RESOLVED that i) anonymous allegations should only be referred for investigation if they include valid documents, photographs or other evidence indicating an exceptionally serious or significant matter; ii) the criteria for assessment of complaints be amended accordingly; and iii) the Committee adopt the criteria set out in Appendix A for determining whether the identity of complainants should be withheld from the Member who is the subject of the complaint.
Word for word from the decision Bracknell Forest published for this meeting.Source: democratic.bracknell-forest.gov.uk
2.1That anonymous allegations should only be referred for investigation if they include valid documents or other photographic evidence indicating an exceptionally serious or significant matter.
2.2That the criteria for assessment of complaints be amended accordingly.
2.3That the Committee adopt the criteria set out in Appendix A for determining whether the identity of complainants should be withheld from the Member the subject of complaint.
3. ADVICE RECEIVED FROM STATUTORY AND OTHER OFFICERS
Borough Solicitor
3.1The Borough Solicitor is the author of this report
Borough Treasurer
3.2No financial implications arising
Equalities Impact Assessment
3.3None relevant
Strategic Risk Management Issues
3.4None relevant.
4 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
Anonymous Complaints
4.1The Standards Board has issued the following guidance:- “Anonymous complaints.
Authorities should publish a statement setting out how complaints received anonymously will be dealt with. The Assessment Sub-Committee may decide that an anonymous complaint should only be referred for investigation or some other action if it includes documentary or photographic evidence indicating an exceptionally serious or significant matter. If so, this needs to be included in the Standards Committees assessment criteria”.
It is proposed that the advice of the Standards Board should be followed.
4.2At its meeting on 5th June 2008 the Committee endorsed assessment criteria for the consideration of complaints. It is proposed that the guidance referred to above should be incorporated into the assessment criteria.
Complainant Confidentiality
4.3Guidance issued by the Standards Board advises that although as a matter of fairness and natural justice a Member should usually be told who has complained about them there may be exceptional circumstances where the complainant’s identity should be withheld. The Referral Sub-Committee should consider the request for confidentiality alongside the substance of the complaint itself. In considering such requests the Sub-Committee should consider whether it is possible to investigate the complaint without making the complainant’s identity known. If a request for confidentiality is refused the Sub-Committee may decide to offer the complainant the opportunity to withdraw his/her complaint although there may be allegations which are so serious that the public interest in pursuing the matter outweighs the complainant’s interest in having their identity withheld from the subject Member.
4.4The criteria set out in Appendix A are those suggested by the Standards Board.
Background Papers None.
Contact for Further Information Alex Jack, Borough Solicitor (01344) 355679 [email protected]
1. The complainant has reasonable grounds for believing that they will be at risk of physical harm if their identity is disclosed.
2. The complainant is an officer who works closely with the subject Member and they are afraid of the consequences to their employment or of losing their job if their identity is disclosed (this should be covered by the Authority’s whistle-blowing policy).
3. The complainant suffers from a serious health condition and there are medical risks associated with their identity being disclosed. In such circumstances, Standards Committees may wish to request medical evidence of the complainant’s condition
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.