Resolved
RESOLVED that the ‘Update on Standards Matters’ report, be noted.
Standards Committee noted this item on Thursday 29 June 2017. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved
RESOLVED that the ‘Update on Standards Matters’ report, be noted.
1.1This report brings to Members’ attention recent national standards news items for information.
2.1To note the content of this report.
3.0DETAILS
3.1Release of reports into code of conduct matters
Assessing whether to publish information related to code of conduct matters can be difficult as it requires balancing data protection legislation and the Freedom of Information Act (‘the Act’) against the public interest. Two recent tribunal rulings provide further guidance on this issue.
Michael Thompson v The Information Commissioner and Cheshire East Council (Freedom of Information Act 2000)
3.2Michael Thompson had been a councillor at Cheshire East Council when he submitted a complaint against a fellow councillor. The complaint was considered and no further action taken. [name removed] sought under Freedom of Information legislation the release of the response of the councillor to the complaint and any documents provided in the councillor’s defence.
3.3The Council declined to release the information on the grounds the councillor’s response was not disclosable as it had been provided in confidence, thereby meeting an exemption under Section 41 of the Act. When an appeal was made to the Information Commissioner, the Council argued that the documents the councillor had used to support his defence, for example council minutes, were publicly available and thereby exempted under Section 21 (information accessible by other means) of the Act and that his personal response contained personal information making it exempt under Section 40(2) of the Act. The Information Commissioner upheld Cheshire East’s decision, leading to an appeal to the First- Tier Tribunal.
3.4In their decision, the Tribunal ruled in favour of the Council and Information Commissioner. They found that the councillor’s response was personal information and could not be redacted to prevent identification. Although the information related to the councillor in his formal capacity, because it pertained to an alleged conduct breach, "the information is clearly of personal in nature, in the same way that an individual’s annual appraisal report can be considered to be personal data.”
3.5Having concluded it was personal data, the Tribunal then assessed whether the appellant had a legitimate interest and disclosure was necessary to meet that legitimate interest. They concluded that it was reasonable for the appellant to want to see the councillor’s response in the interests of assessing how the complaint had been dealt with, but also generally in respect of accountability of elected councillors.
3.6However this legitimate interest was found to be outweighed by the councillor’s interests, rights and freedoms, rendering disclosure unwarranted when the Council had found the complaint to lack merit. The tribunal noted: - Information relating to complaints "carries a very strong expectation of privacy,” because of the distress and reputational damage arising from complaints. This extends to an unfounded complaint because the existence of a complaint can itself be damaging; - There was a legitimate expectation of privacy on the councillor’s part because of the personal nature of complaints investigations; - The code of conduct complaints process should remain confidential as otherwise "all confidence in the process would be lost” and result in a lack of candour on the part of relevant parties in the complaints process; - That the appellant and councillor were no longer in office was irrelevant because they might seek to be again; and - A councillor has a legitimate interest in having their personal data withheld from the public sphere.
Janet Dedman v The Information Commissioner
3.7In a separate case the Information Rights Tribunal overturned a decision of the Information Commissioner regarding the release of a draft report on an investigation into a complaint against a councillor.
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
PDF |
Standards Committee Report: General updateReport | 110 KB | DownloadRead as text |
Follow Standards Committee at Brent and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
| Meeting | Decision | Outcome | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 28 Sep 2017 | Minutes of the Previous MeetingRESOLVED that the minutes of the previous meeting held on 29 June 2017 be approved as an accurate record of the meeting. | Approved | Open |
| 29 Jun 2017 | Minutes of the previous meetingRESOLVED that the minutes of the previous meeting, held on 28 November 2016, be approved as an accurate record of the... | Approved | Open |
| 28 Nov 2016 | Annual Report to the Standards Committee 2016RESOLVED, that the Annual Report to the Standards Committee 2016, be noted. | Noted | Open |
| 21 Mar 2016 | Minutes of the previous meeting- Subject to the above amendment, that the minutes of the previous meeting held on 7 January 2016 be approved as an a... | Approved | Open |
| 21 Mar 2016 | Members' Code of Conduct Complaints Procedure and Independent Members- Members therefore agreed the following change to recommendation 2.1: That the Committee approves the Members’ Code ... | Agreed | Open |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.