RESOLVED that it be recommended to Governance and Audit Committee that the threshold for the registration of gifts and hospitality should remain at £25, from one source, within a rolling 12 month period and that there should be emphasis on erring on the side of caution and to register if there is any doubt. It was agreed that the final wording would be circulated to Committee members via email.
Word for word from the decision Bracknell Forest published for this meeting.Source: democratic.bracknell-forest.gov.uk
1.1The purpose of this report is to seek the view of the Committee as to whether the current threshold for the registration of gifts and hospitality (£25) should be revised (upwards or downwards) or confirmed at its existing level.
Recommendation
2.1The Committee is requested to formulate its view as to the threshold which triggers the requirement for Members to register gifts or hospitality.
Reasons for recommendation
3.1When the Committee considered the (then proposed) revised Code of Conduct for Members at its meeting on 14 January 2013 there was considerable debate as to what the threshold should be for the registration of gifts and hospitality. It was agreed that the issue be deferred for consideration at a subsequent meeting of the Committee.
Alternative options considered
4.1None.
5 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
5.1The Code of Conduct for Members (“the Code”) contains the following paragraph:-
“You should promptly register any gifts or hospitality the value of which exceeds £25 (or the reasonably estimated value of which exceeds £25 where the value is not disclosed) which you and/or your spouse/partner receive because (or when it can reasonably be inferred because) you are a Member of the Council”.
The paragraph is in practically identical terms as a corresponding provision in the old statutory Code which first came into force in 2001.
5.2When a first draft of a statutory code was first published for consultation in 2000/2001 a significant number of representations were made nationally that the threshold was too low. The prevailing view of the Council’s Standards Committee at that time (including that of the then independent Chairman) was that £25 was too low a threshold. However, the Model Code issued by the government set the threshold at £25. Unrestricted
5.3The Code of Conduct Working Group which in 2012 formulated the Council’s replacement Code of Conduct proposed a threshold of £75. At the January 2013 meeting of the Committee there was a significant divergence of opinion with some Members of the Committee indicating support for the proposed £75 threshold with other Members indicating their view that a zero threshold (i.e. all gifts and hospitality irrespective of value) should be adopted. In the event the issue was deferred to allow an opportunity to consider the matter as a discrete issue.
5.4The proposed revised Code was considered by the Governance and Audit Committee at its meeting on 29 January 2013. Again, there was a significant divergence of opinion as to the threshold but following debate that Committee agreed that the Standards Committee should have the opportunity to consider the issue further.
5.5There are arguments in favour of both a zero and higher threshold (as indeed there are for maintaining the current threshold). The main advantages and disadvantages may perhaps be summarised as set out below:-
Zero Threshold
Advantages • maximises sense of transparency.
• does not require Members to make any estimate of value of gift or hospitality.
Disadvantages • could be excessively bureaucratic, imposing an unnecessary administrative burden upon Members and officers in an era of “austerity”
• placing a further administrative burden upon Members could discredit the carefully formulated new arrangements relating to Members in the eyes of Councillors
• would provide greater scope for trifling/vexatious complaints
• no reasonable person would consider that a gift or hospitality of minimal value would influence Member decision making
Higher Threshold
Advantages • would not impose an unnecessary administrative burden
• a higher threshold would give greater credibility to the requirement to register gifts/hospitality than a lower figure
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.