CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Cambridge City Council
Development Plan Scrutiny Sub-Committee, Tuesday 12 October 2010 at 9.30am

South Cambridgeshire District Council – Orchard Park Design Guidance Supplementary Planning Document (SPD) (Consultation Draft,September 2010)

Agreed Scrutiny 4 papers

Development Plan Scrutiny Sub-Committee agreed this item on Tuesday 12 October 2010. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item10/21DPSSC

Resolved

The City Council’s representation to the Orchard Park Design Guidance SPD consultation. Decision of Exec Cllr for Climate Change and Growth: Agreed: The City Council’s representation to the Orchard Park Design Guidance SPD consultation as set out in Appendix A of the officer’s report - with the following minor additions as discussed: - Funding of acoustic barrier. - Routing of non-residential traffic. - Traffic management provision (CCC Parking Policy) And further consideration of the following: - The need for more emphasis on sufficient green space - The need for more emphasis on a hierarchy of priorities in order to maximise planning gain. - The need for more emphasis on extra ‘identity’ of site uses. - The need for more emphasis on public/community transport. - The need for more emphasis on the process for localism and community involvement. It was agreed that final wording be approved through the Executive Councillor, Chair and Spokes. Reason for the South Cambridgeshire District Council is currently undertaking consultation on their Orchard Park Design Guidance SPD. The consultation commenced on 6 September and runs to 18 October 2010. Any alternative options considered and rejected: N/A Scrutiny Considerations: The Committee received a report from the Urban Extensions Project Manager regarding the City Council’s response to the Orchard Park Design Guidance SPD consultation. With regard to the K1 plot, members asked for more clarity on the proposal for enabled co-operative housing. Officers and the Executive Councillor confirmed that the housing would be built to the highest level of sustainability, with baselines costings and a project management framework put in place to push this forward. It was agreed that officers would forward hard copies of the 2009 Orchard Park Report to Councillors Pogonowski and Saunders. The Planning Project Manager confirmed that, due to the possibility of restrictions on any future developments, Property Services had suggested that the K1 plot be removed from the SPD. This view would obviously be raised in their representation to the consultation. In response to a member’s question regarding the consultation, the Planning Project Manager confirmed that the City Council had been consulted as the landowner, and Councillor Blair had been contacted as the Executive Councillor. However the City Council should also have been formally contacted in its statutory role as a Planning Authority, and this had not happened. Officers confirmed that South Cambridgeshire District Council (SCDC) would be expected to take on board all comments made through the consultation and would respond to every individual representation. With regard to cycle parking provision, the Head of Joint Urban Design agreed with members that all good practice should be taken on board and fed into the SPD. It was also noted that the City Council had developed a comprehensive guide to cycle parking provision, and this could be used to inform debate. With regard to sustainable construction, the Head of Joint Urban Design confirmed that standards were based on the current outline planning approval, which dated back to 2005. It was agreed that ongoing discussions would need to take place with the developers in order to raise expectations regarding sustainable construction. It was agreed that in all aspects of sustainable construction the SPD should push the boundaries as far as possible. Members asked for clarity regarding the principal of residential development in the areas of the site adjacent to the A14. Officers confirmed that the view of the Inspector was that residential development would be acceptable providing the minimum standards regarding noise and air quality could be met. It was also confirmed that the COM 4 section had been fully market tested by Savills and was deemed to be unattractive and not commercially viable for commercial use. The Regional Spatial Strategy had also highlighted the need for extra housing on the edge of Cambridge, and this had informed the decision. With regard to noise barriers, the Head of Joint Urban Design confirmed that trees alone would not form an effective barrier. There would be a need for some kind of solid form but the specific design would be dependant on the proposed A14 improvements. The Executive Councillor expressed concern that the SPD made no reference to how any enhancement to the acoustic barrier would be funded . Officers agreed to strengthen this section in the City Council’s representation. Members raised concern regarding traffic movement, access and circulation around the site. It was felt that there needed to be a stronger emphasis on directing all non-residential traffic away from residential areas. This would be especially important for the Q and HRCC corner plots as the proposed Police Station, comprising of over 200 vehicles and a custody suite, would generate a large increase in traffic. Officers agreed to strengthen this section in the City Council’s representation, and initiate further discussions with the County Council regarding the routing of traffic. The Executive Councillor emphasised the need to make reference to the County Councils new Parking Policy, which allowed for traffic management provision to be put in place prior to any new roads being adopted. Officers agreed to include this within the City Council’s representation. Councillor Herbert had asked that the following points be raised in his absence: - Sufficient green space within the site. - A hierarchy of priorities in order to maximise planning gain. - Extra ‘identity’ for site uses. - Public and community transport. - Process for localism and community involvement. Officers agreed to consider these points within the City Council’s representation. The Scrutiny Committee asked that officers make the relevant additions to the City Council’s representation and seek final approval via the Executive Councillor, the Chair and Spokes. The Executive Councillor for Climate Change and Growth approved this approach. Conflicts of interest declared by the Executive Councillor (and any dispensations granted) N/A
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting. Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Cambridge's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Development Plan Scrutiny Sub-Committee

Summary

1.1South Cambridgeshire District Council is currently undertaking consultation on their Orchard Park Design Guidance SPD. The consultation commenced on 6 September and runs to 18 October 2010. The SPD can be accessed on South Cambridgeshire District Council’s website:

http://www.scambs.gov.uk/Environment/Planning/DistrictPlanning/Loc alDevelopmentFramework/SPDs/orchardparkspd.htm

1.2Appendix A sets out the proposed response to this consultation.

