LA04/2020/2200/F & LA04/2020/2201/DCA - Demolition of Nos. 27 to 37 Linenhall Street and Nos. 8-10 Clarence Street and erection of seven storey office building at 8-10 Clarence Street 27-37 Linenhall Street and existing car park at the corner of Linenhall Street and Clarence Street
AgreedPlanning1 paper
Planning Committee agreed this item on Tuesday 20 April 2021. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved - That the Committee agrees to defer consideration of the application to allow the developer to submit further information in respect of viability and improvements to public realm. The Committee noted, as the application had not been presented, that all Members’ present at the next meeting, would be able to take part in the debate and vote on this item.
Word for word from the decision Belfast published for this meeting.Source: minutes.belfastcity.gov.uk
Applications seeking demolition of Nos. 27 to 37 Linenhall Street and Nos. 8-10 Clarence Street and erection of seven storey office building (circa 6000 sqm floor space).
The key issues in the assessment of the proposed development include: Principle of a building on the site Demolition within the Linen Conservation Area Impact on Built Heritage Impact on character and appearance of the Linen Conservation Area Design Acceptability of Office Use at this location Traffic and Parking Impact on Amenity Impact on Historic Monuments Drainage and Flooding Pre-application Community Consultation Air Quality Waste Water Treatment Developer Contributions
1. The principle of the proposed office use is acceptable in this city centre location. 2. 3. However, the scale, height, massing, alignment and form of the building will have a detrimental impact upon the setting of a number of listed buildings, including the Ulster Hall. HED objects to the proposal on grounds of harm to the setting of listed buildings, contrary to Policy BH11 of Planning Policy Statement 6. Application ID: LA04/2020/2200/F
4. The proposal includes the demolition of two buildings, one on Clarence Street and one on Linenhall Street. The principle of demolition of the building on Linenhall Street, which makes a positive contribution to the character of the Linen Conservation Area, is not acceptable and the proposed redevelopment scheme does not enhance the character and appearance of the area as it is of a scale and massing which is unsympathetic to the adjoining buildings and the characteristic built form of the area. Both the Conservation Officer and Urban Design Officer object to the proposal. 5. The Council has a duty to adopt a precautionary principle and when considering demolition of a building which makes a positive contribution (to the character of a conservation area): there should be clear and convincing evidence that all reasonable efforts have been made to sustain existing uses or find viable new uses, and that these efforts have failed. The onus therefore is on the applicant to provide detailed evidence in support of such claims.
In the absence of such evidence (as is the case here), the determining factor in assessing demolition of these buildings will therefore be the merits of the alternative proposals. For the reasons stated above, and amplified in the main body of the report, the proposed redevelopment scheme is deemed to be unacceptable. It would have a detrimental impact on the setting of Listed Buildings and harmful to the character and appearance of the Conservation Area.
6. DAERA and NI Water have advised that at present the waste water treatment infrastructure does not have sufficient capacity to serve the proposed development and no acceptable, alternative solution has been proposed. However, for the reasons set out in the main report, it is considered that this issue could be addressed by a suitably worded planning condition and a refusal reason on this issue is not considered appropriate.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
LA04/2020/2200/F & LA04/2020/2201/DCA: Demolition of Nos. 27 to 37 Linenhall Street and Nos. 8-10 Clarence Street and erection of seven storey office building at 8-10 Clarence Street 27-37 Linenhall Street and existing car park at the corner of Linenhall Street and Clarence StreetMinutes
9eLA04/2020/2200/F & LA04/2020/2201/DCA - Demolition of Nos. 27 to 37 Linenhall Street and Nos. 8-10 Clarence Street and erection of seven storey office building at 8-10 Clarence Street 27-37 Linenhall Street and existing car park at the corner of Linenhall Street and Clarence StreetThis decision
LA04/2020/2200/F & LA04/2020/2201/DCA - Demolition of Nos. 27 to 37 Linenhall Street and Nos. 8-10 Clarence Street and erection of seven storey office building at 8-10 Clarence Street 27-37 Linenhall Street and existing car park at the corner of Linenhall Street and Clarence StreetThis decision
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.