That the above application be deferred, to allow for the submission of a tree survey and report to be undertaken by a suitably qualified arboriculturist advising of the current health of the trees and justifying the proposed works to them. Proposal Pollard 3 Hornbeam trees in rear garden.
Word for word from the decision Bridgend published for this meeting.Source: democratic.bridgend.gov.uk
REFERENCE: T/21/77/TPO APPLICANT: [name removed], 10 Caer Newydd, Brackla, Bridgend CF31 2JZ LOCATION: 10 Caer Newydd, Brackla, Bridgend CF31 2JZ PROPOSAL: Pollard 3 Hornbeam trees in rear garden RECEIVED: 4 November 2021 SITE INSPECTED: 3 February 2022
APPLICATION/SITE DESCRIPTION The application seeks consent to undertake the pollarding of 3 Hornbeam trees at 10 Caer Newydd, Brackla, Bridgend. The trees are situated in the rear garden and are protected under Ogwr Borough Council Tree Preservation Order No.08 (1988).
Fig. 1 – Site Location Fig. 2 – Tree Preservation Order
The application originally sought consent to reduce the three Hornbeam trees to 2 metre high stumps. The agent was asked to provide a Tree Report justifying the works. The application was subsequently amended to incorporate the lesser works of pollarding the three trees.
RELEVANT HISTORY None.
PUBLICITY Neighbours have been notified of the receipt of the application.
The period allowed for response to the consultations for the superseded works expired on 24 December 2021. As the application description was subsequently amended to pollarding, a reconsultation exercise was undertaken and the period allowed for responses to consultations expired on 2 February 2022.
CONSULTATION RESPONSES Councillor J C Spanswick – I am surprised at the poor quality of the location plan. Has this really been accepted?
I would like further clarity as to the need to reduce the height of the trees to 2 metres above ground and the benefit this will bring to the trees.
Due to the reasons given for undertaking the works (i.e. to improve light to the garden) and some confusion with the plans submitted, I feel that this matter needs to be reported to the Development Control committee and not dealt with under officer delegated powers.
While I appreciate the applicant has modified the application from pollards to 2m, the plan provided is not great and it appears they are being pollards to different heights. The sole reason appears to be just to have more light in the garden and prior to changing my position on this I respectfully suggest a formal response is received from an officer in the Countryside section at BCBC who is experienced to give a view from an arboriculture perspective.
REPRESENTATIONS RECEIVED None.
COMMENTS ON REPRESENTATIONS RECEIVED With regard to Councillor Spanswick’s concerns, the agent initially submitted the address incorrectly on the original documentation for the application. The agent was asked to clarify the matter and subsequently confirmed the address was 10 Caer Newydd, Brackla. An amended location plan was also received which is deemed to be acceptable.
The application originally sought consent to reduce the three Hornbeam trees to 2 metre high stumps. The agent was asked to provide a Tree Report justifying the works and was queried how the reduction would benefit the trees. Subsequently, the agent amended the application to incorporate the lesser works of pollarding the three trees. A reconsultation exercise was undertaken incorporating the amended description of works.
The trees are proposed to be pollarded to different heights due to the variation in the overall height of the three trees. At the request of Councillor Spanswick, the Countryside and Tourism Section was consulted on the matter.
Whilst there is no ‘right to light’ from a Planning perspective, an individual’s usable amenity space is a consideration in the determination of tree applications. The issue of justification for the works will be dealt with in the Appraisal Section.
APPRAISAL The application is referred to Committee at the request of Councillor Spanswick.
The application seeks consent to undertake the pollarding of 3 Hornbeam trees at 10 Caer Newydd, Brackla, Bridgend.
Fig. 3 - Agent’s photograph showing extent of pollarding marked red
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.