It was agreed that the initial feeling of the Committee would be included in the Annual Report of the Standards Committee 2010-11 which would be recommended to Council. The Committee agreed that the Borough Solicitor would write to Parish & Town Council Clerks to seek their views in relation to the retention of the Standards Committee and a voluntary Code of Conduct. The Committee would further discuss the future of the framework relating to Member conduct in local authorities in the summer once more detail was know about the provisions in the .
Word for word from the decision Bracknell Forest published for this meeting.Source: democratic.bracknell-forest.gov.uk
The purpose of this report is to appraise the Committee of proposals in the Localism Bill which will radically alter the statutory framework relating to Member conduct in local authorities. The Bill is currently progressing through Parliament and current indications are that it will be enacted in November 2011.
2. THE CURRENT FRAMEWORK
2.1The Local Government Act 2000 was enacted by the previous government in response to the recommendations of the Nolan Committee which investigated standards of conduct in local government. Nolan recommended that each Council should adopt a Code of Conduct for Members and that the Code would be “policed” by a local Standards Committee.
2.2The very largely devolved framework proposed by Nolan was not accepted by the then government. Instead, the 2000 Act provided that there would be a centrally prescribed Code of Conduct for Members which every local authority would be required to adopt. Although the legislation provided that each authority should have a Standards Committee, complaints alleging breaches of the Code had to be made to the national Standards Board (now entitled Standards for England) which would arrange for one of its Ethical Standards Officers to investigate and, if appropriate, submit the matter for determination by an Adjudication Tribunal.
2.3Very predictably, the initially very centralised nature of the standards regime put in place led to a large backlog of cases with complaints taking an unacceptably long time to be investigated and adjudicated upon. The unfortunate start of the “new ethical framework” put in place by the 2000 Act undoubtedly contributed to its falling into some disrepute.
2.4More recently, under regulations made in 2003 and 2008 most investigations and adjudications into allegations of breaches of the Code have been dealt with locally. However, the regulations prescribe in enormous detail the process for investigation/adjudication, which arguably remains far too lengthy and, with the possibility of at least four sub-committee meetings, very bureaucratic.
2.5The existing legislation provides for a range of sanctions which a Standards Committee can impose should it find a Member to be in breach of the Code. The most severe sanction which can be imposed locally is suspension for up to six months. In the case of the most serious complaints which are referred to Standards for England the maximum penalty is disqualification for up to five years. 2.6 The Code of Conduct promulgated by Parliament initially attracted considerable criticism. A significant number of Members, particularly in Parish Councils, objected to the obligation to register interests as an unacceptable intrusion. Also, the provisions relating to Personnel and Prejudicial Interests are undoubtedly complex and, at least until amendments to the Code made in recent years, have led to many Members feeling that too frequently they are precluded from participating in Council meetings on matters which their constituents feel most strongly about. Recent amendments to the Code are such that Members under the Code are barred less frequently than previously from participating. However, the Courts have, independently of the Code, developed a principle of common law that members of public bodies cannot be involved in decision making if they have “pre-determined” the matter under consideration. When that principle first evolved it was applied strictly, one might consider unrealistically so, in the local authority context with the same principles being applied to Judges in the Supreme Court and to Councillors. In recent years though the Courts have taken a more pragmatic view and it is only in the most blatant of cases that a local authority decision is likely to be quashed on the basis of pre- determination.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.