CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Blaby District Council
Scrutiny Commission, Wednesday 21 April 2010

Implementation of Car Park Charges Review - Scrutiny Working Group Final Report

Decided Scrutiny 5 papers

Scrutiny Commission decided this item on Wednesday 21 April 2010. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item415

Resolved

Recommendation That Cabinet Executive: Notes the findings of the Scrutiny Car Park Charges Working Group and fully considers the comments and requests of consultees in relation to car park charges. Provide to Scrutiny Commission as a matter of urgency a robust breakdown of costs for 2009/10, against income and the budget for 2010/11, with both costs and expected income. a) considers extending the one hour free parking to two hours at Enderby Road, Johns Court and Wigston Road in Blaby. OR b) considers one hour free parking with an hourly charging structure thereafter. Explores if options are available to provide three day, five day and six day a week parking permits to provide a flexible payment option for part – time workers. Continues to explore ways to improve car park ticket machines functionality in poor light and weather conditions. Reviews the charging structure at Winston Avenue, Croft due to the sites unique characteristics as described in on page 7 of the report of the Car Park Charges Scrutiny Working Group. That the Market Town Development Project Team and Blaby Parish Council liaise with Blaby Distict Council officers to assess the business type and mix in Blaby. This should include influences on the length of stay in the shoping area for shoppers and visitors to Blaby. This will assist in developing a vibrant and interesting mix of shoppers experiences, including leisure and entertainment programmes during the year. As part of the Local Travel Plan Strategy, Leicestershire County Council is asked to collate local district car park charging structures to enable effective benchmarking and monitoring data information. That Leicestershire County Council Highways Team examine residents and businesses comments in Appendices A, B and C and report traffic regulations options available to Blaby District Council, the Environmental Protection Group Manager and the Scrutiny Commission. That the Working Group reviews the impact of car park charges on businesses in Blaby in November 2010, one year after the implementation of car park charges in the district.
Word for word from the decision Blaby published for this meeting. Source: democracy.blaby.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Blaby's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Scrutiny Commission

Implementation of Car Park Charges Scrutiny Review

Car Park Charges Working Group

1 Contents

1. Introduction 2. Conclusion and recommendations 3. Methodology 4. Evidence and findings 5. Car parking usage, costs and income 6. Other district car parking arrangements 7. Conclusions 8. Appendices a. Response from residents to scrutiny leaflet b. Response from businesses and those working in Blaby and Croft c. Other authorities charges d. Photographs identifying displacement problems

Car Park Charges Scrutiny Working Group Members

Cllr David Jennings – Chairman Cllr Alex Dilks Cllr J Roper Cllr J Springthorpe Cllr A Tanner Cllr J Weatherstone

The Working Group would like to extend its thanks to residents who kindly gave their time to speak to scrutiny members and to those who provided written responses. Also, Blaby Police Unit, Leicestershire County Council, Highways South Area Officers, Phil Jennings, Croft Parish Clerk, [name removed], a resident of Winston Avenue and Max Boden, Policy Manager at the Leicestershire Chamber of Commerce

2 1. Introduction

In February 2010 the Scrutiny Commission considered a report from the Environmental Protection Group Manager outlining key areas of a car parking review that was being undertaken and would be reported to Cabinet Executive on 26 April 2010.

The Commission recommended that the Scrutiny Car Parking Working Group be reconvened to look at the implementation of car parking charges since introduction in October 2009, and report its findings and recommendations to Scrutiny Commission in April 2010.

Whilst the consultation exercise being carried out by the Council was assessed against the Car Parking Strategy aims, set out further within this report, the Working Group defined its aims and objectives as:-

Undertaking a quick touch review to look at the Car Parking strategy and implementation since October 2009 including:

• All parking areas where the regime has changed • Car park costs and usage • Net overall income/overheads • Effects of displacement • Take evidence from the public, businesses and officers

The Working Group was of the view that the impact of displacement and on- street parking had not been fully explored from the perspective of residents and car park users and reflected a gap in the Council’s consultation process.

Due to the tight timescale to complete this work the Working Group focused its closer examination on Blaby Town Centre and Winston Avenue, Croft, which were known to have problems with displacement.

The Working Group excluded car parks in Narborough as they had been reviewed and reported to Cabinet Executive in November 2009.

The Working Group has not had the opportunity to consider other Parish consultation responses received by the Environmental Protection Manager.

3 2. Conclusions and recommendations

The main findings of the consultation Scrutiny undertook with Blaby Town Centre car park users, residents and staff working in the town centre are:

• Prior to the introduction of car park charges Blaby car parks were so full that people were parking on-street. The introduction of charges has solved the availability of spaces for short-term parking but displaced those who require long-stay parking in Blaby.

• The cost of long stay parking is expensive for those working in Blaby and also for charity organisations. Parking on street, while free to the driver, creates problems both from a road safety and community relations perspective. The Blaby Policing Unit refers to this on page 9 in this report.

• The clear message from car park users and businesses in Blaby town centre is that one hour free parking is insufficient.

• The lack of robust financial information on costs provided by the Environmental Protection Team is a concern.

• Car park users feel the requirement to display a ticket for free parking is confusing and not user friendly. The flexible payment options available from ticket machine were commented on as better than other Districts.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Final car parking reportReport 995 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
Final car parking report: App AAppendix 68 KB Download
PDF
Final car parking report: App BAppendix 25 KB Download
PDF
Final car parking report: App CAppendix 12 KB Download
PDF
Implementation of Car Park Charges Review: Scrutiny Working Group Final ReportReport 31 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting
415Implementation of Car Park Charges Review - Scrutiny Working Group Final ReportThis decision

Who was there

11 of 24 attended
JB
Councillor. J. BellMember, apologies
ED
Councillor E.C. DawsonMember, present
JD
Councillor J.A. DilksMember, present
JA
Councillor J. A. DolbyMember, present
FD
Councillor F.E. DuffieldMember, present
JM
Councillor J. M. FoxMember, apologies
DF
Councillor David FreerMember, absent
JK
Councillor J. KenneyMember, present
MM
Councillor M. MurphyMember, absent
EP
Councillor E. ParsonsMember, present
DP
Councillor D. PollardMember, absent
GS
Councillor Gary SandersMember, present

All 24 on the meeting page

On this subject at Blaby

Search all
  1. Implementation of Car Park Charges Review - Scrutiny Working Group Final ReportThis decision
  2. Cabinet Executive Response to Scrutiny Recommendations: Scrutiny Monitoring Report - Implementation of Car Parking ChargesApproved
  3. Scrutiny Monitoring Report: Implementation of Car Park ChargesDecided
  4. Proposed Car Parking Strategy and ImplementationApproved

More from Blaby Scrutiny Commission

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
9 Sep 2026 Scrutiny Work ProgrammeIt was agreed that the Local Government Reorganisation work be paused to reflect the Government's announcement earlie... Agreed Open
17 Jun 2026 Homelessness BriefingIt was agreed that the Commissioners would discuss a suitable date at their next meeting. Members placed on record th... Agreed Open
12 Nov 2025 Cabinet Executive Response to Scrutiny Recommendations: Review into Recruitment and Retention of StaffIt was agreed that a senior officer would respond to the response at the next Scrutiny Commissioners meeting. Agreed Open
28 Oct 2025 Local Government Reorganisation and DevolutionAgreed shared data sets with County and City Inc. population figures, adults and children's social care data? o Popul... Agreed Open
17 Jul 2024 Financial Performance 2023/24It was agreed that the response to the above questions be considered at the next Scrutiny Commissioners meeting. Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies