Description of Decision That the Minutes of the meeting of the Executive held on 4 January 2012 be confirmed, subject to the deletion of the pound sign (£) in Minute 78 RESOLVED (b) and to add in the Mayor’s response to Councillor Wootton’s question in Minute 71, that there would not be an inquiry. Reason for Decision There is a legal requirement for the Minutes of the previous meeting to be considered before being confirmed as an accurate record.
Word for word from the decision Bedford published for this meeting.Source: councillorsupport.bedford.gov.uk
PRESENT: The Mayor (in the Chair) Councillors Atkins, Headley, Holland S Hunt, McMurdo, Oliver, Rigby, Royden and Sawyer
Also Present: Councillors Foster and Wootton
71. QUESTIONS
Councillor Wootton - Question
Have the authors of the Meadow Lane report to the Executive on 13 July 2011 been identified? I do not wish for their identity to be revealed publicly, but is there awareness within the leadership of this Council as to who compiled the report?
Reply by the Mayor
The Mayor responded that he did know who had compiled the report.
Councillor Wootton - Question
Will there be an inquiry into the discrepancies between the report and the conclusions made by Spectrum Acoustic Consultants?
Reply by the Mayor
The Mayor responded that there would not be an inquiry and that the report to be considered at item 6 on the agenda demonstrated that the Council was moving forward on this matter.
Councillor Wootton - Statement
All well and good, but there should be an investigation into such an important issue. I am of the opinion that an explanation needs to be given as to why this report failed to refer to the overall conclusion of the independent assessment. I find it extraordinary that a different verdict was offered without explaining why the independent view should be overridden. I would, therefore, urge you to investigate this issue and to take action accordingly. This is an extremely important issue for villagers in Bletsoe, Bromham, Felmersham, Roxton,
1 4 January 2012
Stagsden, Staploe and Stevington and I feel that they deserve an explanation of why Spectrum‟s advice was not followed.
Councillor Foster - Question
As Ward Councillor for Harrold Ward I am very disappointed that the Borough did not agree to join with Milton Keynes Council in its application for Judicial Review of the Planning Inspector‟s decision in relation to Nun Wood. Advice from Counsel on which the Borough relied is dated 18 November 2011.
I am concerned that the decision whether or not to pursue a Judicial Review was made by Officers and was not put to the Members of the Planning Committee. I and the spokespersons for the three Groups on the Planning Committee were not informed that Milton Keynes Council was intending to file an application for Judicial Review until Friday 23 December 2011 when the deadline for a Judicial Review application was 4pm that day. This I find unacceptable as I understand that Officers were made aware of Milton Keynes Council‟s decision on Monday or Tuesday of that week.
Can I please ask the Chief Executive to ensure that, with highly controversial decisions such as this, the ultimate decision is left to the elected Members who are then given adequate time to consider the options available to them?
Are you aware that Milton Keynes Council took a second opinion from a different barrister after the Advice of 18 November 2011 and it was on the basis of that subsequent Advice that they made its decision to apply for Judicial Review? Did the Borough received a copy of that second opinion and if so when? I would like your assurance that our Officers will give Milton Keynes Council every assistance in its Judicial Review?
Reply by the Mayor
The Mayor responded that this matter was not an Executive function and the question would be more appropriate for the Planning Committee but said he would ask the Chief Executive to respond.
Reply by the Chief Executive
The Chief Executive responded that following concerns raised, he had already asked the Assistant Director responsible for Planning to discuss the issue with the Chair of the Planning Committee and the Spokespersons of the other two Groups, in order to streamline the process. He added that if Milton Keynes Council issued a request then this Council would offer practical assistance in their Judicial Review, although the Council had not given financial assistance as previously outlined.
2 4 January 2012
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Social Housing Allocations PolicyDescription of Decision (1) That the publication of the revised Bedford Borough (at Appendix A) on 1st September 2026...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.