RESOLVED That the application be refused for the following reason:- The significant increase in the frequency of deliveries and the increase in the size of vehicles would give rise to an increased level of safety risk to motorists, pedestrians and cyclists travelling along Aldwick Street by virtue of increased congestion. The proposals would therefore conflict with Policy T SP1 of the Arun Local Plan and policies within the NPPF.
Word for word from the decision Arun published for this meeting.Source: democracy.arun.gov.uk
Report following a request for further information, negotiations or consultation
REF NO: AW/237/19/PL LOCATION: The Former Ship Inn Aldwick Street Aldwick PROPOSAL: Variation of conditions imposed on planning reference AW/211/14/PL relating to condition 8 - delivery times & Condition 10 - delivery of goods serving the store in accordance to the Delivery Management Schedule
This application was deferred from the 8th January Committee meeting due to a request by members that the applicant provide (a) an independent Road Safety Audit (RSA) and (b) tracking diagrams to show what would happen if two refuse collection vehicles were travelling in opposite directions when a delivery was being made.
The applicant has now provided an independent Road Safety Audit undertaken by “Gateway TSP”, a Designers Response (by the applicant) and the requested tracking diagrams consisting of:
- Dwg B202 Rev A “Site Location Plan with Vehicle Tracking: Articulated Vehicle”; - Dwg B203 Rev A “Site Location Plan with Vehicle Tracking: Rigid Vehicle”; - Dwg B204 Rev A “Site Location Plan with Vehicle Tracking: Cars Passing Delivery Vehicles”; and - Dwg B205 Rev A “Site Location Plan with Vehicle Tracking: Refuse Trucks Passing Delivery Vehicles”
The Road Safety Audit (RSA) carried out identifies the following issues:
(1) Lack of surface water drainage may lead to pedestrian slips and falls at the proposed buildouts particularly during icy conditions. The RSA recommends that carriageway levels be reviewed, and drainage provided at the proposed buildouts as necessary;
(2) The current proposal is for a greater frequency of deliveries therefore more turning manoeuvres and greater holding of other traffic. Visibility for northbound vehicles towards waiting traffic may be obscured leading to nose to tail collisions. The RSA recommends that a ‘Delivery Management Plan’ be prepared to set out the routing of delivery vehicles and how deliveries would be managed and supervised by trained members of store staff.
(3) Carriageway widths at kerb buildouts may lead to side swipe collisions and also a danger to pedestrians from larger vehicles (on Aldwick Street). The RSA recommends that carriageway widths & swept paths be sufficient for vehicles to manoeuvre. AW/237/19/PL
(4) Lack of a footway on the northern side of Aldwick Street may lead to pedestrians being struck as customers approaching the store would need to walk in the carriageway. The RSA recommends that pedestrian routes approaching the store be formalised.
The applicants Designers Response (DR) sets out that:
(1) The design of the build out proposals has already been approved by WSCC through a s278. If additional further drainage is deemed necessary, then by agreement with WSCC, a drainage channel could be incorporated to maintain the kerbside drainage channel continuity.
(2) The applicants preferred delivery point would be for large delivery vehicles to use the area adjacent to the building, along Aldwick Street, as this requires no reversing. Smaller vehicles would then use the car parking area and avoid peak periods. The submitted delivery management scheme sets out hours of deliveries and types of vehicles. The store manager will monitor the flow of vehicles and adjust to reflect any local traffic changes or congestion immediately surrounding the store. CCTV would monitor the delivery area/roadways so that all potential matters are fully covered.
(3) The design of the build out proposals has already been approved by WSCC through a s278. Furthermore, the submitted swept path tracking plans show that there is sufficient space for vehicles to pass the delivery vehicle when adjacent to the building.
(4) A pedestrian crossing point to the highway will be provided as part of the s.278 proposals. This is with the build-out and is shown on all tracking plan drawings.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.