Resolved
RESOLVED that the Planning Committee APPROVED consent for the following work: T1 Beech – Crown-lift to 3m. T2 Holly – Fell. T3 Sweet Chestnut – Remove the two lowest branches on the West side. T4 Sycamore – (Consent with modification) – Crown-lift to maximum 4 metres (equivalent to twice the height of the adjoining boundary fence) and to prune the remaining western branches back to a suitable growth-point in order to create a maximum of 2 metres clearance between the house and the remaining tree canopy. T6 Oak - Remove the two lowest branches on its West side. T7 Oak – Prune the lowest branch on the South-west back to a suitable growth-point close to the line of the boundary fence. RESOLVED that the Planning Committee REFUSED consent to the following work: T3 Sweet Chestnut – Crown-lift to 6.5m high. Reason: The consented work to remove two lowest western branches would create 2m clearance which is considered sufficient distance from the house structure. There is no justification to carry out the additional Crown-lift to 6.5m. T4 Sycamore – Crown-lift to 7.5m and Crown-thin by 30%. Reason: The proposed Crown lift to 7.5m is not justified and is contrary to arboricultural best practice, creating a very high and unbalanced canopy. However, taking into consideration the reason for the proposed work, the Council has no objection to lift a Crown-lift up to a maximum of 4m (which would be twice the height of the adjoining boundary fence) and to pruning the remaining western branches to a suitable growth-point in order to establish a maximum of 2m clearance from the house structure. There is no justification for the proposed Crown-thinning. T5 Sycamore - Crown-lift to 9m and Crown-thin by 30% Reason: Restriction of light into a garden is not a material consideration during the TPO application process (this principle also applies to T6 and T7 Oak of this application) A Crown-lift to 9m would create a very high and top-heavy canopy leading to future structural defects and potential instability. There is no justification for the proposed Crown-thinning. T6 Oak – Remove the third and fourth lowest branch on its West side (after permitted removal of the two lowest branches on its West side). Reason: The permitted removal of the two lowest branches will provide adequate height clearance over the patio area; however the additional removal of the next two lowest branches will not reduce the instance of sticky residue falling from the remaining tree canopy onto the patio area.