AI summaryBristol City Council Audit Committee heard public questions on IFRS 16 lease accounting and agreed a written response to a separate question on stock condition surveys.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeAgreedWritten response agreed for one question
Money£10.584 million IFRS 16 adjustmentOver £49,000 extra IFRS 16 audit fees
What happens nextWritten response to followLease detail available on request
Who it affectsCouncil accounts and lease disclosuresPublic access to lease information
What was decided
A written response would be provided on stock condition surveys because the relevant officer was not in attendance.
The Chair responded verbally to a member of the public's questions on IFRS 16 lease accounting, clarifying the materiality figures and the basis for not publishing a full schedule of individual leases. Report P7, P8, P9, P10, P12, P13, P14
Why
The appropriate officer for the stock condition survey question was not present at the meeting.
The Chair explained the £10.584 million adjustment was a balance sheet recognition change for peppercorn leases under IFRS 16, primarily an accounting entry rather than a new cash cost. Report P9, P10
What happens next
A written response will be provided to the stock condition survey question.
Anyone seeking additional lease detail can use the Council's usual information request channels, with disclosure subject to information governance obligations. Report P14, P15
The money
£10.584 million IFRS 16 (2) adjustment to opening balances for peppercorn leases Report P3, P8, P9
£10.244 million Component performance materiality Report P2, P8
£17.68 million Performance materiality for the Council Report P2, P8
£1.357 million Reporting threshold (triviality) Report P4
over £49,000 Delays and additional audit fees on IFRS 16
over £134,000 Other additional audit fees
Options considered
Rejected: Publish a full schedule of individual leases above the reporting threshold. Normal approach is totals and movements, and some lease detail may be sensitive for security or confidentiality reasons Report P12, P13, P14
Chosen: Disclose totals and movements in the Statement of Accounts per the CIPFA Code. Standard practice implementing IFRS 16 disclosure requirements for local authorities Report P13
Implications
Financial: The £10.584 million IFRS 16 adjustment is a balance sheet recognition change for peppercorn leases, not a new cash cost. Report P10
Legal: Any additional lease disclosure must be considered against the Council's information governance obligations, including security and confidentiality. Report P14, P15
Risk: A member of the public raised the IFRS 16 implementation as a red flag in the audit report and flagged possible internal complications applying the standard.
Members of the public seeking lease detail Report P5, P15
Timeline
27 January 2026: Audit Committee meeting, public forum item
Plain English for the jargon
IFRS 16: International Financial Reporting Standard on leases, requiring lessees to recognise most leases on the balance sheet
Peppercorn lease: A lease at a very low or nominal rent
Right of use asset: An asset representing a lessee's right to use an underlying leased asset
Materiality: The significance of an item or error in the financial statements
Performance materiality: A lower level than overall materiality, used by auditors to plan detailed testing
Component performance materiality: Materiality used for group components, reflecting their relative size and risk
Reporting threshold: Threshold for reporting identified misstatements to those charged with governance
CIPFA Code: Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy Code of Practice on Local Authority Accounting
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item7
Resolved
It was agreed that a written response would be provided as an appropriate officer was not in attendance. 2. It looks like BCC were not doing stock condition surveys for a long time. Did BCC ever have arrangements in place for these surveys? It was agreed that a written response would be provided as an appropriate officer was not in attendance. Andrew Bradbury – 1. He understood that for financial statements the normal approach was to disclose totals and movements and not to list every individual contract or asset by name but he did not accept that the situation was different here. The IFRS16 implementation was a red flag in the audit report and sufficient information was not made during the audit. Delays and additional audit fees on this issue alone amounted to over £49,000 alongside other additional audit fees of over £134,000. This was not a normal enforcing situation. It suggested that there were complications internally on how to apply the accounting standard. Was it possible to have the baseline list of leases now deemed to have significant right of use value i.e. a global value in excess of 10 million pounds? The Chair responded that this illustrated how difficult the challenge was as it was the first year this information was needed and had been more difficult than anticipated for officers and GT. The lease information was published as there was a requirement to do so for contract payments. It was not to BCC’s advantage to publish individual lease information due to commercial conflict and other LA’s were probably the same.
Word for word from the decision Bristol published for this meeting.Source: democracy.bristol.gov.uk
Question one I am unsure of the correct figure for Materiality applying to the audit adjustment IFRS16 (2) on page 45 as there appears to be a discrepancy between the figures for Component Performance Materiality on pages 15 and 16 (£10.244M and £17,680,000 respectively) whilst all of the other figures do read across from page 15 to page 16.
Nevertheless, the adjustment to the opening balance of £10.584M (IFRS 16 (2) on page 45) recognising peppercorn leases as right of use assets under IFRS16 is by any measure a substantial one.
Specific leases with new opening balances as a result of this audit which individually exceed the Reporting Threshold (triviality) of £1.357M (page 15) should be in a schedule specifying names and amounts.
Will Audit Committee ensure the availability of the schedule to the public?
Andrew Bradbury
Response. Materiality figures on pages 15 and 16 The two figures you refer to are different measures used for different purposes within the audit approach.
• Page 16 shows performance materiality for the Council of £17.68 million. This is a lower level than overall materiality and is used by the auditor to plan and perform detailed testing across the financial statements. • Page 15 separately shows component performance materiality of £10.244 million. This is used where audit work is performed for group components (subsidiaries or group entities) and reflects their relative size and risk within the group audit. The £10.584 million adjustment for peppercorn leases
The adjustment labelled “IFRS 16 (2)” on page 45 relates to recognising peppercorn lease arrangements as right of use assets at the transition date, in line with the updated lease accounting requirements for local government. It is shown as an adjustment to opening balances.
While £10.584 million is a significant balance sheet movement, it is important to note that it is primarily an accounting recognition and measurement change at transition (that is, bringing arrangements onto the balance sheet), rather than a new cash cost.
OFFICIAL Request for a schedule of individual leases above the reporting threshold
The reporting threshold referred to in the audit report is a threshold for reporting identified misstatements to those charged with governance, not a requirement for publishing lists of individual underlying lease assets.
The Statement of Accounts includes the disclosures required by the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy (CIPFA) Code of Practice on Local Authority Accounting, which implements International Financial Reporting Standard 16 (IFRS 16) disclosure requirements for local authorities. The normal approach is to disclose totals and movements and not to list every individual contract or asset by name.
The Council does not normally publish a full asset by asset schedule of leases as part of the Statement of Accounts. Where additional underlying detail is requested, it may be available on request, but any disclosure would need to be considered against the Council’s information governance obligations. For example, some lease level detail may be sensitive for security reasons or subject to confidentiality or personal data restrictions.
If you would like to request additional detail, you can do so through the Council’s usual information request channels, and the Council will respond in line with the relevant information access legislation and exemptions.
OFFICIAL
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Internal Audit Annual Report 2025/26Decision Notices would be subject to reaudit in the first half of 2026/27. ACTION: Officersto (1)improve accessibilit...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.