll and Bute Council
Policy Development Group, Monday 13 February 2006 at 10.00am

COMMISSION ON BOUNDARY DIFFERENCES AND VOTING SYSTEMS (ARBUTHNOTT)

Noted Committee 2 papers

Policy Development Group noted this item on Monday 13 February 2006. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item4

Resolved

Decision The Group noted the current position. (Ref: Report by Director of Corporate Services dated 2 February 2006, submitted).
Word for word from the decision Argyll and Bute published for this meeting. Source: www.argyll-bute.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Argyll and Bute's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Policy Development Group

Summary

1.1The purpose of this note is to report formally that the Commission on boundary differences and voting systems (the Arbuthnott Commission) has submitted its report to the Secretary of State for Scotland and the First Minister. The Commission’s remit was to examine the consequences of having four different systems of voting in Scotland, and different boundaries for Westminster and Scottish Parliament Constituencies.

Recommendation

2.1The PDG is invited to note the current position.

3.0DETAIL

3.1The Arbuthnott Commission was set up in July 2004 by the Secretary of State for Scotland under the Chairmanship of Professor Sir John Arbuthnott. In examining the consequences of having four different systems of voting, and different boundaries for Westminster and Scottish Parliamentary Constituencies, the Commission was to examine these consequences for –

- voter participation;

- the relationship between public bodies and authorities in Scotland and MPs and MSPs;

- representation of constituents by different tiers of elected members.

1 3.2 The recommendations include –

(1) The current mixed member system for electing the Scottish Parliament should be retained, but with open lists to increase voter choice.

(2) Constituency and regional boundaries for the Scottish Parliament should be based on local authority areas rather than Westminster constituencies, with the regions revised to better reflect natural local communities.

(3) Candidates for election to the Scottish Parliament should not be prohibited from standing in a Constituency and on the Regional List.

(4) Clearer and more positive roles should be developed for Constituency and Regional MSPs.

(5) The single transferable vote system should be introduced for European Parliamentary elections.

(6) Scottish Parliament and Local Government elections should be held on different days.

3.3A summary of the Commission’s 24 recommendations are set out in the appendix hereto. The recommendations at (2) and (6) above are of particular interest in a local government context. In relation to (2) it will be recalled that following the last review of Westminster Parliamentary Constituency boundaries the Argyll and Bute Parliamentary Constituency boundaries were fixed co- terminus with those of the Council. During the course of the Parliamentary boundary Review the Council had advocated that as an outcome, which is to be welcomed in terms of ease of understanding for electors, the administration of elections, and for the relationships between public and other organisations within Argyll and Bute with the MP. It might be desirable to hope that the outcome of the Arbuthnott recommendation will be a review of Scottish Parliament Constituency boundaries that might achieve co-terminosity with the Council boundary.

3.4Recommendation (6) echoes much that has already been said by COSLA, local authorities and electoral practitioners about de- coupling the Scottish Parliament and local government elections. The Ministerial response so far appears not to accept that recommendation (at least for 2007).

Nigel Stewart Director of Corporate Services 2 February 2006

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
COMMISSION ON BOUNDARY DIFFERENCES AND VOTING SYSTEMS (ARBUTHNOTT)Report 58 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
appendix_ArbuthnottAppendix 51 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

10 of 12 attended
RK
Councillor Ronald KinlochMember, present
RC
Councillor Robin CurrieMember, present
GF
Councillor George FreemanMember, present
AH
Councillor Alison HayGuest, present
DM
Councillor Duncan MacIntyreMember, absent
JM
Councillor John McAlpineMember, present
JM
James McLellanOfficer, present
GM
Councillor Gary MulvaneyMember, apologies
LS
Councillor Len ScoullarMember, present
NS
Nigel StewartOfficer, present
IS
Councillor Isobel StrongMember, present
DW
Councillor Dick WalshMember, present

On this subject at Argyll and Bute

Search all
  1. COMMISSION ON BOUNDARY DIFFERENCES AND VOTING SYSTEMS (ARBUTHNOTT)This decision
  2. 2023 review of uk parliament constituencies - boundary commission for scotland proposalsNoted
  3. Local Government Boundary Commission ProposalsAgreed
  4. Update on Boundary Commission review on Local Government Electoral WardsAgreed
  5. Local government boundary commission proposals for argyll and buteNoted
  6. Boundary commission proposalsAgreed

More from Argyll and Bute Policy Development Group

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
20 Feb 2007 Political management arrangementsDecision That the Director of Corporate Services finalise the draft report to reflect the discussion at the meeting a... Decided Open
9 Feb 2007 Consider information required to undertake remitDecision That the Policy Development Group recommend to the Strategic Policy Committee that they note: 1. the positiv... Decided Open
31 Jan 2007 Councillor remunerationDecision The Group noted the contents of the report and the representations made on behalf of the Council. (Ref: Repo... Noted Open
31 Jan 2007 Councillors' allowances and expenses regulations 2007Decision 1. The Group noted the report and the representations that had been made on behalf of the Council, including... Noted Open
31 Jan 2007 The scottish parliament: an awareness seminar for new councillorsDecision Agreed that the Director of Corporate Services accept the offer from The Scottish Parliament and that this b... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies