Resolved
Decision. The Sub-Committee were mindful of the concerns of local residents, in particular relating to noise nuisance at the premises. They heard from residents that there had been considerable problems there in the past, under the management of previous owners, both in relation to the noise from early morning deliveries and from crime and disorder. The Sub-Committee appreciated that this had been the historic context in which the licence conditions had been imposed. The Sub-Committee considered that the condition relating to the delivery of non-alcohol products may no longer be appropriate as they did not relate to the licensable activities. If this was a shop with no alcohol licence, then they could not impose such conditions, leading them to consider that it was not proportionate or reasonable to continue to do so. In addition, the Sub-Committee heard from an environmental health officer that there are powers available under alternative legislation which enabled the control of statutory noise nuisance. They were mindful of paragraph 2.21 of the current government guidance which states that noise limitation conditions may not be appropriate in certain circumstances where provisions in other legislation adequately protect those living in the area of the premises. The Sub-Committee noted that circumstances at the premises had changed since the imposition of the condition relating to staffing levels was imposed. There had been a reduction in crime and disorder and the shop was now well managed and extensively covered by CCTV. The Sub-Committee therefore concluded that the staffing levels were a management matter and it was therefore reasonable and proportionate that this condition be removed. In relation to the condition stating that any ATM be located inside the premises only, the Sub-Committee was mindful of the concerns of residents that an externally located ATM might give rise to an increase in crime and disorder and public nuisance at the premises. The Sub-Committee, particularly in the absence of any objection from the police, felt that the location of an ATM was not a ... view the full minutes text for item 19.