12.1 The revised weightings and criteria used to procure and evaluate tenders as detailed in paragraph 3.3 of the Cabinet report be noted; and 12.2 The award of a works contract for South Kilburn Enterprise and Community Hub (Phase 1b) to Surecast Limited be approved. 12.1 The revised weightings and criteria used to procure and evaluate tenders as detailed in paragraph 3.3 of the Cabinet report be noted; and 12.2 The award of a works contract for South Kilburn Enterprise and Community Hub (Phase 1b) to Surecast Limited be approved.
Word for word from the decision Brent published for this meeting.Source: democracy.brent.gov.uk
1.1This report provides an update to the 13 March 2017 Cabinet report – Phase 1 Building Project at The Granville Centre – Approval to Tender Works Contract
1.2This report seeks authority to award a works contract to progress Phase 1 of Carlton and Granville Centres Development as required by Contract Standing Order 88.
1.3This report asks Members to note a revision in weightings and adjustment in criteria used to evaluate tenders compared to those set out in the March 2017 Cabinet report for the reasons detailed in section 3.
Recommendations
That Cabinet;
2.1Note the revised weightings and criteria used to procure and evaluate tenders as detailed in paragraph 3.3.
2.2Approve the award of a works contract for South Kilburn Enterprise and Community Hub (Phase 1b) to Surecast Limited. 3 Detail
Background
3.1In March 2017 Cabinet approved the procurement process for a contractor to complete Phase 1 works on the basis of the pre-tender considerations set out within the report which put forward a 60:40 split in favour of cost. However this was erroneous in that Officers should have advised members that the recommended split between quality and price criteria was in fact 60:40 in favour of quality.
3.2To set out this change clearly, the original decision in March 2017 was based on the following weightings and criteria:
Quality - 40% of the overall evaluation, assessed using the following criteria.
Proposed application of experience Design approach and compliance with employer’s requirements. Community participation. Project Management and resourcing. Construction approach and technical proposals. Social Value representing 10% of this score.
Price - 60% of the overall evaluation.
3.3Cabinet are now being asked to note that tenders were invited and evaluated on the evaluation criteria and weightings below. The changes were to reflect the fact that Officers should have advised members that the recommended split between quality and price criteria was in fact 60:40 in favour of quality and that the revised criteria were considered likely to better identify the most appropriate tender. The evaluation criteria and weightings were:
Quality - 60% of the overall evaluation, assessed using the following criteria.
Work Management (Maximum of 19.25 marks of 60) Project Examples (Maximum of 8.25 marks of 60) Programme (Maximum of 16.5 marks of 60) Quality (Maximum of 11 marks of 60) Social Value (Maximum of 5 marks of 60)
Price - 40% of the overall evaluation.
3.4Details of the tender process operated by Officers is set out in Appendix 1. The details of organisations tendering are set out in Appendix 2. It is important to note that all the information provided to tenderers and evaluators has been based on the correct split in favour of quality as has the evaluation itself. There has been no disadvantage to any participant. 3.5 Members will note from Appendix 1 that Supplier 10, namely Surecast Limited, has been identified as the most economically advantageous tender.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Minutes of the Previous MeetingCabinet RESOLVED that the minutes of the previous meeting held on Monday 12 October 2026 be approved as a correct rec...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.