Resolved
That the Committee noted the report, and awaits a further report on this matter to ensure the Council’s licensing processes reflect those advocated by the European Court of Judgement.
Licensing Committee noted this item on Friday 27 January 2017. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved
That the Committee noted the report, and awaits a further report on this matter to ensure the Council’s licensing processes reflect those advocated by the European Court of Judgement.
1.1The purpose of this report is to advise Members of the recent European Court of Justice ruling in the Hemming v Westminster Case. The ruling has implications for the way in which local authorities can charge for the cost of administering and enforcing certain licensing regimes.
2. Connection to Corporate Improvement Objectives/Other Corporate Priorities
2.1The duties of the Council as a licensing authority are statutory in nature but many of the licensing objectives support the principal aims of the Corporate Improvement Plan and the Council’s corporate priorities.
3. Background.
Summary of Hemming v Westminster City Council
3.1The European Services Directive aims to make it easier for service providers to operate across Europe. One of its key provisions is that licence fees can only be used to cover the costs associated with the administration of licensing regimes covered by the Directive. Local Authorities therefore cannot make a profit from licensing or deter service providers by levying unreasonable fees. The Directive is enacted in the UK by the Provision of Services Regulations 2009, and Regulation 18(4) provides that charges under an authorisation scheme must be reasonable and proportionate to, and not exceed, the cost of the procedures and formalities under the scheme. The Services Directive does not currently apply to taxi related fees (drivers, operators and vehicles), or fees and charges under the Gambling Act 2005 and Licensing Act 2003.
3.2In 2012, sex shop owner Timothy Hemming instituted legal proceedings against Westminster City Council contesting that the level of licence fees charged by Westminster City council were not reasonable. Westminster’s sex shop fees were in excess of £26,000; the fees included costs for the management of the regime and enforcement activities against unlicensed operators; it was this latter aspect of the fee that Hemming asserted not to be ‘reasonable and proportionate’ under the legislation. The case has progressed subsequently through the upper Courts and the findings of each Court are summarised below.
Administrative Court (May 2012) & Court of Appeal (2013) 3.3 The Administrative Court (and subsequently the Court of Appeal) ruled that licence fees must not exceed the cost of administering the licensing process and that this could not include the costs of enforcement against unlicensed operators. However the judgement did make it clear that the costs of compliance and enforcement against licensed operators could be included in the licence fee.
3.4Supreme Court (April 2015)
Westminster Council appealed the decision of the Court of Appeal and, in April 2015, the Supreme Court overturned the Court of Appeal’s decision and made it clear that local authorities could set their fees at a level that would enable them to recover the full costs of managing end enforcing the licensing regime, including the costs incurred in proceedings taken against unlicensed operators.
3.5The Supreme Court also gave consideration to how such fees should be structured. It identified two different approaches to charging licence fees:
Type A - An application fee is charged to cover the authorisation procedures involved in the processing of the application, then successful applicants are charged an additional fee that covers the running costs and enforcement of the licensing regime.
Type B – The applicant is charged one fee upfront that covers all costs of the application process, and running/enforcement costs of the licensing regime. If the applicant is unsuccessful the portion of the fee that covers the running/enforcement costs is refunded to the applicant.
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
PDF |
Licence Fees: European Court of Justice Ruling: Hemming v WestminsterReport | 89 KB | DownloadRead as text |
Follow Licensing Committee at Bridgend and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
| Meeting | Decision | Outcome | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 24 May 2023 | Approval of MinutesThat the minutes of the meetings of the Licensing Committee dated 22 November 2022 and 1 February 2023 be approved as... | Approved | Open |
| 24 May 2023 | Appointment Of Licensing Sub- Committee(s) and Delegations To OfficersThe Committee approved the formation of two panels sitting on a rota basis (as listed below), each consisting of seve... | Approved | Open |
| 22 Nov 2022 | Approval of MinutesThat the minutes of a meeting of the Licensing Committee dated 27 September 2022 be approved as a true and accurate r... | Approved | Open |
| 27 Sep 2022 | Approval of MinutesThat the Minutes of the meeting of the Licensing Committee of 25 May 2022 be approved as a true and accurate record. | Approved | Open |
| 25 May 2022 | Approval of MinutesThat the Minutes of the meeting of the Licensing Committee of 13 July 2021 be approved as a true and accurate record. | Approved | Open |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.