AI summaryBroxtowe Cabinet defers decision on cemetery memorial scrutiny recommendations, asking for an equalities impact assessment before the report returns. No money committed at this stage.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeDeferredEqualities assessment delegated to Chief Executive
MoneyNone committedNo budget provision currently available
What happens nextResubmit to Cabinet laterAfter equalities impact assessment is completed
Who it affectsCemetery visitors and staffAcross two or more council wards
What was decided
Cabinet deferred the item to a future meeting rather than approving the Overview and Scrutiny Committee recommendations on cemetery memorials. Report P4
The Interim Chief Executive, working with the Deputy Leader, was asked to prepare an equalities impact assessment before the report is brought back to Cabinet.
Two councillors stepped out for the item: one had declared they were predetermined, the other a non-registerable interest, and the Vice-Chair took the chair.
Why
The original Cabinet asked for a scrutiny review in June 2025, and a task and finish group reported its findings to the Overview and Scrutiny Committee the day before this Cabinet meeting. Report P3, P4
Officers flagged that any changes must comply with health and safety law, the Local Authority Cemeteries Order 1977 and the Council's duty of care, or the authority could face legal claims and higher costs. Report P12, P13, P15, P16
The Section 151 Officer noted no existing budget for the proposed changes to grounds maintenance and management, and that any large spend would need fresh Cabinet approval. Report P9
What happens next
The Interim Chief Executive will produce an equalities impact assessment, in consultation with the Deputy Leader, before the report is resubmitted to Cabinet.
Cabinet Members will receive the Overview and Scrutiny Committee's recommendations at the meeting, as they were only agreed the evening before. Report P4
If costs exceed virement limits, a further Cabinet decision will be needed to fund any changes. Report P9
Options considered
Rejected: Approve the Overview and Scrutiny Committee recommendations. Deferred to allow an equalities impact assessment to be prepared first
Implications
Legal: Any relaxation of rules could leave the Council vicariously liable for claims, and Members must give substantial weight to Officer advice on safety risks. Report P15, P16, P18
Financial: No current budget for the recommended changes; significant sums would need a separate Cabinet decision. Report P9
Staffing: The Union supports the direction but wants clear procedures, training, and enough staff capacity before changes are made. Report P23, P24, P25
Risk: Risk implications for operational changes will need to be identified, assessed and managed to avoid exposing the Council to significant risks. Report P10
Equalities: Officers said no equality impact assessment was required, but Cabinet has asked for one anyway before the report returns. Report P31
Climate: Climate change implications are addressed within the supporting report. Report P27
Who and where
Residents and visitors using council cemeteries across more than one ward Report P7
Council staff and contractors carrying out cemetery maintenance and inspections Report P23, P24
Grave owners and families of those buried in council cemeteries Report P15
Timeline
3 June 2025: Earlier Cabinet deferred the cemetery memorial decision to scrutiny Report P3
26 June 2025: Overview and Scrutiny Committee agreed to a task and finish review Report P3
25 September 2025: Scoping document for the review was agreed Report P3
15 December 2025: Overview and Scrutiny Committee considered the task and finish group's final report Report P4
16 December 2025: Cabinet deferred the item and asked for an equalities impact assessment
Plain English for the jargon
LACO 1977: Local Authority Cemeteries Order 1977, the rules governing how councils manage their cemeteries
HSAW: Health and Safety at Work Act 1974, the main law on workplace safety
Task and finish group: A small group of councillors set up to investigate a specific issue and report back with recommendations
Section 151 Officer: The council officer with legal responsibility for its financial affairs
Virement limits: The maximum amount that can be moved between budget headings without a separate committee decision
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item86
Resolved
RESOLVED that the item be deferred to a future meeting, and the formation of an equalities impact assessment be delegated to the Interim Chief Executive in consultation with the Deputy Leader of the Council prior to the report’s resubmission to Cabinet. (Having declared that he was predetermined Councillor M Radulovic MBE left the meeting before discussion or voting thereon. Councillor G Marshall took the Chair for the item. Having declared that a non-registerable interest Councillor J W McGrath left the meeting before discussion or voting thereon.)
Word for word from the decision Broxtowe published for this meeting.Source: democracy.broxtowe.gov.uk
Cabinet is asked to CONSIDER the recommendations of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, and RESOLVE accordingly.
3. Detail
Cabinet, at its meeting on 3 June 2025, where a report was tabled on the matter, deferred a decision on the clearance of cemetery memorials to this Committee for a scrutiny review. It was decided at the meeting of this Committee on 26 June 2025 that the matter will be reviewed through a task and finish exercise, with the scoping document agreed at the Committee’s meeting of 25 September 2025.
The task and finish group’s final report and recommendations were considered at the meeting of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee that took place on Monday 15 December 2025, where Officers gave their feedback on its recommendations, which were then voted on by the Members of the Committee. The recommendations of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee to Cabinet are presented at this meeting. As the meeting of the Committee took place yesterday evening, they will be distributed to Cabinet Members at the meeting.
The additional documentation considered by the Overview and Scrutiny Committee is also provided in this Cabinet agenda for information.
4. Key decision
This report is a key decision as defined under Regulation 8 of the Local Authorities (Executive Arrangements) (Meetings and Access to Information) (England) Regulations 2012 as it will be significant in terms of its effects on communities living or working in an area comprising two or more Wards or electoral divisions in the Council’s area. Cabinet 16 December 2025
Financial implications
The comments from the Interim Deputy Chief Executive and Section 151 Officer were as follows:
Any recommended actions with a cost implication would have to be contained within existing budgets. There is currently no budget provision to support the recommendation that refers to making available any additional funding necessary to implement changes to cemetery management and grounds maintenance procedures which are required to work around any memorials that will remain under the new rules, such as changes to shift patterns and procurement of new equipment. Any significant budget implications, over and above virement limits, would require specific approval by Cabinet.
The risk implications for any changes to operations will have to be carefully identified, risk assessed and suitably managed in order to mitigate the Council from being exposed to any significant risks.
Legal implications
The comments from the Monitoring Officer / Head of Legal Services were as follows:
The relevant legislation is set out in the report at page 28, whilst there is no statutory duty on the Council to provide burial facilities but where they do then the management is governed by the Local Authority Cemeteries Order (LACO) 1977. The Council’s powers to provide a cemetery derives from the Local Government Act 1972. LACO 1977 gives the Council wide-ranging powers of management to do what is considered necessary or desirable for the management, regulation and control of the cemeteries. The Council also have a legal obligation to keep the cemeteries in good order and repair from a health and safety element whilst maintaining records, plans, issuing deeds, etc.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Response of the Assistant Director of Environment to the group's final report and recommendations, 15/12/2025 Overview and Scrutiny CommitteeAppendix 1
Response of the Head of Health, Safety, Compliance and Emergency Planning on the group's final report and recommendations, 15/12/2025 Overview and Scrutiny CommitteeAppendix 3
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.