CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Ashfield District Council
Planning Committee, Thursday 21 April 2016 at 6.30pm

Town and Country Planning Act 1990; Town Planning Applications Requiring Decisions

Refused Planning 7 papers

Planning Committee refused this item on Thursday 21 April 2016. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

ItemP.35

Resolved

RESOLVED that 1. Application V/2016/0130, [name removed], single storey side and rear extension with porch to front, 18 Cricket Close, Kirkby in Ashfield. It was moved and seconded that conditional consent be granted. 2. Application V/2016/0076, [name removed] , retention of storage shed, Enjoy Café, Portland Square, Low Street, Sutton in Ashfield. The Chairman informed the Committee that Councillor Cathy Mason had called in the application however, she would not be attending the meeting to address the Committee in view of her Disclosable Pecuniary Interest in respect of this application. Councillor David Griffiths subsequently proceeded to read out a statement on behalf of Councillor Mason highlighting her comments, concerns and reasons for calling in the application to enable the Committee to consider this matter further. It was moved and seconded that conditional consent be granted. 3. Application V/2016/0108, Ashfield District Council, demolition of offices, former ADC Sutton Office, Fox Street, Sutton in Ashfield. It was moved and seconded that conditional consent be granted. 4. Application V/2016/0039, Ashfield District Council, demolition of Public Toilets and reinstatement of public space, Public Toilets, Ogle Street, Hucknall. It was moved and seconded that conditional consent be granted. 5. Application V/2016/0133, [name removed], Fell one Sycamore Tree, 2 Portland Gardens, Hucknall . It was moved and seconded that conditional consent be granted. 6. Application V/2015/0255, [name removed], erection of agricultural dwelling and provision of package waste water treatment plant, Felley Alpacas, Felley Mill Lane South, Underwood. [name removed], agent for the applicant, took the opportunity to address the Committee in respect of this matter. It was moved and seconded that planning permission be refused for the following reasons: The proposal lies within the designated Nottinghamshire Green Belt and would result in the siting of an isolated dwelling of detriment to the purposes and openness of the Green Belt, without sufficient justification in the form of an acceptable business case to demonstrate that there is an essential functional need and viable business to justify an agricultural workers dwellings within the Green Belt. The proposal is therefore contrary to Part 9 ‘Protecting Green Belt land’, and paragraph 55 of the National Planning Policy Framework, and Saved Policy EV1 of the Ashfield Local Plan Review 2002, which seeks to avoid isolated new homes in the Green Belt unless Very Special Circumstances have been demonstrated.
Word for word from the decision Ashfield published for this meeting. Source: democracy.ashfield.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Ashfield's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning Committee

FFFFFFEEELL LLLLLLLLEEE 118

EEEY YY YY Y © Crown Copyright and database right 2016. Ordnance Survey 100024849

MM MMM MIIIILIILL LLLLLLLL LLLLLA AA AA AN NN NN N EEE((( ((N N(NN NOOO OOOR RRR R TTTHHH HH))))) 106

Felley House

Felley View

k ac Tr 121.0m UTH)))))) UTH UTH LL LLLAN LANEE LAN LLAN (SO (SO (SOUTH EE(SO (SO (SOUTH UTH FEL FEL LEY LEY MIL MIL MILL LEYMIL FELLEY MIL MIL LAN LAN 114.3m FEL FEL FELLEY LEY

137.6m

FFFFFFE EEE ELLL LLLLLLLLEE EEEY YY YY YMMM MMIIILIILL LLLLLLLL LLLLLA AA AA ANNN NNNE EEE E ((N N(N NN NOO OOOR RR RR RTTTTTT HHH))) ))

Felley Plantation

Issues Issues

V/2015/0255 - Erection of Agricultural Dwelling and Provision of Package Waste Water Treatment Plant Felley Alpacas, Felley Mill Lane South, Underwood, NG16 6FG Underwood

Scale: 1 to 1250

Date: 21 April 2016  © Crown Copyright and database right 2016. Ordnance Survey 100024849 COMMITTEE DATE 21/04/2016 WARD Underwood

APP REF V/2015/0255

APPLICANT [name removed] of Agricultural Dwelling and Provision of Package Waste Water Treatment Plant

LOCATION Felley Alpacas Felley Mill Lane South Underwood

WEB LINK https://www.google.co.uk/maps/search/felley+mill+lane/data=!4m2! 2m1!4b1

BACKGROUND PAPERS A, B, C, D, E, F, I, K

RECOMMENDATION Refuse

App Registered 28/04/2015 Expiry Date 23/06/2015

Extension of time Agreement 30/11/2015

Consideration has been given to the Equalities Act 2010 in processing this application.

