RESOLVED that Council be recommended to approve the appointment of [name removed] as an additional independent Trustee to the Sutton in Ashfield Recreation Grounds 2006 Charitable Trust. Reason: For the legal reasons set out in the report, an additional Trustee is required to be appointed in order for the land transactions to progress. The Council has been advised that the Trustee should have no prior/ongoing connections to the Council in order to ensure independence.
Word for word from the decision Ashfield published for this meeting.Source: democracy.ashfield.gov.uk
To seek authority to appoint an additional Trustee.
Recommendation(s)
To recommend that Council agrees to appoint, by Deed, [name removed] as an additional independent Trustee to the Sutton-in-Ashfield Recreation Grounds 2006 Charitable Trust.
Reasons for Recommendation(s)
The Council has previously approved a series of land transactions in order to release the Lammas Recreation Ground from the Trust restrictions to which it is subject and to impose the Trust restrictions upon part of the Sutton Lawn Pleasure Ground.
For the legal reasons set out in the report, an additional Trustee needs to be appointed in order for the land transactions to progress.
The Council has been advised that the Trustee should have no prior/ongoing connections to the Council in order to ensure independence.
Alternative Options Considered (with reasons why not adopted)
Not appointing an additional Trustee is not an option for the legal reasons set out in the report.
Other options for the appointment may be considered. Detailed Information
Background
Three parcels of land were conveyed to the then Sutton-in-Ashfield Urban District Council in 1914 by the 6th Duke of Portland and the Marquess of Titchfield as a gift. The three parcels of land consist of the Lammas Recreation Ground, Priestsic Recreation Ground and part of the Sutton Lawn Pleasure Ground (off the former Penn Street) all in Sutton-in-Ashfield.
Following the decision to build the Lammas Leisure Centre on part of the Lammas Recreation Ground, the Council became aware that, in conveying the land, a Charitable Trust was established requiring the parcels of land to be kept as open space and “used for recreation and pleasure ground” purposes. A clause was also entered into whereby if the land ceased to be used for recreation and pleasure ground purposes for 12 months or more then the Duke’s and Marquess’ successors could take the land back or “re-enter”. The successors are The Welbeck Estates Company Limited and The Welbeck Estates Company (Title) Limited (hereafter “Welbeck Estates”).
The Council entered into lengthy discussions with the Charity Commission in order to identify a means of freeing the Lammas Recreation Ground from the Trust restrictions. This can be achieved by the Council as Trustee “swapping” restricted land with other land within its corporate ownership which is not so restricted. Part of the Sutton Lawns was identified for this purpose and various authorities were given by Council some time ago in order for this to proceed. Before the transfer could take place the “re-entry” restriction had to also be removed.
Over a period of more than three years, the Council entered into negotiations with Welbeck Estates to release the “re-entry” clause. The negotiations were finally successful and the necessary legal work has been undertaken which allows the Council to proceed to deal with remaining Trust issues.
Legal Advice
In accordance with Council approvals, external legal support has been obtained in respect of the land transactions. The Council in its capacity of Trustee must have separate external legal provision as the Director of Legal and Governance cannot act for both sides of the transaction.
In obtaining this external advice, further stumbling blocks which make the progress of the transactions more complex have emerged.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.