1.3The City Council welcomes the concept of the Design Guidance for the undeveloped plots at Orchard Park. On the whole, the City Council supports the momentum and parameters set out in the document. However, it is considered that the Design Guidance does not at present provide a fully robust and comprehensive document, which will secure the highest quality development at Orchard Park.

1.4The City Council recommends that amendments be made to the document especially in the design principles sections in order to provide a more detailed framework for the development of these sites.

Recommendations

2.1This report is being submitted to the Development Plan Scrutiny Sub- Committee for prior consideration and comment before decision by the Executive Councillor for Climate Change and Growth.

Report Page No: 1 2.2 The Executive Councillor is recommended to agree the City Council’s representations to the Orchard Park Design Guidance SPD consultation as set out in Appendix A.

Background

3.1South Cambridgeshire District Council is currently preparing the Orchard Park Design Guidance SPD as a part of their Local Development Framework (LDF). The purpose of this SPD is to set out the design principles for the remaining land parcels at Orchard Park. South Cambridgeshire District Council (SCDC) expects these principles to be addressed by developers in any planning application in order to ensure the creation of a high quality desirable ‘place’. It is intended that the SPD will provide a clear framework that will assist in the assessment of applications.

3.2The preparation of this document commenced after the adoption of the South Cambridgeshire Site Specific Policies Development Plan Document (DPD) in January 2010.

3.3Development at Orchard Park commenced in 2005, originally from proposals in the South Cambridgeshire Local Plan 2004 for a sustainable 900 dwelling urban extension to Cambridge with employment provision and supporting community facilities and open space. Policy SP/1 of the Site Specific Policies DPD (January 2010) (attached as Appendix B) carried forward the 2004 Local Plan proposals. The Site Specific Policies DPD policy also provides for a change in the mix of development with further residential development in place of some non-residential uses. Known land parcels could provide an additional 220 dwellings on top of the 900 originally planned.

3.4The City Council objected to SCDC’s Site Specific Policies DPD (January 2010) as it was considered that further work needed to be carried out in relation to noise and air quality before the sites at Orchard Park were allocated for development. The City Council was not convinced that a satisfactory residential environment could be achieved, given the sites’ proximity to the A14. The loss of employment land and impact on the surrounding roads were also raised as concerns over the change of use to residential on plots L2, COM4 and Q/HRCC (See Appendix C, Page 7).

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Draft Representations /21DPSSCAppendix A 38 KB Withheld: personal details
PDF
Policy SP1 /21DPSSCAppendix B 118 KB Download
PDF
Orchard Park Design Guidance Draft SPD /21DPSSCAppendix C 24 MB Download
PDF
South Cambridgeshire District Council: Orchard Park Design Guidance Supplementary Planning Document (SPD) (Consultation Draft,September 2010)Supplementary 31 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting
10/19DPSSCMinutesOn the agenda
10/21DPSSCSouth Cambridgeshire District Council – Orchard Park Design Guidance Supplementary Planning Document (SPD) (Consultation Draft,September 2010)This decision

Who was there

4 of 6 attended
TW
Councillor Tim WardChair, present
RZ
Councillor Roman ZnajekVice-Chair, present
LH
Councillor Lewis Herbert Labour SpokesCommittee Member, apologies
AP
Councillor Adam Pogonowski Green SpokesCommittee Member, present
PS
Councillor Paul SaundersCommittee Member, present
DT
Councillor Damien TunnacliffeCommittee Member, expected

On this subject at Cambridge

Search all
  1. South Cambridgeshire District Council – Orchard Park Design Guidance Supplementary Planning Document (SPD) (Consultation Draft,September 2010)This decision
  2. 4 Day Week - Shared Services South Cambridgeshire District CouncilApproved
  3. Update on the Four Day Week Trial Being Carried out by South Cambridgeshire District CouncilApproved
  4. Adopted Cambridge and South Cambridgeshire Local Plans 2018: Five year review of Strategic PoliciesAgreed
  5. Review of the Design Review Service (Design and Conservation Panel in Cambridge City Council and the Design Enabling Panel in South Cambridgeshire District Council)Agreed
  6. Cambridge City Council and South Cambridgeshire District Council - Authority Monitoring Report for Greater Cambridge 2019-2020Agreed

More from Cambridge Development Plan Scrutiny Sub-Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
13 Feb 2018 Grafton Area of Major Change – Masterplan and Framework Supplementary Planning DocumentDecision The draft Cambridge Local Plan 2014: Proposed Submission (as amended) designates the area around Fitzroy Str... Approved Open
13 Feb 2018 Land North of Cherry Hinton Supplementary Planning DocumentDecision The draft Cambridge Local Plan 2014: Proposed Submission (as amended) allocates Land North of Cherry Hinton ... Approved Open
5 Dec 2017 Annual Monitoring Report 2017Decision The Council is required to produce an Annual Monitoring Report (AMR) on at least a yearly basis. The draft A... Agreed Open
12 Sep 2017 Draft Grafton Area of Major Change – Masterplan and Framework Supplementary Planning DocumentDecision The draft Cambridge Local Plan 2014: Proposed Submission (as amended) designated the area around Fitzroy Str... Agreed Open
27 Jul 2017 Draft Land North of Cherry Hinton Supplementary Planning DocumentDecision The draft Cambridge Local Plan 2014: Proposed Submission (as amended) allocated Land North of Cherry Hinton ... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies