RESOLVED That the officer recommendation to approve not be accepted. Members then considered reasons to refuse the application in respect of lack of amenity space and a cramped overdevelopment of the site and were advised by the Group Head of Planning that :- (1) The Council’s relevant policy HDM4 relating to the conversion of rural buildings stipulated that the proposals should minimise the amount of land used as residential curtilage; and (2) The amenity space provided for the proposal was in fact larger than that provided for the previously approved conversion two years ago. However, Members maintained that the proposal was inappropriate and RESOLVED That the application be refused for the following reason:- The proposals would result in a form of development that would be cramped and over intensive with inadequate amenity space, resulting in an adverse impact on the character of the area contrary to policy DDM1 of the Arun Local Plan.
Word for word from the decision Arun published for this meeting.Source: democracy.arun.gov.uk
LOCATION: Kents Yard Brookpit Lane Climping BN17 5QT PROPOSAL: Change of use of barns to 3 No dwellings (resubmission following CM/24/18/PL). This application may affect the setting of a listed bulding.
SITE AND SURROUNDINGS
DESCRIPTION OF APPLICATION The proposal is to convert and extend the former farm stable buildings to create 3 separate dwellings. One 4 bedroom, one 3 bedroom and one 2 bedroom.
The current application proposes three dwellings instead of previously approved two and comprises: - A slightly deeper east wing. - An existing flat roof above east wing would be replaced with a pitch roof. - A small section of the court yard has been allocated for parking and bin/cycle store. - The parking spaces are replaced from the central position of the yard to the west of the former farm buildings. - A new entrance is proposed. - Three Flash conservation roof lights are proposed to the western roof plane facing to the yard. SITE AREA 0.14 hectares. RESIDENTIAL D E V E L O P M E N T 21 dwellings/hectare. DENSITY (NET) BOUNDARY TREATMENT To Crookthorne Lane 2m high flint wall. To east overgrown bund planted with hedging. To east 2m high brick wall. SITE CHARACTERISTICS The proposal site is located on the southern side of Crookthorne Lane and comprises single storey traditional flint and brick built farm buildings enclosing an inner yard area. CHARACTER OF LOCALITY The area is rural in character with a few neighbouring properties with one residential property on the opposite side of the road and a group of five to the south-east. Residential properties adjoin the site to the east and on the opposite side of Crookthorne Lane.
RELEVANT SITE HISTORY CM/25/19/PL CM/19/17/PL Conversion of former agricultural buildings to form two ApproveConditionally dwellings (Revised design). Resubmission following 25-10-17 CM/28/16/PL. This application affects the setting of a Listed Building.
CM/28/16/PL Conversion & extension of barns to form 2 No. dwellings Refused & detached car port This application affects the setting 09-02-17 of a Listed Building.
CM/19/15/PL Change of use of argicultural building to 2 No. dwellings. ApproveConditionally This application affects the setting of a Listed Building. 05-11-15
CM/38/14/PD Prior notification under Class MB part (a) for change of No Objection use of agricultural building to dwellinghouse (Use Class 19-12-14 C3)
CM/40/14/PD Prior notification under Class MB part (a) for change of No Objection use from agricultural building to dwellinghouse (Use 19-12-14 Class C3)
CM/28/16/PL related to conversion to 2 x 4 bed units and was refused for the following reasons:
- The proposed conversion is unacceptable in that it includes an extension to the approved residential curtilage and involves significant and unsympathetic rebuilding and alteration which together with the number and size of the new openings has an unacceptable impact on the rural character and appearance of the building and the wider locality. The proposal is therefore considered to conflict with policies GEN3, GEN7, AREA10 and DEV2 of the Arun District Local Plan. - Given the design and extent of alteration the proposal involves damage to the setting of a Grade 2 Listed Building, and therefore conflicts with the provisions of the National Planning Policy Framework.
Application CM/19/17/PL satisfactorily addressed the reasons of refusal in CM/28/16/PL.
REPRESENTATIONS REPRESENTATIONS RECEIVED:
Climping Parish Council Climping Parish Council has objected stating:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.