CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Boston Borough Council
Cabinet, Wednesday 19 October 2016

DISCLOSURE AND BARRING SERVICE (DBS) CHECKS

Approved Executive 2 papers

Cabinet approved this item on Wednesday 19 October 2016. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item29

Resolved

DECISION That full Council be recommended to take no further action in respect of conducting DBS checks on elected Members due to the associated legal restrictions. Portfolio Holder and Officer Cllr Bedford KN REASON FOR DECISION The Leader introduced a report by the Head of HR and Transformation on a proposal to conduct Disclosure Barring Service checks (DBS) on elected Members. The report stated that at a meeting of the Council held on 11 July, a Motion on Notice was submitted asking Council to approve that a voluntary scheme be adopted allowing the Council to request DBS checks for elected Members. Following debate it was agreed to refer the motion to the Corporate and Community Committee for full evaluation of all the implications and a recommendation be submitted to a future meeting of the Cabinet and Council. The report explained that the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 (PFA) introduced changes to the arrangements for carrying out criminal records checks, including the merger of the Criminal Records Bureau and the Independent Safeguarding Authority in December 2012 to form a new body called the Disclosure and Barring Service. The DBS provided access to criminal records and other relevant information for organisations in England and Wales and was also responsible for investigating safeguarding concerns and maintaining the barred lists for children and adults and the combined list, which were statutory lists containing details of people considered unsuitable to work with children and/or adults. The changes introduced under the PFA scaled back the number of activities involving work with children and adults that were ‘regulated’. Individuals on a barred list could not undertake a regulated activity and it would be a criminal offence for the Council to allow an individual to do so without first checking whether they were on a barred list. However, the revised definition of regulated activity was one of involving close work with vulnerable groups, including children. The legislation also redefined and reduced the scope of regulated activity, examples included being employed in a position that involved regular undertaking of unsupervised activities such as caring for or supervising children, regularly working for establishments such as children’s centres and providing personal care to an adult in a care home or day care centre. As the majority of Councillors did not have unsupervised contact with children or adults as part of their role they would not be involved in regulated activity. Therefore, unless activities fell within the redefined scope of regulated activity Councillors were not required to be checked by virtue only of their position as a Councillor. Given that the Council was not a first tier authority and councillors were not involved in education or social services activity as a primary function there was unlikely to be any regulated activity occurring. The Council could still request that DBS checks be carried out if it was possible to demonstrate that the requirement met legislative conditions. As those conditions related to social care and education it would be difficult for a second tier ... view the full minutes text for item 29.
Word for word from the decision Boston published for this meeting. Source: democracy.boston.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Boston's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cabinet, 7 pages

Summary

This matter was debated by Council in June following a motion on notice. It was agreed a report would be taken to the Corporate & Community Committee for it to consider the matter further; an update on the result of its consideration at its next meeting on 6th October will be included in the final report to Cabinet.

It is not recommended that any changes be made to the current arrangements of not checking councillors at our authority unless a case for checking specific roles exists on a case by case basis. Changes to the legislation have made the test more difficult to satisfy. It is interesting to note (attached) a letter from the DBS to Cornwall County Council and also the position of an elected member from Cornwall who has been deemed a risk to children by the Council but who has not been charged with any offence and is still in office.

Recommendations

For Cabinet to consider the report and the comments from the Corporate & Community Committee.

Reasons for recommendations

As agreed by Council in June 2016.

ALTERNATIVES CONSIDERED

There is a note on the Disclosure Scotland service as an alternative option in this report. REPORT

1. Reforms to CRB and Independent Safeguarding Authority

1.1The Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 (“PFA”) introduced changes to the arrangements for carrying out criminal records checks. One of the key changes involved the merger of the Criminal Records Bureau (“CRB”) and the Independent Safeguarding Authority (“ISA”) in December 2012 to form a new body called the Disclosure and Barring Service (“DBS”).

1.2The DBS is a non-departmental public body, sponsored by the Home Office. The DBS provides access to criminal records and other relevant information for organisations in England and Wales and is also responsible for investigating safeguarding concerns and maintaining the barred lists for Children and Adults and the combined list (these are statutory lists containing details of people considered unsuitable to work with children and/or adults).

2 Types of check

2.1There are two levels of DBS checks that can be carried out. Standard DBS checks which show disclose previous cautions, convictions, police reprimands and warnings relating to an individual. Enhanced Checks (without a check of the barred lists) provide the information resulting from a standard DBS check with the addition of relevant police information provided by the local police force. Chief police officers are asked to provide any information which they “reasonably believe to be” “relevant and ought to be included in the [enhanced DBS] certificate”, having regard to the purpose for which the certificate is sought.

2.2To address concerns about proportionality, the Government has recently introduced legislation to prevent certain minor and old convictions and cautions from being revealed by a DBS check.

3. Changes to the definition of Regulated Activity

3.1The changes introduced under the PFA not only affected the administrative arrangements but also scaled back the number of activities, involving work with children and adults, that are regulated; these are known as “regulated activities”. Individuals on a barred list for children and/or adults cannot undertake a “regulated activity” and it is a criminal offence for the Council to allow an individual to do so without first checking whether they are on a barred list. That it is why it is important for the Council to carry out pre-appointment checks in relation to individuals appointed to positions that involve the carrying out of a “regulated activity”.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Cornwall-letter-from-DBSAppendix A 3 pages Download
PDF
DISCLOSURE AND BARRING SERVICE (DBS) CHECKSReport 7 pages DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

On this subject at Boston

Search all
  1. DISCLOSURE AND BARRING SERVICE (DBS) CHECKSThis decision
  2. Disclosure and barring service (dbs) checksDecided

More from Boston Cabinet

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
24 Jun 2026 Draft Outturn 2025/26That the draft outturn revenue position of a £0.064m underspend for 2025/26, as detailed in Appendix A – Table 1 with... Noted Open
24 Jun 2026 Local Council Tax Support Scheme 2027/28 - ConsultationThat the consultation to retain the current scheme, updated in line with the Department for Work and Pension (DWP) an... Approved Open
24 Jun 2026 South & East Lincolnshire Destination Management PlanThat the South & East Lincolnshire Destination Management Plan 2026 – 2030, attached in Appendix A to the report, be ... Approved Open
24 Jun 2026 Public Spaces Protection Order for Dog ControlsThat, after taking into account the consultation feedback, the proposal to extend the Public Spaces Protection Order ... Approved Open
24 Jun 2026 Strategy / Policy Review and DevelopmentThat the policies and strategies listed in Appendix A be extended to 31 March 2028 where their current expiry date is... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies