Resolved
Description of Decision (1) That Bedford Borough Council continues to provide the current recycling service (described as the ‘baseline’ in this WRAP report) including that no charge is made for green waste collection. (2) That the services continue to be operated in-house, and therefore for the CSO-E6 saving to be removed from the proposed BB2020 Programme savings target. (3) That it be noted that due to the contractual requirements and procurement timescales that Central Bedfordshire Council is working to, that any joint procurement options will not be possible this time around, so savings based on this predication are not an option. (4) That the current improvements to the recycling rate achieved by the current service and savings to date be noted. Reason for Decision Continuing with the current service commissioning and kerbside recycling options (described as the ‘baseline’ service) has the lowest modelled cost that also maintains a low financial risk to the Council at this time, whilst also providing the flexibility to the council in future to make changes if required. Furthermore, at this present time, it is clear that there is significant national and global uncertainty in the recycling market place for material. Income from the sale of recyclables has dramatically dropped over recent months and the market continues to be very uncertain. Option 4a, while modelled as the cheapest service, represents a radical change to our collection service and the actual financial performance could vastly differ from the model in case of: • Kerbside collection crews not meeting the productivity assumptions in the report • Changes in the value of materials collected and sold for recycling (as being reflected by the dramatic drop in income from current material sales). • Householder participation in recycling services not matching the model Taking into account the requirement for additional recycling and customer support staff, all the options for food waste collection would cost more than the baseline service, and come with a degree of uncertainty and therefore at this time a high financial risk to the Council. The impact in January 2018 of China’s implementation of its ‘National Sword’ operation has seen a more restrictive policy being applied on the waste recycling market this has led to some types of plastic being banned altogether, with additional quality requirements for those materials that are imported. These requirements have introduced greater volatility into the commodities markets and any previous assumptions about income need to be treated with extreme caution. An example of how this market volatility impacts upon the value of recyclates is seen in terms of mixed paper and corrugated containers. In terms of overall impact. The Environmental Audit Committee has described this issue as ‘the biggest problem the UK recycling industry has ever faced’. Furthermore there is also the impact on plastic containers is also likely to have an impact on the council and the recycling markets following a recent announcement, from Government (28 March 2018) that it intends to move forward with plans to implement a Drinks Return Scheme ...