RESOLVED That a supplementary estimate be agreed for up to £25,000 to fund the commissioning of an independent expert to undertake the following actions [this amount representing a Band D equivalent of Council Tax in the sum of £0.40: a) Review the decisions already taken to establish if there are any issues (process and judgement) b) Identify what legal options exist for securing changes to the acoustic fence c) What are the implications of the above, including financial (compensation) and legal.
Word for word from the decision Arun published for this meeting.Source: democracy.arun.gov.uk
Public Document Pack Subject to approval at the next Planning Committee meeting
SPECIAL MEETING OF DEVELOPMENT CONTROL COMMITEE
18 May 2021 at 1.30 pm
Present: Councillors Bennett (Chair), Blanchard-Cooper, Bower, Charles, Clayden (Substitute for Roberts), Coster, Hamilton, Kelly, Lury, Pendleton, Tilbrook, Warr, Catterson (Substitute for Thurston) and Oliver-Redgate (Substitute for Edwards)
Apologies: Councillors Edwards, Roberts and Thurston
575. DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST
No declarations of interest were made.
576. MINUTES
The Minutes of the meeting held on 28 April 2021 were approved by the Committee.
577. FITZALAN LINK ROAD ACOUSTIC FENCE
5 Public Speakers
Cllr Jill Long, Littlehampton Town Council Tracey Lynch David Willis Peter Hawkes Cllr Britton, West Sussex County Council
The Group Head of Planning presented his report. This was followed by five Public Speakers and response to comments made was provided by the Group Head of Planning.
Members then took part in a full debate on the report where a number of concerns with the acoustic fencing were raised. These concerns primarily revolved around height, traffic speed on the new road, materials and proximity to housing.
Members who spoke noted that the fencing was high and some noted that it could have a claustrophobic effect on residents, but that there was not currently enough information to determine if the fencing was too high. There was a perception amongst Members who spoke that the height of the fencing was strongly determined by the speed of the road and the subsequent noise generated, and therefore if the speed limit could be reduced to 30mph from 40mph then the fencing height could also be reduced. Subject to approval at the next Planning Committee meeting
484 Special Meeting of Development Control Committee - 18.05.21
It was explained that West Sussex County Council, with responsibility for Highways and having previously determined the speed of the new road, would have to agree to a reduction in the speed limit. The Group Head of Planning also confirmed that there was no technical evidence that demonstrated that a lower speed limit would result in the need for a significantly lower structure. Members were asked to note changes to Government policy on carbon neutrality and the future impact of more electric vehicles on the road but appreciated in the short and medium term that the road may be used by large vehicles including HGVs. The Cabinet Member for Planning noted that there was not a direct correlation between height and speed limit due to the complexities of sound mitigation and therefore seeking a lowering to the speed limit might not be the right direction to take as it would not necessarily translate into a lower fence.
Members who spoke raised concerns around the look of the weathered steel both for residents and road users and how in keeping with other road barriers in the District it was. Members who spoke suggested that options around alternative materials that were more sympathetic to residents and the area should be explored including transparent ones and the use or greater use of natural barriers such as trees and shrubs. The proximity of fencing of that height to the houses on Highdown Drive and Amberley Close was also raised as a concern and whether an option of moving the fence further away from the houses could lessen the impact of both the height and look for residents.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.