CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Basingstoke and Deane Borough Council
Development Control Committee, Wednesday 12 November 2025 at 6.30pm

Determination of T/00402/24/TPO 95 Cavalier Road, Old Basing, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG24 7ER

Refused Planning 1 paper

AI summaryBasingstoke and Deane refused an application to fell three protected oak trees in Old Basing Conservation Area, citing insufficient evidence the trees caused structural damage to a neighbouring property.

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeRefusedWorks to three protected oak trees refused
Money£380,671Combined CAVAT amenity value of the three oaks
What happens nextRight of appeal to Secretary of State. Applicant may appeal the refusal
Who it affectsOld Basing Conservation Area; 95 Cavalier RoadThree mature oaks along former canal bed

What was decided

The Development Control Committee refused application T/00402/24/TPO to fell three oak trees protected by TPO/BDB/0472A and located within the Old Basing Conservation Area. Report 1.3, P7

Two earlier applications to fell the same trees were withdrawn in 2024. Report P5, P6

Why

Officers concluded the submitted evidence did not show, on the balance of probabilities, that the oaks were the substantial and effective cause of the structural damage to 95 Cavalier Road, with concerns over very shallow foundations, unverified drainage repairs and limited geotechnical testing. Report P75, P76, P77, P78, P79, 12.2

The council found the trees have significant ecological, visual and heritage value, contributing to the character of the Old Basing Conservation Area, and that their loss would conflict with Policy EM11 of the Local Plan and the Heritage SPD. Report P35, P36, P74, 12.1

What happens next

The applicant may appeal the refusal to the Secretary of State under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, and may in principle seek compensation under section 202E for loss or damage caused by the refusal. Report 4.1, 6.4

The decision notice will carry informatives advising on future evidence requirements and noting the decision does not constitute a tree safety inspection. Report P90, P91, P92, P93

The money

  • £380,671 Combined CAVAT amenity value of the three oaks Report P35
  • £50,000 Applicant's stated minimum estimated repair cost if trees remain Report P9
  • £21,000 Applicant's stated estimated repair cost if tree works proceed Report P9
  • £71,000 Applicant's stated total repair cost if trees remain, including alternative method Report P9

Options considered

  • Chosen: Refuse the application as recommended. Insufficient evidence the trees caused damage and harm to amenity and heritage Report 5.1, P51, P84
  • Rejected: Grant consent subject to conditions. Not supported by the evidence before the committee Report 5.3

Implications

  • Financial: Refusal may give rise to a compensation claim under section 202E of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, although no claim has been made. Report 6.4, 5.2
  • Legal: Any appeal to the Secretary of State would be determined under Part VIII of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 and the 2012 Tree Preservation Regulations. Report 4.1, 6.1
  • Legal: Ownership and access to the trees are private civil matters; the council's decision does not confer any right to enter third party land. Report P37
  • Equalities: Fifteen representations were received, all objections, from two Ward Members, Old Basing Parish Council, the Historic Environment Team and local residents. Report 2.1, 2.2
  • Climate: Objectors raised concerns about loss of trees and impact on climate change mitigation and biodiversity. Report P23, P24, P28
  • Risk: The applicant's own arboricultural report warns that removing vegetation on shrinkable soils can cause rehydration and heave, potentially worsening structural damage. Report P43, P80

Who and where

  • Owner and occupants of 95 Cavalier Road, Old Basing Report 1.3, P7
  • The King's Fund, as owner of the land on which the trees stand Report P18, P30
  • Local residents, Old Basing Parish Council and Ward Members who objected Report 2.1, 2.2
  • Old Basing Conservation Area, including historic canal route area 6b Report P16, P36

Timeline

  • 26.03.2024: Earlier application T/00136/24/TPO to fell the oaks was withdrawn Report P5
  • 12th August 2024: Application T/00402/24/TPO received by the council Report 1.3
  • 03.10.2024: Application T/00318/24/TPO to fell the oaks was withdrawn Report P6
  • 12/11/2025: Development Control Committee refused the application Report P94

Plain English for the jargon

  • Tree Preservation Order (TPO): A legal order made by a local authority to protect specific trees or woodland from being cut down, topped, lopped or uprooted without consent.
  • CAVAT: Capital Asset Value for Amenity Trees, a UK method for valuing a tree's amenity based on replacement cost and other criteria.
  • Heave: Upward ground movement caused by soils re-wetting, which can damage foundations and buildings.
  • Section 202E compensation: A statutory right to claim compensation from a council where loss or damage is caused by the refusal of consent for works to a protected tree.
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item55/25

Resolved

RESOLVED that: the application be REFUSED.
Word for word from the decision Basingstoke and Deane published for this meeting. Source: democracy.basingstoke.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Basingstoke and Deane's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Development Control Committee

Summary

This report summarises the key points of application T/00402/24/TPO for works to trees subject to a Tree Preservation Order (TPO) and sets out the reasons and basis upon which it is considered that the application should be refused.

