RESOLVED that the Committee adopt the assessment criteria as set out in the Standards Board guidance “Local Assessment of Complaints” supplemented by the following: “Q: If the complaint does allege a breach of the Code of Conduct, would the sanctions available to the Committee be likely to be sufficient to dispose of the matter should the complaint be upheld. If so, is there any other reason (such as the particular political sensitivity of the matter) why the complaint should be referred to the Standards Board? “Q: Could the complaint adequately be dealt with by referring the matter to the Monitoring Officer with a direction to take steps other than the carrying out of an investigation (e.g. by arranging for the Member to undergo training or by arranging for the Member and the complainant to engage in conciliation)”.
Word for word from the decision Bracknell Forest published for this meeting.Source: democratic.bracknell-forest.gov.uk
2.1That the Committee adopt the assessment criteria as set out in the Standards Board guidance “Local Assessment of Complaints” supplemented as proposed in Section 4 of this report.
3 ADVICE RECEIVED FROM STATUTORY AND OTHER OFFICERS
Borough Solicitor
3.1The Borough Solicitor is the author of this report.
Borough Treasurer
3.2There are no financial implications directly arising from this report.
Equalities Impact Assessment
3.3None relevant.
Strategic Risk Management Issues
3.4None relevant.
4 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
4.1The guidance issued by the Standards Board on the criteria for assessing complaints is shown at Annexe A to this report.
4.2It is very likely that the community of Monitoring Officers will develop more detailed assessment criteria over the following few months and if so the Council will be able to access that body of accumulated thinking. In the meantime it is proposed that the criteria proposed by the Standards Board should be accepted but supplemented by the following questions:-
“Q: If the complaint does allege a breach of the Code of Conduct, would the sanctions available to the Committee be likely to be sufficient to dispose of the matter should the complaint be upheld. If so, is there any other reason (such as the particular political sensitivity of the matter) why the complaint should be referred to the Standards Board?
The Committee has limited sanctions available which it may impose if a complaint were to be upheld. Whilst those sanctions will be sufficient to deal with the large majority of cases, there may be allegations of such gravity that they merit reference to the Standards Board. There may be other reasons (for example, an allegation concerning a matter of extreme political sensitivity) why it would not be appropriate for the matter to be determined locally”.
“Q: Could the complaint adequately be dealt with by referring the matter to the Monitoring Officer with a direction to take steps other than the carrying out of an investigation (e.g. by arranging for the Member to undergo training or by arranging for the Member and the complainant to engage in conciliation)”.
A Member may have made a bona fide misinterpretation of the Code. In the less serious of such cases it may be appropriate simply to deal with the matter by arranging training for the Member. In other cases an attempt to engage in conciliation with the complainant may be the most productive route although conciliation is only likely to be beneficial if both parties agree to pursue that avenue”.
Background Papers None.
Contact for Further Information Alex Jack, Borough Solicitor (01344) 355679 [email protected]
Doc Ref: Aj/f/reports/Standards Committee – Criteria for Assessment of Complaints – 5th June2008
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.