LA04/2019/2273/F - Use of unit A as a supermarket with rear extension and loading bay, alterations to elevations and external trolley bay Unit A Holywood Exchange Retail Park, 304 Airport Road West
ApprovedPlanning1 paper
Planning Committee approved this item on Tuesday 19 May 2020. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
The application is approved subject to conditions as detailed in the case officer report with authority delegated to the Director of Planning and Building Control to finalise the wording of those conditions. The application is assessed as not impacting protected centres within the relevant catchment area. Appropriate controls are conditioned in respect of the retail offer at the proposed development. The design and materials are considered acceptable with no adverse impact on amenity. The proposal will lead to the creation of 26 jobs thus having a positive economic development impact. Whilst 2 objections were received in respect of traffic and associate issues, DFI has indicated that it has no objection to the proposal. It is assessed that the proposed development will not result in unacceptable impact in terms of traffic given existing uses. Members of the planning committee were consulted with the majority supportive of the proposed development. Briefing session to be held for committee members on retail planning policy and the sequential test.
Word for word from the decision Belfast published for this meeting.Source: minutes.belfastcity.gov.uk
The key issues in the assessment of the proposal are as follows: - The principle of a major foodstore at this location; - The economic impact of the proposal; - Impact on amenity / character of the area; - Impact on transport and other infrastructure. - Impact on natural environment;
The proposal seeks to alter an existing warehouse retail unit at Holywood Exchange (HE) to a supermarket in order to permit the sale of convenience and comparison goods. Bulky goods are generally sold from such units, which is secured by planning condition such as in this case. Alterations are also proposed including to the rear of the building to facilitate goods access.
The proposal has a net sales floorspace of 1376 sqm. 1101 sqm would be for convenience goods, with 275 sqm for the sale of comparison goods. The proposal relates to a named operator Lidl, who are already operating from other locations within East Belfast and Dundonald. It should be noted however, that any planning permission cannot be linked to an operator, rather the scale and nature of retailing can only be linked to the site. Thus, if permission was granted, any operator could trade from the retail unit subject to compliance with any conditions deemed appropriate. The applicant indicates that the proposal would have a turnover of approximately £8.04m in the design year of 2021.
The site is not subject to any zonings in dBMAP, and whilst located within a complex of retail warehouse uses, it is outside any designated retail centres identified within both the BUAP and dBMAP. It is therefore sited in an ‘out of centre’ location.
A review of available sites indicates there are no sequentially preferable locations available within the city centre and district centres. The proposal therefore meets the sequential test. Application ID: LA04/2019/2273/F
In terms of convenience impact, it is considered that the proposal is likely to draw the majority of trade from Sainsbury’s HE, Home Bargains HE, and Tesco Knocknagoney by virtue of a combination of proximity and similarity factors. Following assessment of the economic information, on balance, it is considered that the majority of trade will be drawn from unprotected locations and as such the scale of impact on protected centres is not likely to be significant.
In relation to comparison impacts, the Agent asserts that the majority of trade would be diverted from unprotected centres. Following assessment of the economic information it is considered that the proposal is unlikely to draw a significant amount of trade away from any protected centres within the catchment area.
It is also considered that the proposal, when assessed individually and cumulatively with other extant retail permissions within the catchment, would not adversely affect the vitality and viability of protected centres within its catchment area.
No evidence has been presented within the submitted assessment to decisively demonstrate that a need for the proposal exists. That said, assessment of the Retail Impact Assessment (RIA) indicates that adverse impacts on protected centres are unlikely to occur. On balance, this consideration outweighs the need for the proposal in this instance.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
LA04/2019/2273/F: Use of unit A as a supermarket with rear extension and loading bay, alterations to elevations and external trolley bay Unit A Holywood Exchange Retail Park, 304 Airport Road WestMinutes
3cLA04/2019/2273/F - Use of unit A as a supermarket with rear extension and loading bay, alterations to elevations and external trolley bay Unit A Holywood Exchange Retail Park, 304 Airport Road WestThis decision
LA04/2019/2273/F - Use of unit A as a supermarket with rear extension and loading bay, alterations to elevations and external trolley bay Unit A Holywood Exchange Retail Park, 304 Airport Road WestThis decision
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.