CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Blaby District Council
Scrutiny Commission, Wednesday 13 May 2009

Scrutiny Update and Working Group Progress

Decided Scrutiny 2 papers

Scrutiny Commission decided this item on Wednesday 13 May 2009. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item482

Resolved

RECOMMENDATION TO COUNCIL That any Member of Scrutiny Commission can be appointed to Chair the Commission meeting in the event of the Commission Chairman and Vice-Chairman being absent from the meeting. Reason: To remove the restriction placed upon members of the majority political group (in particular the relevant Scrutiny Commissioner) that they are ineligible take the position of Chairman for a meeting of Scrutiny Commission where the normal Chairman and Vice-Chairman are not in attendance.
Word for word from the decision Blaby published for this meeting. Source: democracy.blaby.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Blaby's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Scrutiny Commission

Purpose of report

1.1This report provides a progress update of the work being undertaken by Scrutiny Working Groups, other scrutiny information and updates.

Recommendation

2. Decision recommended

The Scrutiny Commission is asked to consider:

1) progress in relation to work undertaken by the Working Groups

2) recommendations of Working Groups as set out in the report at para. 6.2.

3) Give any consequential instructions to the Working Groups.

3. Reason for Decision Recommended

For the Scrutiny Commission to monitor progress of Working Groups in relation to agreed work as set out in review scopes and give consequential instructions as required.

4. Forward Plan

4.1Not applicable.

5. Key Decision

5.1Not applicable. 6. Matter(s) for Consideration

6.1Progress of the Working Groups is attached at Appendix 1. Verbal updates will be provided by Working Group Lead Members where meetings have been held since circulation of this report.

Chairing the Scrutiny Commission

6.2At its meeting on 11 March the Scrutiny Commission questioned the reason for the constitutional restriction of nominating a member of the non-controlling political group for the meeting in the absence of both the Scrutiny Commission Chairman and Vice- Chairman at the meeting. And why the third Commissioner, if in attendance, shouldn’t automatically chair the meeting in the first instance. The Commission therefore recommended:

‘that the Scrutiny Commissioners review the Constitution in relation to chairing of the Commission and report back to the next available Scrutiny Commission meeting.’

6.3Part 4 Section 5 paragraph 6 of the Constitution in relation to ‘Who Chairs the Scrutiny Commission meetings?’ states:

‘Any Member of the Non-controlling Political Groups is eligible to be the Chairman of the Scrutiny Commission’.

6.4Chairing a Scrutiny Commission meeting is not an appointed position and unfortunately has been misinterpreted as such therefore Scrutiny only allowing members of the Non-controlling Political Groups.

RECOMMENDATION 6.5 To provide clarity it is recommended that Part 4 Section 5 paragraph 6 in the Constitution be amended as follows:-

‘that any Member of the Scrutiny Commission can be appointed to Chair the Commission meeting in the event of the Commission Chairman and Vice- Chairman being absent’

The Sickness Absence Working Group

At the date of circulation of this report the Working Group’s final report was being finalised. It will therefore be distributed prior to the meeting.

7. Other Options Considered

7.1Not applicable.

8. Appropriate Consultations

8.1None 9. Financial and Asset Implications

9.1None in relation to this report.

10. Appendix to this report

Appendix 1 – Scrutiny Working Group progress report

11. List of Background Papers

None

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Commission Wk Grp Progress rpt 13 MAY 09 App 1.xlsAppendix 18 KB Download
PDF
Scrutiny Update and Working Group ProgressReport 24 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

12 of 29 attended
GW
Councillor Geoff WelshChair- Scrutiny Commissioner, present
PN
Councillor P. N. FoxVice-Chair - Scrutiny Commissioner, present
AT
Councillor Alan TannerScrutiny Commissioner, present
JB
Councillor. J. BellMember, present
ED
Councillor E.C. DawsonSubstitute, present as substitute
JD
Councillor J.A. DilksMember, present
FD
Councillor F.E. DuffieldMember, present
JF
Councillor Janet ForeyMember, present
DJ
Councillor David JenningsMember, present
DP
Councillor D. PollardSubstitute, present as substitute
RC
Councillor R. C. WardSubstitute, present as substitute
JL
Councillor J. L. WeatherstoneMember, present

All 29 on the meeting page

On this subject at Blaby

Search all
  1. Scrutiny Update and Working Group ProgressThis decision
  2. Scrutiny Update and Working Group ProgressAgreed
  3. Scrutiny Update and Working Groups Progress ReportAgreed
  4. Scrutiny Update and Working Group ProgressAgreed
  5. Cabinet Executive Response to Scrutiny Recommendations - Final Report of the DDA Review Working GroupDecided
  6. Cabinet Executive Response to Scrutiny Recommendations - Final Report of the Car Parking Review Working GroupDecided

More from Blaby Scrutiny Commission

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
9 Sep 2026 Scrutiny Work ProgrammeIt was agreed that the Local Government Reorganisation work be paused to reflect the Government's announcement earlie... Agreed Open
17 Jun 2026 Homelessness BriefingIt was agreed that the Commissioners would discuss a suitable date at their next meeting. Members placed on record th... Agreed Open
12 Nov 2025 Cabinet Executive Response to Scrutiny Recommendations: Review into Recruitment and Retention of StaffIt was agreed that a senior officer would respond to the response at the next Scrutiny Commissioners meeting. Agreed Open
28 Oct 2025 Local Government Reorganisation and DevolutionAgreed shared data sets with County and City Inc. population figures, adults and children's social care data? o Popul... Agreed Open
17 Jul 2024 Financial Performance 2023/24It was agreed that the response to the above questions be considered at the next Scrutiny Commissioners meeting. Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies