CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Bristol City Council
Communities Scrutiny Commission, Monday 24 April 2017 at 10.00am

Cotham Trial for Glyphosate-Free Weed Treatment - Outcome Report

Decided Scrutiny 2 papers

Communities Scrutiny Commission decided this item on Monday 24 April 2017. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item102

Resolved

(1) That the Commission recommends that a cost-neutral trial be carried out with pelargonic acid on an area of highways of enough scale to ensure that the trial is credible. (2) The Service Manager to take forward for discussion with Highways.
Word for word from the decision Bristol published for this meeting. Source: democracy.bristol.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Bristol's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Communities Scrutiny Commission

Neighbourhoods Scrutiny Commission – Report

Neighbourhoods Scrutiny Commission 24th April 2017

Report of: Strategic Director, Neighbourhoods

Title: Outcome Report - Cotham trial for glyphosate-free weed treatment Ward: Cotham, Ashley

Officer Presenting Report: Strategic Director, Neighbourhoods: Alison Comley

Contact Telephone Number: 0117 3574357

Recommendation 1. To continue to use glyphosate in parks and green spaces, on the adopted highway and on hard surfaces under council ownership as necessary. 2. To map priority areas and features for weed treatment with a view to reducing use of glyphosate where possible as a precautionary approach. This would require commitment from individual service areas. 3. To consider longer-term weed treatment contracts from 18/19 and in doing so assess whether costs of alternative treatments can be lowered through investment and whether environmental impacts from water and energy use can be reduced. Summary The Council has completed a 12 month trial in Cotham ward and St Andrews Park to treat weed growth on the adopted highway without using a glyphosate-based product. It has also completed a desktop study of alternatives to glyphosate for weed control. The trial, desktop study and European guidance do not provide a compelling environmental or financial rationale, at this point in time, to change the approach to weed treatment. However, growing public interest in the use of glyphosate suggests that recent efforts to reduce its use in parks and open spaces should continue and be extended to hard surfaces where possible and ways to lower the cost of alternative weed treatment on the highway should be sought. The significant issues arising are: Final research findings are in line with those set out in the October 2016 ‘Interim Findings’ report to Scrutiny: 1. Use of an acetic acid-based product on the highway is closest to using a glyphosate product in terms of cost but is a greater cost and is less effective per application; Neighbourhoods Scrutiny Commission – Report

2. Alternative treatments such as foam stream are available but appear to be at a much higher cost, have other environmental impacts, and are more difficult to use in a congested urban environment; 3. Greater weed growth on the highway and in parks has not generated a significant uplift in complaints in the trial and residents’ tolerance to weeds in streets should be tested further; 4. Greater attention to hard surface design and materials will reduce the need to control weed growth in the long term; 5. Keep up to-date with relevant research and consider emerging products and techniques; 6. It is recommended to map priority areas and features for weed treatment with a view to reducing use of glyphosate where possible as a precautionary approach.

Context

 A full context to the trial and the assessment of glyphosate alternatives was set out in the October 2016 interim report to Neighbourhoods Scrutiny Commission and is not repeated here.

 A more detailed methodology of the trial and other key primary and secondary research is given in Appendix 1.

Proposal

 The aim of the trial was to provide answers to the following: i. How effective is acetic acid compared to glyphosate as a herbicide? ii. How is the public responding to visual changes in parks and streets? iii. What are the costs of alternative weed control? iv. Will further reduction on herbicide application effect infrastructure? v. How and where can herbicide use be reduced without damage to infrastructure or increasing public concern?

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Cotham Trial for Glyphosate-Free Weed Treatment: Outcome ReportReport 164 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
Glyphosate final report main appendix April 2017_finalAppendix 1.3 MB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

8 of 31 attended
MH
Councillor Margaret HickmanCommittee Member, present
CJ
Councillor Carole JohnsonVice-Chair, present
SJ
Councillor Steve JonesCommittee Member, present
MM
Councillor Matthew MeliasCommittee Member, present
AN
Councillor Anthony NegusChair, present
JS
Councillor Jo SergeantCommittee Member, present
MT
Councillor Mhairi ThrelfallCommittee Member, apologies
JW
Councillor Jon WellingtonCommittee Member, present
AC
Alison ComleyOfficer, in attendance
DR
Di RobinsonOfficer, expected
BP
Becky PollardOfficer, expected
GD
Gillian DouglasOfficer, expected

All 31 on the meeting page

More from Bristol Communities Scrutiny Commission

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
27 Feb 2024 Community assets update (time allocation: 1 hour)It was agreed that it would be appropriate for the Commission to recommend that, post-May, the relevant new policy co... Agreed Open
14 Sep 2023 Minutes of previous meetingTo confirm the minutes of the meeting of the Communities Scrutiny Commission held on 23 March 2023 as a correct record. Decided Open
14 Sep 2023 Annual business reportRESOLVED : 1. To note the Commission’s terms of reference. 2. To note the appointment of Cllr Martin Fodor as Chair o... Noted Open
14 Sep 2023 Quarterly performance report (Quarter 4 2022-23)RESOLVED : - To note the report and the above update information. Noted Open
23 Mar 2023 Confirmation of ChairIt was agreed that Councillor Henry Michallat would also step down as Vice Chair, with Councillor James Scott to take... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies