RESOLVED That the officer recommendation to approve be rejected. The Group Head of Planning then gave advice on the options open Members and, following discussion, it was agreed that the variation should be refused on the basis that the proposal would generate unacceptable levels of activity and noise. The Committee then RESOLVED That the application be refused for the following reason:- “The proposal would generate unacceptable levels of activity and noise which would adversely affect the adjoining properties in conflict with Planning Policies DDM1, QEDM1 and QESP1 of the Arun Local Plan.
Word for word from the decision Arun published for this meeting.Source: democracy.arun.gov.uk
LOCATION: Quercus Nursery Littlehampton Road Ferring BN12 6PH PROPOSAL: Variation of condition 2 following a grant of planning permission FG/52/18/PL - permit deliveries to be made to the site by HGVs. No more than 5 times per week between the hours of 05.00 & 06.00 & in addition to deliveries made during the hours of 06.00 to 19.00.
SITE AND SURROUNDINGS
DESCRIPTION OF APPLICATION This proposal seeks to amend condition 2 of FG/52/18/PL which states: 'There shall be no deliveries undertaken between 1900 hours and 0600 hours.'
Reason: In the interests of amenity in accordance with Arun Local Plan policies QE SP1 and QE DM1.
This condition was attached at the request of Development Control Committee (DCC) on 12 December 2018. The committee considered that 6am was a reasonable time to commence deliveries. The recommendation to DCC was that some deliveries could take place between 05.00 - 06.00 hours.
The application seeks approval to undertake deliveries one hour earlier a day, from 5am, up to 5 times per week. This was proposed as part of FG/52/18/PL but the decision of DCC in December 2018 was to allow deliveries from 06.00 hours only.
The application is supported by a Noise Impact Assessment. SITE AREA 1.4 hectares. TOPOGRAPHY Predominantly flat. TREES None affected by the proposed development. BOUNDARY TREATMENT Fencing/hedging to approx. 1-2m height. SITE CHARACTERISTICS Established nursery site used for tree growing with single storey poly tunnels and outbuildings within the site. CHARACTER OF LOCALITY Predominantly rural. Equestrian Centre to north, Vineyard to east and nursery to west.
RELEVANT SITE HISTORY FG/35/19/PL FG/52/18/PL Amendments to design approved under FG/95/16/PL, ApproveConditionally polytunnels, outdoor growing beds, tree nursery, storage 13-12-18 & welfare facilities for a horticultural enterprise.
FG/95/16/PL Polytunnels, outdoor growing beds, tree nursery, storage ApproveConditionally & welfare facilities for a horticultural enterprise 10-08-16
REPRESENTATIONS REPRESENTATIONS RECEIVED:
Ferring Parish Council Objection: - Conditions were applied to the delivery times on this site as a direct consequence of the site owners failing to respect neighbouring residents by the ongoing practice of overnight deliveries with the associated noise and disturbance previously identified in the many objections. While the conditions were welcomed to give some degree of overnight relief from such disturbances to the nearby residents, the conditions did not adequately restrict the delivery times when taking account of the location. - Totally opposed to any relaxation of the conditions in recognition of the impact of these frequent disturbances on the sleep patterns, general health and stress to which the residents are subjected. - Deliveries have continued despite the conditions being imposed with a complete disregard for the planning process and the local community. - There are no requirements for these deliveries to be received at unsocial hours other than for the convenience of the transport companies. - Continuing to contravene the planning conditions cannot be justified and should not be tolerated with appropriate compliance measures being enforced without further delay.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.