Resolved
Resolved (by 6 votes to 1) to accept the officer recommendation and part approve, part refuse planning permission with the amendment that the only part of stackboard 6 to be approved was that facing Newmarket Road. Stackboard 6 facing Evening Court was refused. Refuse consent for the following hoardings and stackboards for the following reasons: Erection of all but the southern 44metres of the hoarding and the 3 stackboards facing Walnut Tree Avenue, and the hoarding and stackboard facing Newmarket Road (all non-illuminated) 1. The proposed 11 hoarding panels which run along the site’s eastern boundary along Walnut Tree Avenue from Midsummer Common up to a point approximately 44 metres from the National Tyre depot; the proposed 18 hoarding panels which run along the northern boundary of the site adjacent with Midsummer Common; the proposed 8.5 hoarding panels which run along the western boundary of the site adjacent to Auckland Road allotments; and the hoardings fronting Evening Court are considered unacceptable because their extensive length, scale and positioning would be unreasonably intrusive in the local townscape and landscape and would therefore have a detrimental impact upon the character and appearance of the locality, in particular Midsummer Common, the Auckland Road allotments and Evening Court, and would not preserve or enhance the Central Conservation Area. For these reasons, these advertisements would be in conflict with policies 3/4, 4/2 and 4/11 of the Cambridge Local Plan 2006, and with PPS5 Planning for the Historic Environment and PPG19 Outdoor Advertisement Control. 2. The proposed positioning of stackboards 4 and 5, adjacent to Midsummer Common is unacceptable because their size, scale and position would make the signs unreasonably intrusive in the local townscape and landscape and would therefore have a detrimental effect on the character and appearance of Midsummer Common and the Conservation Area within which the site is situated. The west-facing element of stackboard 6, that fronting Evening Court, is also unacceptable and would because of its height and dominating presence in what is a relatively narrow street, be detrimental to the visual amenity of the immediate area and of residents of the street. For these reasons, these advertisements would be in conflict with policies 3/4, 4/2 and 4/11 of the Cambridge Local Plan 2006, and with PPS5 Planning for the Historic Environment and PPG19 Outdoor Advertisement Control. Approve Consent for 6 Hoarding panels positioned abutting one another on the eastern boundary of the site, commencing directly adjacent to the National Tyre depot leading down Walnut Tree Avenue towards Midsummer Common approximately 44 metres in length as shown on Plan E5; 5.5 Hoarding panels positioned on the Newmarket Road frontage between the south-west corner of the site adjacent to Evening Court and The Bird in Hand Public House as shown on Plan E8; and stackboards 1, 2 and 3 and the south facing element of stackboard 6, that fronting Newmarket Road, as indicated on Plans H1, E5, E8, E9 and E10, subject to the following conditions: Erection of the southern 44metres of the hoarding and the 3 stackboards facing Walnut Tree Avenue and the hoarding and stackboard facing Newmarket Road (all non-illuminated) 1. The erection of advertisements hereby permitted shall be begun before the expiration of one year from the date of this permission. Reason: In accordance with the requirements of Section 51 of the Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004. 2. The advertisement hoarding panels and stackboards, the subject of this express consent, shall be removed three years from the date of permission or within three months of the final completion of the development, whichever is the sooner. Reason: In accordance with Regulation 13 of the Town and County Planning (Control of Advertisements) Regulations 1992 (as amended). 3. No part of the advertising hoarding or stackboard structure shall overhang or encroach under or upon the public highway. Reason: In the interests of highway safety. Reasons for Approval 1. This development has been partially approved, conditionally, because subject to those requirements it is considered to generally conform to the Development Plan, particularly the following policies: Cambridge Local Plan (2006): 3/4, 4/2, 4/11. The decision has been made having had regard to all other material planning considerations, none of which was considered to have been of such significance as to justify doing other than grant planning permission.