Item31
Resolved
DECISION That the recommendation from the Environment and Performance Committee that all charges for replacement green and blue wheeled bins be abolished, be not accepted. Portfolio Holder and Officer Cllr Stevens CA A specific recommendation had been referred to Cabinet from the Environment and Performance committee in respect of charges for replacement wheeled bins. The Committee had considered a report at its meeting on 24 September 2019, in response to a resolution agreed at its meeting on 24 July that charges for replacement wheeled bins be added to the work programme. The report stated that a charge of £25 for replacement 240L green and blue bins had been introduced in the 2013/14 budget report, which had been considered by the Corporate and Community Committee, Audit and Governance Committee, Cabinet and full Council as part of the budget setting process. At an Inquiry Evening held on 14 January 2019 on the draft Waste and Recycling Operational Procedures document, which included reference to the charges, no comments or challenge had been forthcoming from Members in respect of the charges for replacement bins. However, since the approval of the charges in 203/14 it had become apparent that the charge had not been consistently applied. The Operations Manual, agreed following the Inquiry Evening, was published on the Council’s website and clearly stated under Procedure 14 that when a bin was damaged by the collection vehicle a note would be made by the crew and a replacement bin would be provided free of charge. During debate Members of the scrutiny committee expressed concerns regarding the charges, stating that the only service residents received for their council tax was waste removal and they should not have to pay any further charges for the service. The resolution of the committee was: That the Environment and Performance Committee recommend to Cabinet that it withdraw all replacement charges for the green and blue domestic wheeled bins. The Portfolio Holder for Environmental Services thanked the scrutiny members for their detailed and diligent consideration of the issues. However, she was not in a position to support the recommendation due to the severe financial challenges facing the council, and no viable alternative option had been proposed to fund the budget deficit that would be created by the abolition of charges. The policy had been in place since 2013/14 and consulted on annually as part of the budget setting process since that time, no comments or concerns had been raised. The authority was legitimately entitled to recover the costs for supply and delivery of replacement bins and it was fair and proportionate to do. The charge also ensured there was an onus of responsibility on residents to look after their bins and it would be unfair to burden all tax payers with costs of replacement in circumstances where the Council was not at fault. It was clarified that if damage was caused by the refuse vehicle or crew the replacement bin would be provided at no cost to the householder. The charges were ... view the full minutes text for item 31.
Word for word from the decision Boston published for this meeting.
Source: democracy.boston.gov.uk