RESOLVED that the Schools Forum: NOTED the outcome of the re-tendering of the school meals contract which had been awarded to ISS Education with improved financial and other benefits. NOTED that following consultation, schools wished to continue to charge the current price per meal of £2.00.
Word for word from the decision Bracknell Forest published for this meeting.Source: democratic.bracknell-forest.gov.uk
1.1To advise Schools Forum on the decision and outcome of awarding the school meals contract to ISS Education.
Recommendations
2.1That the Schools Forum notes the outcome of the re-tendering of the school meals contract which has been awarded to ISS Education with improved financial and other benefits is NOTED.
2.2That following consultation, schools wish to continue to charge the current price per meal of £2.00 is NOTED.
Reasons for recommendations
3.1It is appropriate for the Forum to be aware of, and where relevant, comment on these contractual matters on behalf of schools.
Alternative options considered
4.1These are set out in the supporting information.
5 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
Background
5.1The current Council-managed contract for school meals was tendered in 2006 and expires in July 2012. A total of 28 Primary/Infant/Junior, 1 secondary and 1 Special School participate in the current contract which is with ISS Education. The remaining 5 Secondary and 3 Primary/Infant/Junior in the borough make their own arrangements for school meals by a combination of individually tendered contracts and in-house delivery.
Procurement
5.2The Procurement Plan for the school meals service was endorsed by the Executive Member for Education in October 2011, and in December 2011 Schools Forum gave feedback on the draft specification.
5.3The contract was jointly procured with West Berkshire Council to make it more attractive in the marketplace and to achieve economies of scale. Officers from both Councils collaborated to produce a joint specification and Invitation to tender. There will however be separate contracts for each authority to ensure each can effectively manage the service on behalf of its own schools. Unrestricted
5.4School meals is considered to be a Part B service, and not subject to the Public Contract Regulations (2009) requiring advertisement via the Official Journal of the European Union (OJEU). The contract was therefore procured using a two-stage restricted procedure, with advertisement on the South East Business Portal, which attracted expressions of interest from 12 suppliers.
5.5From this a tender list was drawn up with 5 contractors, all of whom demonstrated that they had appropriate resources and experience of working in schools. Tenders were let in January 2012 and responses were received from all 5. Schools Forum will recall that in 2006 when the contract was last tendered the market was such that no tenders were received. The 2006 contract had to be negotiated at a cost plus profit basis, and the subsequent subsidy payable by schools, though reduced, has continued to be an ongoing burden.
5.6Tenders were evaluated against the pre-defined criteria by a joint Bracknell Forest/West Berkshire team including school representatives, based on a 40/60 Price/Quality ratio. All 5 tenders were of a high standard, and all 5 contractors were interviewed.
5.7ISS Education scored highest on quality whilst also offering the lowest cost option for Bracknell Forest schools. ISS is our current provider, which also avoids the disruption of mobilising a new contractor.
5.8In February 2012 the Executive agreed to delegate the decision to award the contract to the Director of Children Young People & Learning in consultation with the Executive Member for Education to allow more time for consultation with schools, and the award decision was taken in April 2012.
The New Service
5.9This procurement has been successful in that it has also resulted in a number of significant improvements and benefits for Bracknell Forest schools, including:
• The contractor has provided a signed compliance statement that all of the features of the specification will be met, and this will form part of the contract documentation.
• The new contract can be delivered at a zero subsidy by schools, which amounts to an overall saving of £90k per annum when compared to the current contract.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.