Resolved
RESOLVED : That the report be noted. The meeting closed at 11.30am.
Standards Committee noted this item on Thursday 31 July 2014. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved
RESOLVED : That the report be noted. The meeting closed at 11.30am.
1.1To provide Members with a summary of the recent case Heesom v Public Services Ombudsman for Wales [2014].
2. Connection to Corporate Improvement Plan / Other Corporate Priority
2.1Standards are an implicit requirement in the successful implementation of the Corporate Themes.
3.1Councillor Patrick Heesom, the appellant (H) was a long standing local councillor of Flintshire County Council who had served since 1990. In 2009, a number of allegations of misconduct were made against him by the non-elected officers of the Council. The allegations led to him standing down from the Executive but continuing to perform his duties as a Councillor. A complaint was then made about him to the Public Services Ombudsman for Wales and after an enquiry, he was found to have breached the Council’s Code of Conduct. As the breaches were considered to be serious, the matter was sent by the Ombudsman to the Adjudication Panel for Wales for adjudication by a case tribunal.
3.2The proceedings before the Panel had, it appears, proceeded at extraordinary length and cost (58 hearing days, 48 witnesses, 7000 documents etc). The Panel found that H had committed 14 breaches of the Council’s Codes of Conduct by failing to show respect and consideration for Council Officers, using bullying behaviour, attempting to compromise the impartiality of officers, conducting himself in a manner likely to bring his office or the Council in to disrepute. In terms of sanction, the tribunal disqualified H from being a Member of the Council or of any other local authority for two and a half years. H challenged the tribunal’s decision by bringing a statutory appeal to the High Court on the basis that the misconduct findings and the subsequent sanction were both unlawful.
3.3The appeal raised a number of interesting points. The first was the proper approach of the High Court to appeal from the Adjudication Panel. Hickinbottom J found that appropriate weight should be given to the Panel’s determination as a decision of a specialist tribunal. It is necessary to show that the Panel’s decision is wrong, and the starting point is that it is right until the contrary is shown. The second was as to the standard of proof applicable in proceedings before the Adjudication Panel. Was it the civil standard (the balance of probabilities) or the criminal (beyond reasonable doubt)? Hickinbottom J’s view was that it was the civil standard. There was nothing in the gravity of the charges or the potential consequences to justify introducing the criminal standard. These were disciplinary proceedings which were exclusively civil in nature.
3.4Thirdly, the Judge considered at length what constituted a politicians right of freedom of expression under Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights. Article 10 provides for the right to freedom of expression and information therefore, comments and assertions made within a political setting are acceptable but the same comments could be considered unacceptable behaviour in a non- political environment. However, within a political environment a politician would be shielded as long as any comments made by him were honestly held and not knowingly untrue.
3.5The European legislation provides politicians with greater protection than non- politicians as the Court acknowledged that the environment in which they inhabit makes them susceptible to adverse criticism and haranguing and as such they are obliged to accept this and respond in a manner befitting their office, in contrast to a non-political individual. This protection also covers political commentators and those who write about politicians e.g the newspapers.
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
PDF |
Ombudsman Litigation: Heesom v Public Services Ombudsman for WalesReport | 37 KB | DownloadRead as text |
Follow Standards Committee at Bridgend and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
| Meeting | Decision | Outcome | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7 Jul 2023 | Annual ReportIt was agreed that the Committee received the for 2022/23, which will in turn, be presented to full Council. | Agreed | Open |
| 7 Jul 2023 | Independent Review of the Ethical Standards FrameworkThat the Committee noted the report. | Noted | Open |
| 7 Jul 2023 | National Forum for Standards Committee ChairsThat the Committee noted the report and confirmed that the Chair and Monitoring Officer (or their deputies) represent... | Noted | Open |
| 7 Jul 2023 | Gifts and HospitalityRESOLVED : That the Committee agreed to support the proposal that local authorities in Wales should voluntarily harmo... | Agreed | Open |
| 7 Jul 2023 | Observations of the Vale of Glamorgan's Standards CommitteeRESOLVED : (1) The Committee noted the report the observations from the Vale of Glamorgan meeting. (2) That Members d... | Noted | Open |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.