Supplementary Estimate to Defend Appeals at Middleton Poultry Farm [M/80/19/PL]; Inglenook Hotel, Pagham [P/58/19/PL}; and Land East of Shripney Road, Shripney [BE/109/19/OUT]
AgreedExecutive1 paper
Cabinet agreed this item on Monday 20 July 2020. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
The Cabinet RECOMMEND TO FULL COUNCIL That a supplementary estimate of £40,000 is agreed in order to defent decisions taken on planning applications M/80/19/PL; P/58/19PL and BE/109/19/OUT at planning appeal. The Band D equivalent for a £40k supplementary estimate is £0.64.
Word for word from the decision Arun published for this meeting.Source: democracy.arun.gov.uk
ARUN DISTRICT COUNCIL REPORT TO AND DECISION OF CABINET ON 20 JULY 2020
SUBJECT: Supplementary Estimate to defend planning appeals at Middleton Poultry Farm (M/80/19/PL), Inglenook Hotel, Pagham (P/58/19/PL) and Land east of Shripney Road, Shripney (BE/109/19/OUT)
REPORT AUTHOR: Neil Crowther – Group Head of Planning DATE: June 2020 EXTN: x 37839 PORTFOLIO AREA: Planning
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: There are three planning appeals for major development where planning permission has been refused by the Council. All of these decisions were made at the Development Control Committee (DCC) contrary to the Officer recommendation. A Supplementary Estimate is sought to be able to present a case to these appeals because Officers are unable to fully articulate the case for the Council.
RECOMMENDATIONS: That Cabinet recommends to Full Council that a Supplementary Estimate of £40,000 is agreed in order to defend decisions taken on planning applications M/80/19/PL, P/58/19/PL and BE/109/19/OUT at planning appeal.
The Band D equivalent for £40k supplementary estimate is £0.64.
1. BACKGROUND: 1.1 A Supplementary Estimate is sought for decisions on planning applications to be defended at forthcoming appeals. These appeals relate to the following applications and are all applications that were refused planning permission, contrary to officers’ recommendation, at Development Control Committee (DCC);
Middleton Poultry Farm (M/80/19/PL). Refused February 2020. Inglenook Hotel, Pagham (P/58/19/PL). Refused March 2020. Shripney Road, Shripney (BE/109/19/OUT). Refused June 2020.
An appeal against M/80/19/PL has been submitted with appeals against the other decisions expected in the coming weeks. 1.2 The reasons for seeking a Supplementary Estimate are:
1. Officers are currently dealing with a significant number of appeals. There are 34 current appeals with the Council (10 of which are decisions made by DCC contrary to officer recommendations). In the calendar year 2019, there were a total of 42 appeal decisions. In 2020 there has been an increase in cases and consequential workloads. There have already been 24 decisions received from The Planning Inspectorate in addition to the 34 current appeals. 2. There has been some DCC Member criticism around the quality of some appeal submissions made by Officers. 3. Officers are unable to fully articulate the reasons for the refusal and provide required evidence to support these. Officers also have limited time in which to try and present such cases on decisions taken at the Development Control Committee.
1.3It is estimated that up to £40,000 would be required to instruct consultants to present a case on behalf of the Council at these appeals. The Council will be required to prepare and submit technical evidence on highways and trees as well as a planning policy case on overdevelopment, character and sustainability in order to address its reason for refusal on these applications (see para 1.8).
1.4Supplementary Estimates for this type of work have previously been secured for appeals/judicial reviews at Summer Lane, Pagham (March 2019), and Horsemere Green Lane, Climping (CM/1/17/OUT) (February 2018).
Resources & Capacity
1.5In the municipal year May 2018 – May 2019, 6 out of 88 applications that went to DCC that were overturned and refused planning permission (7%). This resulted in only one appeal for officers to defend. There has been a substantial increase in appeals workload since the local elections in May 2019. In the municipal year May 2019 – May 2020, 16 out of 81 applications that went to DCC were overturned and refused planning permission (20%). This has resulted in 14 appeals to defend (10 current appeals and 4 already decided).
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Supplementary Estimate to Defend Appeals at Middleton Poultry Farm [M/80/19/PL]; Inglenook Hotel, Pagham [P/58/19/PL}; and Land East of Shripney Road, Shripney [BE/109/19/OUT]Supplementary
91Supplementary Estimate to Defend Appeals at Middleton Poultry Farm [M/80/19/PL]; Inglenook Hotel, Pagham [P/58/19/PL}; and Land East of Shripney Road, Shripney [BE/109/19/OUT]This decision
Supplementary Estimate to Defend Appeals at Middleton Poultry Farm [M/80/19/PL]; Inglenook Hotel, Pagham [P/58/19/PL}; and Land East of Shripney Road, Shripney [BE/109/19/OUT]This decision
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.