16/05680/F and 16/05681/LA - (Land To The East Of) Colston Street - Alterations to boundary wall, new access, development of sui-generis residential units for students ( 2 no. 5-bed cluster flats), with associated refuse and cycle storage
RefusedPlanning1 paper
Planning Committee A refused this item on Wednesday 4 April 2018. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
(2 for and 7 against ) that the application be refused on the grounds; The application proposal would by virtue of its angular form, flat roof design and modern character, appearance, detailing and materials result in an unsympathetic form of development that would overall, fail to preserve ... view the full minutes text for item 56.
Word for word from the decision Bristol published for this meeting.Source: democracy.bristol.gov.uk
The report relates to applications for planning permission 16/05680/F and listed building consent 16/05681/LA on land to the east of Colston Street, directly south of the Grade II* Foster's Almshouses (Three Kings Court). The report discusses the context of the site, the development proposals and the key issues arising. The officer recommendation is for approval subject to a planning agreement and subject to conditions.
The site lies within the St Michaels Hill Conservation Area and within the Central Area Plan boundary. The last use of the site was as gardens for former residents of Foster's Almshouses. The Almshouses were converted to private residential apartments in 2007 and renamed the Three Kings Court. The garden land was subsequently sold to a separate private developer in 2015. The gardens are currently unused and overgrown.
Planning Permission and Listed Building Consent are sought for alterations to the boundary wall, creation of a new pedestrian access from Colston Street and erection of a two storey building, to provide 2 residential units for students (2no. 5-bed cluster flats (sui-generis)) with ornamental garden, refuse and cycle storage.
The application has been referred to Committee by Councillor Smith, on the following grounds -
I have received numerous representations from local residents and businesses opposing the application. My grounds for referral is that the development proposed is inappropriate for the location, adjacent to a significant listed building within a conservation area. Given the significance of the location I feel this should be considered by the planning committee and give local people the opportunity to comment.
Thirty three objections have been received to the proposal from third parties including the Civic Society and the Christmas Steps Arts Quarter Planning scrutiny group. The objections are summarised in the report and include objections to additional student accommodation in the area, harm to the garden setting of the listed building, harm to the Conservation Area and impact on the residential amenity of residents of Three Kings Court (formerly Foster's Almshouses).
No objections have been raised from the Conservation Officer, BCC City Design Team, BCC Arboriculture Officer, BCC Transport Development Management, or BCC Pollution Control. Historic England have not objected to the application but have raised concerns and advised that these should be considered under the assessment. Arup consultants have reviewed the supporting geotechnical information and provided recommendations regarding further information requirements to ensure that land stability issues are suitably addressed and mitigated.
Officers have undertaken assessment of the application and have concluded that on balance, the development is acceptable and in accordance with the development plan. Officers are recommending that members resolve to grant conditional planning permission and listed building consent, subject to completion of a unilateral undertaking securing financial contribution for tree loss.
SITE DESCRIPTION
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
16/05680/F and 16/05681/LA: (Land To The East Of) Colston Street: Alterations to boundary wall, new access, development of sui-generis residential units for students ( 2 no. 5-bed cluster flats), with associated refuse and cycle storageReport
5616/05680/F and 16/05681/LA - (Land To The East Of) Colston Street - Alterations to boundary wall, new access, development of sui-generis residential units for students ( 2 no. 5-bed cluster flats), with associated refuse and cycle storageThis decision
Minutes of the previous meetingRESOLVED (unanimously) – That the minutes of the previous meeting be approved as AMENDED, as a correct record, and si...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.