Description of Decision (1) That a formal proposal be submitted to the Secretary of State to vary the part of the water fluoridation scheme to cease fluoridation at Manton Lane, Bedford as referenced by the Adult Services and Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee on the 15 June 2016. (2) That the required procedure be undertaken for varying aWater Fluoridation Schemeat Manton Lane as required by the Secretary of State for Health in accordance with the Public Health England’s toolkit which will necessitate the need to set up a joint committee across affected Councils in accordance with section 101 Local Government Act 1972. (3) That the regrettable fact that the recommendation to Full Council on 20 July 2016 did not accurately reflect the resolution of the Executive on 15 June 2016, be acknowledged and that Full Council be requested to endorse the above decisions. Reason for Decision Following receipt of the letter from the Department of Health refusing to accept that Bedford Borough Council has varied the current scheme, it is necessary to undertake the procedure for varying a water fluoridation scheme, as set out in Public Health England’s toolkit, so thatthe variation proposal canbe agreed bythe Secretary of State. To acknowledge that the recommendation from Executive on 15 June 2016 differed to that reported to Council.
Word for word from the decision Bedford published for this meeting.Source: councillorsupport.bedford.gov.uk
The Executive at its meeting of 7 September 2016 accepted the Adult Services and Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee’s recommendation which would result in the continuation of the variation not to artificially fluoridate the Boroughs water supply. Subsequently, the Council have now received a letter from the Department for Health stating that Public Health England in conjunction with Anglian Water do not accept that there has been a variation to Bedford Borough’s water fluoridation arrangements. Therefore, the Department for Health is unable to officially notify Anglian Water of the variation.
Recommendations
That the Executive be recommended to:
2.1Submit a formal proposal to the Secretary of State to vary the part of the water fluoridation scheme to cease fluoridation at Manton Lane Bedford as referenced by the Adults and Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee on the 15 June 2016.
2.2Undertake the required procedure for varying a Water Fluoridation Scheme at Manton Lane as required by the Secretary of State for Health in accordance with the Public Health England’s toolkit which will necessitate the need to set up a joint committee across affected Councils in accordance with section 101 Local Government Act 1972.
2.3Acknowledge the regrettable fact that the recommendation to Full Council on 20th July did not accurately reflect the resolution of the Executive on 15th June 2016 and that Full Council be requested to endorse the above recommendations.
6(1) 3. Reasons For Recommendations
3.1Following receipt of the letter from the Department of Health refusing to accept that Bedford Borough Council has varied the current scheme, this report sets out to the Executive the procedure for varying a water fluoridation scheme as set out in Public Health England’s toolkit, so that the variation proposal can be agreed by the Secretary of State
3.2To allow the Executive to acknowledge that the recommendation from Executive on 15th June 2016 differed to that reported to Council.
4. Key Implications
Legal Issues
4.1The legislation regarding artificial fluoridation of the water supply is the Water Industry Act 1991, as amended by the Health and Social Care Act 2012. Under the legislation, local authorities are responsible for water fluoridation schemes within their area. Regulations set out the consultation and decision-making process for local authorities where there is an existing scheme in place.
Counsel provided the opinion that the current water fluoridation scheme has been varied by Public Health England following a proposal from the Council, when the Mayor wrote to Public Health England in December 2014 to ask that there was no re-introduction of water fluoridation pending the outcome of the Adult Services and Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee health scrutiny review.
Following on from the letter received from the Department of Health (See appendix A) whereby they do not believe that the current water fluoridation scheme in operation within Bedford Borough has been varied since the scheme was established in 1971, the Council could seek to challenge this position through a Judicial Review, but given the potential costs it is considered appropriate to move forward on the basis of the response from the Office of the Secretary of State.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Social Housing Allocations PolicyDescription of Decision (1) That the publication of the revised Bedford Borough (at Appendix A) on 1st September 2026...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.