The proposal accords with the following Policy of the Regional Spatial Strategy for the South East of England: BE6 – which seeks to which protect, conserve and, where appropriate, enhance the historic environment and the contribution it makes to local and regional distinctiveness and sense of place. The proposal accords with the following Core Strategy Development Plan Document Policies: CS1 – which seeks to ensure that development makes efficient use of land and buildings, reduces the need for travel, promotes a mix of uses, conserves water and energy use, supports the economic wellbeing of the population, protects and enhances safety, natural resources, character of local landscape and historic and cultural features. CS7 – which seeks to ensure that developments are of high quality design. (Please note that this is not intended to be an exhaustive list). The following material considerations have been taken into account: Although the proposed development would result in substantial harm to the cultural heritage and significance of the Broadmoor Estate, the applicant has provided a robust and detailed case as to why the development should go ahead in the national interest. It is on balance concluded that the national need for a modern high secure mental health hospital at Broadmoor outweighs the harm that has been identified to heritage assets. Listed Building Consent is therefore granted. In the event that planning application 11/00743/FUL is not approved by 16th June 2012 to REFUSE the application on the following grounds: The ... view the full minutes text for item 80.
Word for word from the decision Bracknell Forest published for this meeting.Source: democratic.bracknell-forest.gov.uk
ITEM NO: 07 Application No. Ward: Date Registered: Target Decision Date: 11/00744/LB Crowthorne 28 October 2011 23 December 2011 Site Address: Broadmoor Hospital Lower Broadmoor Road Crowthorne Berkshire RG45 7EG Proposal: Application for listed building consent for the demolition of Lancashire House, Yorkshire House and the Richard Dadd Centre, and partial demolition of Berkshire House. Applicant: West London Mental Health Trust Agent: Oxford Architects LLP Case Officer: Trevor Yerworth, 01344 352000 [email protected]
Site Location Plan (for identification purposes only, not to scale)
Planning Committee 15th March 2012 1 RELEVANT PLANNING HISTORY (If Any)
11/00446/FUL Validation Date: 29.06.2011 Erection of replacement secure mental health hospital and associated development, involving demolition of some existing buildings, and construction of new access road and roundabout junction to the A3095 Foresters Road. Withdrawn
11/00447/LB Validation Date: 29.06.2011 Application for listed building consent for the demolition of Lancashire House, Yorkshire House and the Richard Dadd Centre, and partial demolition of Berkshire House. Withdrawn
11/00743/FUL Validation Date: 28.10.2011 Erection of replacement secure mental health hospital and associated development, involving demolition of some existing buildings, and construction of new access road and roundabout junction to the A3095 Foresters Road. (No Decision – Application Currently Under Consideration)
2 RELEVANT PLANNING POLICIES
Key to abbreviations
BFBCS Core Strategy Development Plan Document BFBLP Bracknell Forest Borough Local Plan RMLP Replacement Minerals Local Plan WLP Waste Local Plan for Berkshire
SPG Supplementary Planning Guidance SPD Supplementary Planning Document PPG (No.) Planning Policy Guidance (Published by DCLG) PPS (No.) Planning Policy Statement (Published by DCLG) MPG Minerals Planning Guidance DCLG Department for Communities and Local Government SEP South East Plan
Plan Policy Description (May be abbreviated) BFBCS CS1 Sustainable Development Principles BFBCS CS7 Design
3 CONSULTATIONS (Comments may be abbreviated)
Conservation Officer
Demolition of the female wing (and Berkshire House), though harmful, is understandable, in order to build a hospital. However mitigation should be provided.
Crowthorne Parish Council
Crowthorne Parish Council members do not feel they have sufficient knowledge regarding the demolition of listed buildings to comment on this planning application.
The Council For British Archaeology
(No comments received at time of producing this report).
Planning Committee 15th March 2012 The Georgian Group
(No comments received at time of producing this report).
Society Protection Ancient Buildings
(No comments received at time of producing this report).
The Victorian Society
The listed buildings, including the curtilage listed buildings and the registered historic landscape are of national significance. The proposed demolitions would result in significant harm to the significant Victorian heritage assets on this site.
The loss of the women's block is extremely regrettable notwithstanding the fact that its setting has been somewhat compromised by the Paddock Centre. The loss of Essex House and part of its listed garden terracing, will result in even greater harm given its prominence in public views and it forming "part of a wonderfully designed array of buildings".
However, based on information provided by the applicant the Victorian Society is persuaded that (a) the national benefits of providing a secure mental health institution on this site outweighs the significant harm identified; and (b) that there are no reasonable alternatives to either the Broadmoor site or the proposed configuration of buildings at Broadmoor.
On the basis of the above assessment the Victorian Society has withdrawn its formal objection to this application.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.