CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Boston Borough Council
Cabinet, Wednesday 7 September 2016

HOUSES IN MULTIPLE OCCUPATION AND LEGISLATIVE POWERS INCLUDING ARTICLE 4 DIRECTIONS, AVAILABLE TO THE COUNCIL

Noted Executive 5 papers

Cabinet noted this item on Wednesday 7 September 2016. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item21

Resolved

DECISION That, in the light of the information contained within the report (including the attached appendices) and the recommendations received from the Corporate and Community Committee, and having recognition of financial and resource implications on the Council: 1. It is not an expedient and worthwhile exercise to bring into being an Article 4 Direction removing Permitted Development Rights for small HMOs and it would not benefit the Borough overall. 2. Cabinet looks forward to receiving a future report from the Corporate & Community Committee in due course on the impact of licensing HMOs and the Council Tax banding of separate occupied units. 3. The current work ongoing relating to the development of the HMO policy in respect of the South East Lincolnshire Local Plan is noted. Portfolio Holder and Officer Cllrs Bedford & Cooper SL REASON FOR DECISION The Leader introduced a report on Houses in Multiple Occupation (HMOs), which explained the legislative powers available to the Council, including Article 4 Directions. Full Council on 25 April 2016 agreed to undertake a review of all legislative tools that might be available to the Council and to consider whether an Article 4 Direction introduced under the planning legislation would help Boston by seeking to bring in controls and to limit HMOs. This review was also to consider what representations might be made to the emerging local plan in this context. The report detailed Article 4 Directions, their advantages and disadvantages, and their potentially significant resource implications. A Direction would mean that proposals for smaller HMOs would normally require planning permission for the first time. The report also referred to the emerging South East Lincolnshire Local Plan and the development of a strategic HMO policy proposed within that. The request from Council stemmed from concerns arising from parts of Boston’s community and from some elected Members about the perceived negative impacts of HMOs large and small, which included increased levels of rubbish; noise and disturbance; anti-social behaviour; traffic and parked cars; and impact on overall residential character etc. The Head of Built Environment & Development explained that Members had to consider various issues, including the fact that an Article 4 Direction was not retrospective, was not a ban on HMOs, that evidence would be required to refuse planning permission and that there would be significant resource implications, particularly as no fee could be charged for applications. Also to be considered was the experience of other authorities that had introduced the Direction and the views of the national Association of Landlords, which were detailed in the appendices. The Head of Built Environment & Development added that the South East Lincolnshire HMO Policy, which had previously been general, had since been improved and strengthened and did not require further representation from the Council. The report had been considered at the Corporate & Community Committee meeting of 5 th September at which the Committee had made the following resolution: 1. That it be recommended to Cabinet that the Committee considers that it would not be an expedient or worthwhile exercise ... view the full minutes text for item 21.
Word for word from the decision Boston published for this meeting. Source: democracy.boston.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Boston's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cabinet, 8 pages

Summary

Full Council on 25 April 2016 agreed to undertake a review of all legislative tools that may be available to the Council and to consider whether an Article 4 Direction introduced under the planning legislation, would help Boston, by seeking to bring in controls and to limit HMOs. Also to include within this review what representations might be made to the emerging local plan in this context.

This report covers the matter appertaining to Article 4 Directions and asks the Cabinet to consider the pros and cons and the potentially significant resource implications of proceeding to introduce such a Direction. A Direction would mean that proposals for smaller ‘Houses in Multiple Occupation’ (HMO’s) would normally require planning permission for the first time. The report will also make reference to the emerging South East Lincolnshire Local Plan and the development of a strategic HMO policy proposed within that.

The request from Council stems from concerns arising from parts of Boston’s community and from some elected members about the perceived negative impacts of HMO’s large and small. These perceptions include:

 Increased levels of rubbish left outside properties  Noise and disturbance  Anti-social behaviour  Increased traffic and more parked cars  Change on overall residential character and over concentration of HMO tenure type – for the worse  Unkempt garden areas  Loss of needed family homes

On the other hand the question that must be asked is; ‘Do all HMO’s have such associated issues?’ If not, what proportion does and is there evidence for this? And to be balanced with the fact that HMO’s provide much needed housing accommodation for various sections of the community where family living is not needed or sought. Would the reasons for seeking an Article 4 Direction be part of an intention to restrict supply or better manage future development to ensure they do not lead to over concentration?

We might also need to consider if there is a distinction between ‘small’ and ‘large’ HMOs and what the quantitative split is between them is how many there are of each and where they are, probably requiring surveys .We need to know if it is the large or the small HMO which create a perceived or actual problem?

The Corporate and Community Committee considered and discussed this same report on 5th September 2016 and a verbal report on its conclusions and recommendations will be provided to Cabinet at its meeting.

Recommendations

That Cabinet considers the resolution made by Council, and in the light of the information contained within this report (including the attached appendices) in addition to the comments and recommendations received from the Corporate and Community Committee, considers:

1) as to whether further work to bring into being an Article 4 Direction removing Permitted Development Rights for small HMO’s is an expedient and worthwhile exercise and will benefit the Borough overall, having recognition of financial and resource implications on the Council and IF it does, then the Cabinet further seeks to undertake a separate costings exercise so as to properly understand the financial and staffing implications and the budget provision be found, before any final decision is made to progress.

2) that Cabinet notes current work ongoing relating to the development of HMO policy in respect of the South East Lincolnshire Local Plan and offers any further comments that might assist the finalisation of that policy.

Reasons for recommendations

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Example Guidance Note from City of Nottingham: “Planning Rules for Houses in Multiple Occupation”Appendix 1 11 pages Download
PDF
Houses in Multiple Occupation: Lincoln Supplementary Planning DocumentAppendix 2 19 pages Download
PDF
Residential Landlords Association: “The case against Article 4 directions for small houses in multiple occupation (HMOs)”Appendix 3 19 pages Download
PDF
Draft South East Lincolnshire Local Plan extracts relating to HMOsAppendix 4 3 pages Download
PDF
HOUSES IN MULTIPLE OCCUPATION AND LEGISLATIVE POWERS INCLUDING ARTICLE 4 DIRECTIONS, AVAILABLE TO THE COUNCILReport 8 pages DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

More from Boston Cabinet

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
24 Jun 2026 Draft Outturn 2025/26That the draft outturn revenue position of a £0.064m underspend for 2025/26, as detailed in Appendix A – Table 1 with... Noted Open
24 Jun 2026 Local Council Tax Support Scheme 2027/28 - ConsultationThat the consultation to retain the current scheme, updated in line with the Department for Work and Pension (DWP) an... Approved Open
24 Jun 2026 South & East Lincolnshire Destination Management PlanThat the South & East Lincolnshire Destination Management Plan 2026 – 2030, attached in Appendix A to the report, be ... Approved Open
24 Jun 2026 Public Spaces Protection Order for Dog ControlsThat, after taking into account the consultation feedback, the proposal to extend the Public Spaces Protection Order ... Approved Open
24 Jun 2026 Strategy / Policy Review and DevelopmentThat the policies and strategies listed in Appendix A be extended to 31 March 2028 where their current expiry date is... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies