Resolved
It was agreed that officers will strengthen representation with regards to the unfounded presumption that land is available and will review the representation being made by Property to ensure consistency. The following points were raised about the Southern Fringe: · There was concern as to whether or not there was a consistent approach in response to Green Belt issues and to rehearse the arguments when there could be perceived inconsistencies. Officers had taken account of the impact on the Green Belt in different locations when considering representations. The proposals for the Southern Fringe are on unbroken arable land and full account has not been taken by the County of the visual impacts of these proposals and the impact on the setting of the City. · Butt Lane has less visual impact and a history of use while green belt land on the southern fringes is highly visible, part of an unbroken green belt and a defensible edge to the City. · The County Council is ignoring its own evidence base on the visual impact. · There is frustration that the County have not looked within the Southern Fringe for a more suitable site and negotiated with developers (i.e. next to the Park and Ride). The County Council could have considered a land swap for free up more appropriate land. · Discussions focused on the merit of having a site near development versus making better use of an existing facility in a less sensitive location. Development as proposed could set a precedent for further development in the Green Belt. · The County Council have not responded to previous representation on the above issues and officers feel it is correct to put them to an inspector. The following points were raised about North Newmarket Road. · It was agreed that a temporary site for construction waste during the development phase would be acceptable. However, permanent provision North of Newmarket Road is not supported – there are considerable access issues with this site, and vehicle movements would be through residential areas which is not acceptable. · A long-term site will be needed but this should be addressed later in the master plan and should focus on land South of Newmarket Road. · The retention of the car showrooms North of Newmarket Road would be a further constraint on the provision of a permanent facility in this location. As such officers were recommending that the area of search should focus on land south of Newmarket Road as this part of the site offers greater opportunities in terms of land availability and more suitable access for vehicular movements likely to be generated by proposals. The Chair suggested revisions to this part of the report to add strength to our support for an area of search south of Newmarket Road, with the positive benefits of the location highlighted.