RESOLVED That the reasons for refusal be approved as detailed in the report and the officer report update and subject to inclusion of Polices TSP1 and TDM1 of the Local Plan and Paragraph 110 and 122 of the NPPF in reason 1. As a recorded vote had been requested, Councillors Bennett, Coster, [name removed], Lury, Oppler, [name removed] and [name removed] voted FOR (7); Councillors Bower, Charles, Kelly, [name removed] and Roberts voted AGAINST (5); and Councillors Edwards and Tilbrook ABSTAINED (2).
Word for word from the decision Arun published for this meeting.Source: democracy.arun.gov.uk
Report following a request for further information, negotiations or consultation
REF NO: BE/109/19/OUT
LOCATION: Land east of Shripney Road & south of Haddan House Shripney Road Bersted
PROPOSAL: Outline application with some matters reserved for up to 46 No dwellings together with access. This application is a Departure from the Development Plan & may affect the character and appearance of the Shripney Conservation Area.
Contrary to officer's advice and recommendation, it was resolved to refuse the application at the meeting on 3 June. Only Cllr Coster spoke on reasons for refusal which were seconded by Cllrs Thurston and Hamilton. However, the comments from Cllr Coster were extensive and in a form of a list of issues rather than reasons and the application was therefore deferred in order to allow officers an opportunity to formulate some suggested reasons for refusal based on this list for the Committee to consider.
Cllr Coster's comments in full were;
'On the basis that it is contrary to number of Local Plan policies. For example.
- TSP 1 (f2). Site has to have access to high quality public transport services. Which It does not. - T DM1 (b) Proposals for new development must contribute to the extension of public transport service to serve the development. There is no commitment in this to serve the development at all. - C SP1, SD SP2 Outside BUAB's and doesn't fall into any exception categories. - Bersted NP ES7 ditto. - SO DM1 Best and most versatile land grade 2. Development will not be permitted unless the need for the devt out weights the need to protect such land. Also, not permitted if the applicant has not submitted the necessary reports, which they have not. - SD SP1 claim this supports sustainable development only on the condition that will contribute to the social, economic and environmental conditions south the National Park. This development does not contribute to any of these. - Its also in conflict with the NPPF paragraphs 110, which refers to high quality public transport which is not present there, and it doesn't address the needs for people with disabilities and reduced mobility. It's also 117, 118, 122(c), 127(f) and 155 as I mentioned before about that it has to avoid flooding or has to be made safe for its lifetime. 155 is important. - And the future effects of climate change 157(d), 158, 160, 161. There is a lot of aspects there that it can be refused under. - This development has very limited social, economic and environmental benefits and they don't do anything to outweigh the clear harm that this development will do to the village of Shripney and potential users of this development.'
Officers have worded reasons for refusal for the Committee to consider around these comments (as there were no other comments made by members).
(1) The proposals have limited economic, social and environmental benefits and result in clear harm to the village of Shripney. The site lacks access to high quality public transport, is outside of the built-up area and the benefits of the proposals do not outweigh the harm. The BE/109/19/OUT
proposals are contrary to policies C SP1 and SD SP1 of the Arun Local Plan, Policy ES7 of the Bersted Neighbourhood Plan and the guidance within the NPPF.
(2) The proposed development fails to address the flood risk requirements associated with future climate change in the longer term and is contrary to paragraph 155, 157, 158, 160 and 161 of the NPPF.
(3) The proposed development is on land defined as the best and most versatile agricultural land (Grade 2). As the benefits of the proposals do not outweigh and the applicant has not submitted reports required within policy SO DM1 of the Arun Local Plan, the proposals are therefore contrary to this policy.
Officer advice at the meeting was clear in that;
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.