RESOLVED unanimously that option 1, a direct replacement with an oak framed structure, funded from sources including section 106 contingencies, be approved. Reason The memorial would provide a fitting tribute to those who worked and gave their lives at the site. Options considered and rejected 2. Direct replacement with a steel structure. 3. Ground level interactive art piece.
Word for word from the decision Broxtowe published for this meeting.Source: democracy.broxtowe.gov.uk
Cabinet is asked to CONSIDER the options provided in the Appendix and RESOLVE accordingly.
3. Detail
Brinsley Headstocks operated at Brinsley Colliery a former coal mine, between 1872 and 1934. The twin Headstocks and nearby disused mineral railway track, were all that remained of the once extensive coal mining works, acting as a visual link to the heritage of the site.
In January 2023, a condition report and safety inspection was undertaken on the Headstocks. It identified that the Headstocks were no longer considered capable of safely carrying the load from the winding wheels without intervention. In late November 2023, further deterioration of the wooden structure was identified and concerns were raised by suitably qualified employees, that the structure was at risk of imminent collapse. In the interest of public safety, the Headstocks were dismantled in December 2023.
A report was presented to Cabinet on 12 March 2024, requesting approval for a public consultation to be undertaken regarding potential replacement options for the Headstocks. The proposed questions were approved, and the consultation was undertaken from the 7 to the 31 May 2024. The consultation was conducted using an online platform and paper questionnaires. The latter was distributed across various locations in the Borough.
The options presented for replacement were as follows:
1. Direct replacement with an oak framed structure. 2. Direct replacement with a steel structure. 3. Ground level interactive art piece. 4. Other (detail to be provided).
Findings from the public consultation and feedback captured from the Friends of Brinsley Headstocks focus group are presented in the Appendix. Cabinet 16 July 2024
4. Key Decision
This report will be a key decision as defined under Regulation 8 of the Local Authorities (Executive Arrangements) (Meetings and Access to Information) (England) Regulations 2012. As one of the options for approval could result in the Council incurring capital or revenue expenditure of £250,000 or more.
5. Updates from Scrutiny
Not applicable.
Financial implications
The comments from the Head of Finance Services were as follows:
Members should note that there is currently no budgetary provision for the refurbishment of Brinsley Headstocks. The capital cost of the most popular replacement choice from the consultation is estimated at £220,000. Any capital investment would have to be funded from prudential borrowing unless alternative capital grant funding and/or other third party contributions could be sourced. It has been identified that up to £145,000 of capital contributions may become available. In addition to the cost of borrowing (principal and interest), there would be ongoing revenue budget implications in terms of maintenance and repairs. Further details are provided in the appendix.
Legal implications
The comments from the Monitoring Officer / Head of Legal Services were as follows:
There are no direct legal implications that arise from this report.
8. Human Resources Implications
Not applicable.
7. Union Comments
Not applicable.
8. Climate Change Implications
When considering the climate change implications of replacing the Headstocks, it is important to evaluate the environmental impact of various materials. Opting for a wooden replacement could offer potential ecological benefits due to the woods renewable nature and lower carbon footprint. Responsible sourcing of the wood would be crucial. It should be noted that whilst a wooden replacement would be an environmentally sustainable option, it would require an enhanced and extensive programme of maintenance Cabinet 16 July 2024
9. Data Protection Compliance Implications
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.