RESOLVED That the application be refused for the following reasons:- The development by reason of its size, appearance and materials would cause harm to neighbouring heritage assets (Grade II listed Buildings) contrary to HER DM1 of the Arun Local Plan.
Word for word from the decision Arun published for this meeting.Source: democracy.arun.gov.uk
LOCATION: Nyton House Nyton Road Westergate PO20 3UL PROPOSAL: Construction of a 10 No. bedroom dementia unit with attached covered walkway in the grounds of Nyton House Care Home and including the conversion of an existing garage into a staff day room, the erection of a new garage with laundry room, garden store & external bin store, demolition of various outbuildings and sections of wall and the re-landscaping of the existing garden areas. This application affects the setting of a listed building.
SITE AND SURROUNDINGS
DESCRIPTION OF APPLICATION New dementia care unit on grassed land in the north-western part of the site. This comprises 10 en-suite bedrooms, a kitchenette/utility area, additional bathroom, lounge/dining area, external covered walkway, internal courtyard garden plus new external gardens and landscaped amenity areas. The building will be part flat and part pitch roofed to a maximum height of 5.2m. It is proposed that the pitched roof gables be hipped in order to slope the roof away from the western boundary. The building will be constructed from a mix of brick, red zinc cladding, flint walling and timber fencing.
The proposal seeks permission to demolish various outbuildings located in the parking area to the north of the Care Home and to erect in their place a new small building containing single garage, laundry room, garden store and with an attached external fenced bin store. This building will be in the north-eastern part of this parking area and will have a footprint of 6.4m by 10.9m. It will have a pitched & hipped roof to a total height of 5.2m. Also to be demolished are small sections of flint wall.
The plans show the conversion and partial alteration of the garage to the front of the Care Home (to create a staff day room) and comprehensive landscaping including the removal of the swimming pool. Parking will be provided within the existing car park at the rear of the site. SITE AREA 0.35 hectares. TOPOGRAPHY Predominantly flat. TREES There are several trees in the vicinity of the site - 10 are potentially affected. One is noted as dying and to be removed AL/42/19/PL (T6 - a Wild Cherry located south of the dementia care unit). The remainder will be protected during construction. BOUNDARY TREATMENT Boundary treatments are mixed given the size of the site, however the following were noted:
- Part 1.8m high, part 1m high timber fencing to the rear/side garden boundaries of the three terraced cottages; - 2.5-3m high flint wall to the northern boundary of the garden where the Dementia unit will be sited; - 2.5-3m high flint wall to the southern boundary with Nyton Road; and - 3m high flint wall to the western boundary with Nyton Grange Cottage. SITE CHARACTERISTICS The site comprises a detached two and a half storey, Grade 2 Listed care home which has previously been extended at ground floor on the north western side and projecting towards the rear (west). There are large gardens to the front (east) and rear (west) and the rear gardens extend northwards at the rear of three terraced two and half storey cottages (Nyton Farm Cottage, Nyton Gable & Wyncote). These have ground floor principal windows and first floor bedroom windows which look out towards the site of the new dementia unit. The southernmost dwelling (Nyton Farm Cottage) has a large first floor flank window whilst the middle dwelling has a large first floor flank window on a rear projection which also looks south. Two of the three cottages are in the ownership of the applicant (Wyncote is separately owned) and it is understood that there are separate plans to change the use of the two dwellings to become part of the wider care home use.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.