Main considerations

1 Background and relevant history

1.1Planning History

T/00136/24/TPO T5, T6, T7 Oak trees: fell. Withdrawn 26.03.2024

T/00318/24/TPO T5 Oak: fell. Withdrawn 03.10.2024 T6 Oak: fell. T7 Oak: fell.

1 of 10 1.2 The application relates to three mature Oak trees situated along the former canal bed, adjacent to the rear boundary of 95 Cavalier Road, Old Basing. The trees are located within the Old Basing Conservation Area and are protected under Tree Preservation Order TPO/BDB/0472A.

1.3On 12th August 2024 the council received an application 360 Globalnet (agents acting for an insurance company) to fell trees subject to a Tree Preservation Order (T/00402/24/TPO). The proposal is to remove three Oak trees on land adjacent to the rear boundary of 95 Cavalier Road citing the works are required to stop the influence of trees on the soil below the building foundation level and to provide long term stability. The application states that: -

“the estimated costs of repair to the building is a minimum of £50,000 if the influence of trees remain and £21,000 if the proposed works are allowed to proceed. Granting permission will limit these costs. In the event of refusal we, or our clients, will seek to secure compensation for the additional costs incurred through Section 202(e). Should the trees remain the total cost of repairs will be superstructure repairs plus alternative method of repairs (minimum) of £71,000. It is the expert opinion of both the case engineer and the arborist that on the balance of probabilities the supporting information demonstrates the influence of trees’’.

The application was supported by a suite of professional reports as referenced within section 10 of this report.

2 Summary of representations

2.1A total of 15 representations were received. These comprise representations from two Ward Members, Old Basing Parish Council, the Historic Environment Team and local residents, all of which were objections to the proposal and as such, the application is being brought to the Development Control Committee to decide whether or not to permit the proposed tree removals.

2.2The objections are summarised as follows: -

a) The environmental benefits, community value, wildlife habitat and aesthetic importance of the subject trees.

b) The proposals risk setting a harmful precedent and undermining the protection afforded to trees within Conservation Areas or subject to Tree Preservation Orders (TPOs).

c) The Oaks are an important contribution to the wider setting of the historic environment of Old Basing. This area (known as 6b) was specifically added to the Old Basing Conservation Area during the 2020/21 review being the historic route of the Basingstoke Canal and positive contribution to the character and appearance of the area with the established tree belt. As such the proposals would seek to harm the significance of the designated heritage assets and conflict with Policy EM11 of the Local Plan and Principles CA01, SH01 and SH06 of the Heritage SPD.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Determination of T/00402/24/TPO 95 Cavalier Road, Old Basing, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG24 7ERReport 191 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting
53/25Minutes of the meeting held on the 24th September and 8th October 2025On the agenda 54/25Applications for planning permission and public participation thereonApproved
55/25Determination of T/00402/24/TPO 95 Cavalier Road, Old Basing, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG24 7ERThis decision

Who was there

11 of 12 attended
TD
Councillor Tony DurrantChair, present
AM
Councillor Andrew McCormickCommittee Member, present
MB
Councillor Mike BoundCommittee Member, present
RC
Councillor Richard CourtCommittee Member, present
AF
Councillor Angie FreemanVice-Chair, present
JG
Councillor Jay GaneshCommittee Member, present
PG
Councillor Paul GaskellCommittee Member, present
SG
Councillor Sheena GrassiCommittee Member, present
RH
Councillor Ronald HusseyCommittee Member, present
JJ
Councillor Julian JonesCommittee Member, present
KW
Councillor Karen WattsCommittee Member, present
KF
Katherine Fitzherbert-GreenOfficer, expected

On this subject at Basingstoke and Deane

Search all
  1. Determination of T/00402/24/TPO 95 Cavalier Road, Old Basing, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG24 7ERThis decision
  2. Determination of T/00121/25/TPO Ashley Lodge, Frescade Crescent, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 3NEApproved

More from Basingstoke and Deane Development Control Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
9 Sep 2026 Applications for planning permission and public participation thereonRESOLVED that : the application be APPROVED subject to the applicant entering into a Section 106 legal agreement unde... Approved Open
9 Sep 2026 Quarterly Planning Appeals ReportRESOLVED that: Members of the Development Control Committee note the outcomes of the appeal decisions and the reasons... Noted Open
12 Aug 2026 Applications for planning permission and public participation thereonRESOLVED that : the application be REFUSED for the following reason: Reason for Refusal 1 The proposed development by... Refused Open
8 Jul 2026 Applications for planning permission and public participation thereonRESOLVED that : the application be APPROVED subject to: · the completion of a Section 106 legal agreement under the T... Approved Open
10 Jun 2026 Applications for planning permission and public participation thereonRESOLVED that : the application be APPROVED subject to: · the completion of a Section 106 legal agreement under the T... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies