Resolved
To consider the content of the Draft Phase 2 Detailed Water Cycle Strategy for the Major Growth Areas in and around Cambridge and suggest any changes before the report is taken to the Cambridgeshire Horizons’ Board for consideration and sign off. Decision of Exec Cllr for Climate Change and Growth: Considered the content of the Draft Phase 2 Detailed Water Cycle Strategy for the Major Growth Areas in and around Cambridge. Changes as discussed to be agreed with the Chair and Spokes before the report is taken to the Cambridgeshire Horizons’ Board for consideration and sign off. Reason for the I. Cambridgeshire Horizons commissioned a Phase 2 Water Cycle Strategy for the major growth areas in and around Cambridge. Representatives of the City Council have been members of the steering group for this study, along with adjoining local authorities and other stakeholders. II. Water Cycle Strategies (WCS) are examinations of water supply capacity, wastewater infrastructure, surface water drainage and flood risk management. They are undertaken to ensure that new development would be supplied with water services infrastructure in a sustainable way. The Phase 2 Water Cycle strategy built upon the work in the outline Phase 1 (September 2008) which identified no insurmountable technical constraints to the proposed level of growth for the study area. III. The Phase 2 WCS goes further than the Phase 1 study, by providing evidence in support of a more aspirational vision for water management. Any alternative options considered and rejected: N/A Scrutiny Considerations: The Committee received a report from the Senior Planning Officer regarding the Draft Phase 2 Detailed Water Cycle Strategy for the Major Growth Areas in and around Cambridge. The officer briefly outlined the document and invited members to comment. Cllr Blair praised the overall content of the document and said that she thought it was very useful. However, she asked for the Executive Summary (pages 1 to 4) to be re-drafted as the current format assumes ownership of the policy by the City Council. Cambridgeshire Horizons commissioned the strategy but are not the drivers of policy. The report will be used by the City Council as an evidence base to develop our own planning policy following development plan procedures. The text on pages 38 and 39 also uses instructive language more suited to planning guidance documents. Cllr Nimmo-Smith questioned the aspirational language used in the report which would be difficult to defend in planning terms. Cllr Ward supported this view and suggested that developers would choose to ignore requirements such as ‘aspire to’. The Planning Policy Manager stated that the document would be used as an evidence base to develop specific planning policies in the future. Members felt that both this and the previous item, Cambridgeshire and South Cambridgeshire Strategic Flood Risk Assessment, would need to be accompanied by clear guidance to the public to avoid confusion and unnecessary concerns. The officers would redraft the document as suggested and agree the Executive Summary with the Executive Councillor, Chair and Spokes before the proposed changes are sent to Cambridgeshire Horizons. The Scrutiny Committee considered and endorsed the recommendations in the report subject to agreed amendments . The Executive Councillor for Climate Change and Growth agreed the recommendations subject to amendments agreed with the Chair and Spokes. Conflicts of interest declared by the Executive Councillor (and any dispensations granted) N/A