This application has been referred to Planning Committee by Councillor Sears- Piccavey as the proposal is inappropriate development within the Green Belt.

Committee Deferral

This planning application was heard at planning committee on the 24 th November 2015 and was deferred in order to obtain further financial information. This was particularly relevant given a late item that had been received on 10th November 2015 to the application from Pedley & Co Solicitors. The Solicitors confirmed that having considered further information, they were in retrospect unable to give a professional opinion regarding the commercial viability of the business known as Felley Alpacas. In order to give such a full audit of the business would be required.

Communication between the Local Planning Authority and the applicant was undertaken after the planning committee and the applicant stated that they would submit the required robust business case as soon as possible. The Local Authority chased the applicant for this information in March 2016. Since then the following information has been provided in support of their business case:

 Letter from Kevin Russell Accountants dated 22/03/2016 – this confirms that they have reviewed the accounts for David Swain (the applicant) and Felley Alpacas and state that “the accounts dated 06/07/2015 give a true and fair view of the company’s position and of its profits for that period ended. They have been properly prepared to meet the requirements for HMRC and conform to generally accepted accounting practice for sole traders. There is however a presentational error where depreciation on the plant and machinery has been shown as loss on disposal; this does not alter the underlying results re net profit or balance sheet.”  Email from the applicant dated 01/04/2016 – this aims to further support their case and summarise their position since the committee deferral. Their comments are summarised as follows and are in their words:

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Town and Country Planning Act 1990; Town Planning Applications Requiring DecisionsDecisions 291 KB Download
PDF
V2015-0255 Felley AlpacasReport 517 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
V2016-0039 Public Toilets Ogle Street HucknallReport 358 KB Download
PDF
V2016-0076 Enjoy Cafe Portland Square Low Street Sutton in AshfieldReport 260 KB Download
PDF
V2016-0108 Former ADC Sutton Office Fox Street Sutton in AshfieldReport 277 KB Download
PDF
V2016-0130 18 Cricket Close Kirkby in AshfieldReport 235 KB Download
PDF
V2016-0133 2 Portland Gardens HucknallReport 276 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting
P.34MinutesOn the agenda
P.35Town and Country Planning Act 1990; Town Planning Applications Requiring DecisionsThis decision
P.36Planning Appeal DecisionsNoted

Who was there

16 of 28 attended
LA
Councillor Lee AndersonCommittee Member, present
RB
Councillor Rachel BissettCommittee Member, present
CB
Councillor Cheryl ButlerCommittee Member, present
SC
Councillor Steve CarrollVice-Chair, present
DD
Councillor Don DavisCommittee Member, present
DG
Councillor David GriffithsCommittee Member, present
JK
Councillor John KnightChairman, present
RM
Councillor Rachel MaddenCommittee Member, absent
GM
Councillor Glenys MaxwellCommittee Member, present
KR
Councillor Kevin RostanceCommittee Member, present
PR
Councillor Philip RostanceCommittee Member, present
RS
Councillor Robert Sears-PiccaveyCommittee Member, absent

All 28 on the meeting page

On this subject at Ashfield

Search all
  1. Town and Country Planning Act 1990; Town Planning Applications Requiring DecisionsThis decision
  2. Town and Country Planning Act 1990: Town Planning Applications Requiring DecisionsRefused
  3. Town and Country Planning Act 1990: Town Planning Applications Requiring DecisionsRefused
  4. Town and Country Planning Act 1990: Town Planning Applications Requiring DecisionsApproved
  5. Town and Country Planning Act 1990: Town Planning Applications Requiring DecisionsRefused
  6. Town and Country Planning Act 1990: Town Planning Applications Requiring DecisionsDecided

More from Ashfield Planning Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
2 Sep 2026 Proposed and Recent Legislation and Policy Changes.RESOLVED that the report be received and noted. Noted Open
2 Sep 2026 Planning Appeal Decisions.RESOLVED that the report be received and noted. Noted Open
22 Jul 2026 Planning Appeal DecisionsRESOLVED that the report be received and noted. Noted Open
10 Jun 2026 Planning Appeal DecisionsRESOLVED that the report be received and noted. Noted Open
15 Apr 2026 Planning Appeal DecisionsRESOLVED that the report be received and noted. Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies