CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Ashfield District Council
Planning Committee, Thursday 14 December 2017 at 6.30pm

Town and Country Planning Act 1990; Town Planning Applications Requiring Decisions

Refused Planning 4 papers

Planning Committee refused this item on Thursday 14 December 2017. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

ItemP.21

Resolved

RESOLVED that 1. Application V/2016/0737, Chardstock Management Services Limited, outline application for the erection of 24 one and two bedroom apartments and associated works, land at junction of Outram Street and Park Street, Sutton in Ashfield. It was moved and seconded that that planning permission be refused for the following reasons:- 1. The Town and Country Act 1990, Section 106 allows a local planning authority to enter into a legally-binding agreement or planning obligation with a landowner in association with the granting of planning permission. These agreements are a way of delivering or addressing matters that are necessary to make a development acceptable in planning terms. The applicant refuses to enter into a Section 106 Agreement, the terms of which were confirmed in advance of the presentation of the application to the initial planning committee for determination. Accordingly, in the absence of the contributions requested, the development is considered to be unsustainable, failing as it would to contribute towards local facilities, infrastructure and services considered necessary to mitigate against the impacts of the proposed development. 2. The proposed development, without the satisfactory completion of the Section 106 Agreement, is considered to be contrary to Policy HG4 of the ALPR 2002, the ADC SPD – Affordable Housing 2009 and HG2 of the ALP Publication 2016 in it’s failure to meet the affordable housing provision; contrary to Policy HG6 of the ALPR 2002 and HG3 of the ALP Publication 2016 in it’s failure to secure off-site open space and public realm improvements; and contrary to Policy PJ5 of the ALP Publication 2016 and Paragraph 72 of the NPPF in it’s failure to provide an education contribution for primary school places in the locality. 2. Application V/2017/0571, Ashfield District Council, alterations to the external façade including new cladding, new windows and doors, Kingsmill Reservoir, Sherwood Way South, Sutton in Ashfield. (At this point in the proceedings Councillor Cheryl Butler declared that she was predetermined in respect of this application. Her interest arose from the fact that she had recently attended the launch of the Kingsmill Reservoir Visitors Centre and also taken part in a radio interview promoting the virtues of this facility. Councillor Butler therefore left the room at 6.42 p.m. and took no part in the discussion and voting thereon). It was moved and seconded that conditional consent be granted. (Councillor Butler returned to the room at 6.47 p.m. following consideration of the above application). 3. Application V/2017/0589, Ashfield District Council, installation of external wall insulation and new external doors and windows to 78 dwellings, various properties at Story Gardens, Arden Close and Bestwood Road, Hucknall. (At this point in the proceedings Councillor Keir Morrison declared a Non Disclosable Pecuniary/Other Interest in respect of this application in his capacity as the Cabinet Portfolio Holder for Housing and Assets. In view of the nature of his interest he remained in the meeting and took part in the discussion and voting thereon). In accordance with the Council’s Policy for dealing with late matters in ... view the full minutes text for item P.21
Word for word from the decision Ashfield published for this meeting. Source: democracy.ashfield.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Ashfield's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning Committee

i es

60 © Crown Copyright and database right 2017. Ordnance Survey 100024849

tsi

a St b cP

Su El 59 r im 39

ary an

63 d Nu 24

64 rse

65 ry Sc ho

bu Cl ol 22

25 NO 12 RT

87 H ST

1 RE 13 ET 2

ET 13

RE 1

ST

2 AM

70 75

TR OU 152.8m

23 14

73 69 PA

58 67 R KS

58 a TR

CR EE

56 y 26

Bd T

ED 65 63 43

23 61 57

44 59

42 38

15 36 34 152.0m

11 28

to 26 20 to 24

1 15

152.2m

PENN STREET

Car Park 153.3m 18 20 28 26 10

2 Shelter 2

1 Scarcliffe 4 8

Shelter 6

Court 10 a St

44 b Su

12 El

34 36

20 CR

11 32

15 BR AM 4

LE YC OU RT BR 6 37

Station House 75

20 16

V/2016/0737 - Outline Application With Some Matters Reserved For A Maximum of 24 Apartments and Associated Works Land at Junction of Outram Street and Park Street, Sutton In Ashfield Central and New Cross

Scale: 1 to 1250

Date: 2nd March 2017  © Crown Copyright and database right 2017. Ordnance Survey 100024849 COMMITTEE DATE 14/12/2017 WARD Central and New Cross

APP REF V/2016/0737

APPLICANT Chardstock Management Services Ltd

PROPOSAL Outline application for the erection of 24 one and two bedroom apartments and associated works

LOCATION Land at Junction of Outram Street and Park Street Sutton in Ashfield.

https://www.google.co.uk/maps/@53.1275873,- WEB-LINK 1.2580441,160m/data=!3m1!1e3 RECOMMENDATION Refuse Planning Permission

BACKGROUND PAPERS A, B, C D, E, I

App Registered 29/11/2016 Expiry Date 10/01/2017

Consideration has been given to the Equalities Act 2010 in processing this application.

This application was initially referred to Planning Committee by Councillor Amanda Brown.

Relevant Planning History

V/2004/0653: Erection of 28 flats. Conditionally Approved subject to S106 Agreement which required contributions of £42,000 towards Public Open Space improvements and £64,000 towards off-site affordable housing.

V/2005/1073: Erection of 37 apartments. Refused but allowed on appeal subject to conditions requiring schemes to be submitted for off-site public open space improvements and the provision for off-site affordable housing.

The Application

This is an outline application with all matters except access reserved for further approval for the erection of up to 24 one and two bedroom flats with associated works.

Members may recall the initial submission to the Planning Committee on 2nd March 2017 where conditional approval was authorised, subject to the satisfactory completion of a S106 Agreement. A copy of the Officer’s Report presented at the meeting is attached for clarity.

The proposed S106 requirements were as follows:-

 Affordable housing - 10% provision or possibly an off-site contribution in lieu.  Landscape & public realm contributions ;  £24,000 for Sutton Lawn improvements  £48,000 for Portland Square; Station Rd/High Pavement Gateway; or any other as identified in future adopted plans and policies  Education - £57,275 for 5 primary school places

On the 2 December 2016 the applicant confirmed their willingness to enter into a S106 Agreement if it is necessary to secure an outline planning consent. The contributions were outlined to the applicant on 14 February 2017 and comments requested. The applicant was also advised that the application was to be presented to the Planning Committee on 2 March. On 17 February the applicant suggested they would submit a viability assessment to be considered as part of the S106 Agreement but other than that, they raised no specific concerns over the allocation of and/or amount of contributions requested.

Policy The main policy considerations are:

Ashfield Local Plan Review 2002  ST1- Development  ST2- Main Urban Area  HG4- Affordable Housing  HG5- New Residential development  HG6- Public Open Space  EM5- Protection of Existing Employment land and Buildings  SH2 Local Shopping Centre

NPPF  Core Planning Principles  Part 1 Building and Strong, Competitive Economy  Part 6 Delivering and Wide Choice of High Quality Homes  Part 7 Requiring Good Design

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Town and Country Planning Act 1990; Town Planning Applications Requiring DecisionsDecisions 284 KB Download
PDF
V2016-0737 Land at Junction of Outram Street and Park Street Sutton in AshfieldReport 497 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
V2017-0571 The Mill Adventure Base, Kingsmill Reservoir, Sherwood Way South, Sutton in AshfieldReport 203 KB Download
PDF
V2017-0589 Properties at Story Gardens, Arden Close and Bestwood Road HucknallReport 315 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting
P.20MinutesOn the agenda
P.21Town and Country Planning Act 1990; Town Planning Applications Requiring DecisionsThis decision
P.22Planning Appeal DecisionNoted

Who was there

19 of 26 attended
LA
Councillor Lee AndersonCommittee Member, absent
CB
Councillor Chris BaronCommittee Member, present
TB
Councillor Tim BrownCommittee Member, present
CB
Councillor Cheryl ButlerCommittee Member, present
DG
Councillor David GriffithsChairman, present
TH
Councillor Tom HollisCommittee Member, present
RM
Councillor Rachel MaddenCommittee Member, present
CM
Councillor Cathy MasonCommittee Member, present
GM
Councillor Glenys MaxwellVice-Chair, present
KM
Councillor Keir MorrisonCommittee Member, present
KR
Councillor Kevin RostanceCommittee Member, present
HS
Councillor Helen-Ann SmithCommittee Member, present

All 26 on the meeting page

On this subject at Ashfield

Search all
  1. Town and Country Planning Act 1990; Town Planning Applications Requiring DecisionsThis decision
  2. Town and Country Planning Act 1990: Town Planning Applications Requiring DecisionsRefused
  3. Town and Country Planning Act 1990: Town Planning Applications Requiring DecisionsRefused
  4. Town and Country Planning Act 1990: Town Planning Applications Requiring DecisionsApproved
  5. Town and Country Planning Act 1990: Town Planning Applications Requiring DecisionsRefused
  6. Town and Country Planning Act 1990: Town Planning Applications Requiring DecisionsDecided

More from Ashfield Planning Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
2 Sep 2026 Proposed and Recent Legislation and Policy Changes.RESOLVED that the report be received and noted. Noted Open
2 Sep 2026 Planning Appeal Decisions.RESOLVED that the report be received and noted. Noted Open
22 Jul 2026 Planning Appeal DecisionsRESOLVED that the report be received and noted. Noted Open
10 Jun 2026 Planning Appeal DecisionsRESOLVED that the report be received and noted. Noted Open
15 Apr 2026 Planning Appeal DecisionsRESOLVED that the report be received and noted. Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies