Resolved
Resolved (by 7 votes to 0) to accept the officer recommendation to part approve, part refuse planning permission as per the agenda. Condition 14 has been amended to read as follows: Prior to occupation, a management plan for the student occupation of the building shall be submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority. The plan shall be implemented as agreed and shall continue to be implemented as agreed and shall not be varied without the prior agreement, in writing, of the Local Planning Authority. Reason: In the interests of residential amenity. (Cambridge Local Plan 2006, policy 3/7) INFORMATIVE: The Applicant is advised that in order to discharge condition 14 the applicant will have to provide to the Local Planning Authority detailed information about the management of the 14 rooms and flats including information to address the following matters: (i) The display of contact details of a responsible party who can be contacted in the event of difficulties being experienced on site; (ii) Details of the tenancy agreement between the owners/managers and the occupiers; (iii) An explanation as to how the prohibition on keeping or controlling a car in Cambridge will be enforced for all parties save for a disabled occupier, and details of the mechanism by which any student who is found to be keeping or controlling a car in Cambridge will be sanctioned for a breach of their agreement; (iv) A prohibition on students making an application for or seeking to obtain a residents parking permit; and (v) Annually for the first five years following the date of first occupation of the student accommodation, monitor and review the success of the management scheme and provide to the Council on request details of the results of the annual monitoring and review. The applicant is reminded that the information provided will have to be referred to Committee for discharge of this condition. Reasons for Part Approval and Part Approval Refuse consent for the erection of three four-bedroom houses, for the following reasons: 1. The proposed dwellings, because of their scale and mass and the height and depth of the east and west elevations, would be a dominant and intrusive form in the streetscene of Humberstone Road. For this reason the houses in the development fail to respond positively to their context or to draw inspiration from the key characteristics of their surroundings, would not have a good interrelationship with neighbouring buildings and, instead of having a positive impact on their setting by creating of an attractive built frontage which positively enhances the Conservation Area, would detract from the localtownscape and the Conservation Area. The development is therefore contrary to East of England Plan (2008) policies ENV6 and ENV7 and Cambridge Local Plan (2006) policies 3/1, 3/4, 3/7, 3/12, and 4/11 and advice provided by Planning Policy Statement 1 - Delivering Sustainable Development (2005) and Planning Policy Statement 5 - Planning for the Historic Environment (2010. 2. The proposed dwellings, because of their scale, the placement of the windows in the north elevation and their proximity to the common boundary with the property to the north, 17 Elizabeth Way, would unreasonably enclose and dominate that property and create the potential for an unreasonable degree of overlooking. The development would for these reasons unacceptably detract from the amenity of the occupiers of the neighbouring property and it follows that the proposal has not responded to context or recognised the constraints of the site. The development also fails to provide adequate private amenity space for the proposed 4-bedroom dwellings. The development is therefore contrary to East of England Plan 2008 policy ENV7 and Cambridge Local Plan 2006 policies 3/4 and 3/12 and advice provided by Planning Policy Statement 1 - Delivering Sustainable Development (2005). Reasons for Approval 1. This development has been approved subject to conditions and the prior completion of a section 106 planning obligation (/a unilateral undertaking), because subject to those requirements it is considered to conform to the Development Plan as a whole, particularly the following policies: East of England plan 2008: SS1, ENV6, ENV7; Cambridgeshire and Peterborough Structure Plan 2003: P6/1, P9/8; Cambridge Local Plan (2006): 3/1, 3/4, 3/7, 3/12, 4/11, 5/1, 8/2, 8/6, 8/10; 2. The decision has been made having had regard to all other material planning considerations, none of which was considered to have been of such significance as to justify doing other than grant planning permission. Amendment to condition - t he Planning Committee agreed that the discharge of condition 14 (Management Plan for The Fleur) should come back to Planning Committee. These reasons for approval can be a summary of the reasons for grant of planning permission only. For further details on the decision please see the officer report online at www.cambridge.gov.uk/planningpublicaccess or visit our Customer Service Centre, Mandela House, 4 Regent Street, Cambridge, CB2 1BY between 8am to 6pm Monday to Friday.