RESOLVED That a supplementary estimate of £100,000 is agreed in order to defend appeals taken on planning applications A/110/21/PL and A/168/21/PL, A/129/21 PL and P/178/21/OUT to cover the costs award in respect of BE/109/19/OUT and to carry out further work required on the Fitzalan Acoustic Barrier. The Band D equivalent for a £100,000 supplementary estimate is £1.58. Councillor Gunner then turned to two recommendations contained within Minute 110 [Combined Cleansing Services Contract Extensions – Financial Implications] which he duly proposed. The recommendations were then seconded by Councillor Cooper. The Council RESOLVED – That (1) It approves a supplementary revenue budget of £180k in 2022/23 to fund the increase in cost of the contract indexation as agreed for year 6 of the current contract and 2 months of the new contract. This equates to a Band D equivalent tax of £2.86; and (2) It approves a further supplementary revenue budget of £109k (£655 full year effect) plus appropriate indexation in 2022/23 to fund the increased cost of continuing current weekly refuse collections in February and March 2023. The £109k for 2022/23 equates to a Band D Council Tax of £10.40
Word for word from the decision Arun published for this meeting.Source: democracy.arun.gov.uk
ARUN DISTRICT COUNCIL REPORT TO AND DECISION OF POLICY & FINANCE COMMITTEE ON 30 JUNE 2022
SUBJECT: Supplementary Estimate to defend planning appeals at Chandlers, Angmering (A/1101/21/PL), Rustington Golf Centre (A/129/21/PL), Worthing Road, (A/168/21/PL) and Pagham Road (P/178/21/OUT). This will also cover the costs award at Shripney Road (BE/109/19/OUT). It will also cover costs associated with further technical work that Planning Committee have requested on the Fitzalan acoustic barrier.
REPORT AUTHOR: Neil Crowther – Group Head of Planning DATE: 1 June 2022 EXTN: 01903 737839 AREA: Place
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Normally, the Council may get one appeal to be heard by way of inquiry every 1 – 2 years. There are currently four planning appeals to be heard by way of public inquiry that have all been submitted in the space of a few months. Officer time in carrying out the work necessary in defending these appeals would be significant and would result in time that would otherwise have been available for determining of planning applications not being available.
A budget is also requested to continue the technical work that has been requested by Planning Committee on the Fitzalan acoustic barrier.
RECOMMENDATIONS: That the Policy & Finance Committee recommends to Full Council that:
(1) A Supplementary Estimate of £100,000 is agreed in order to defend decisions at appeal taken on planning applications A/110/21/PL, A/168/21/PL, A/129/21/PL & P/178/21/OUT, to cover the Costs award in respect of BE/109/19/OUT and to carry out further work required on the Fitzalan Acoustic Barrier.
The Band D equivalent for £100,000 supplementary estimate is £1.58. 1. BACKGROUND: Appeals 1.1 The Planning Department has a relatively small budget to use on external consultants and other miscellaneous costs over the course of a year. Typically, this budget would be used for dealing with the occasional appeal or instructing a consultant to carry out a specific bit of work on our behalf and the budget allocated is sufficient for this purpose.
1.2We are only a few months into the 22/23 financial year and it is obvious that this budget will be significantly exceeded this year due to the following appeal costs;
Application/Site Likely cost BE/109/19/OUT Appeal against decision to refuse. Application was £20 - £30k Shripney Rd refused contrary to the officer recommendation and the appeal allowed. The Inspector allowed a partial award of costs due not being able to provide any evidence on settlement boundary and flood risk issues.
This appeal had already cost nearly £10k to defend that was from a previous Supplementary Estimate. A/110/21/PL Appointed consultants to present the Council’s £25k Chandlers, case at the appeal inquiry as well as the need to Angmering appoint legal representation. A/168/21/PL To be heard by way of Inquiry. legal representation £30k Littlehampton being appointed and a need to appoint external Rd/Worthing Rd consultants to represent the Council due to officer time constraints. A129/21/PL To be heard by way of Inquiry. There will be a £20k - Rustington Golf need to appoint legal representation and it is likely £30k that we will need to appoint external consultants to represent the Council due to officer time constraints. P/178/21/OUT To be heard by way of Inquiry. There may be a £20k - Pagham Road, need to appoint legal representation and it is likely £30k Pagham that we will need to appoint external consultants to represent the Council due to officer time constraints.
1.3The above current appeals have all been refused under delegated authority but, due to day-to-day work dealing with planning applications, case officers simply do not have sufficient time to dedicate to a long and detailed appeal process and present the Council’s case as well as possible.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.